Summary#
The Scottish Elections (Representation and Reform) Act 2024 amends laws governing Scottish Parliament and local government elections. It changes rules on candidate eligibility, disqualification, campaign spending, election timing, voter registration and election administration. Its stated goal is to make further provision about eligibility for elected office and reform aspects of election law; that goal is not a guaranteed result.
- Ministers must lay draft rules to disqualify MPs and members of the House of Lords from the Scottish Parliament; they may make rules to disqualify councillors.
- The Act adds disqualifications linked to certain sexual-offence notification requirements and court orders, and creates five-year disqualification orders for some offences aggravated by hostility towards election officials and their staff.
- It gives election officials new powers to postpone some elections or, in specified circumstances, not hold a by-election.
- It restricts certain third-party campaign spending and requires identifying information on some unpaid electronic election material.
- It requires an Access to Elected Office Fund for disabled candidates and gives Ministers powers to fund wider democratic-engagement activities.
- It changes the Electoral Management Board for Scotland from a committee into a body corporate (a legal entity), with staff, budgets and reporting duties.
What it means for you#
- People considering standing for election: The Act changes candidacy rules for foreign nationals, but the supplied material does not establish exactly which people gain or lose eligibility. It also adds disqualifications. A person subject to covered notification requirements or a covered sexual-harm or risk order is generally not disqualified immediately: the Act provides a period of up to three months for appeals. A Scottish court must make a five-year disqualification order after a listed offence aggravated by hostility towards election or registration officials, or counting officers and their staff, unless it would be unjust in the circumstances.
- MPs, peers and councillors: Ministers must lay draft regulations to disqualify MPs and House of Lords members from the Scottish Parliament. Ministers may make regulations to disqualify councillors from the Scottish Parliament. The Act does not itself set out those new disqualifications in full; the regulations would do so.
- People campaigning in elections: During a Scottish Parliament election regulated period, certain third parties may not incur controlled campaign expenditure unless they are in a category eligible to give notice under existing law. Expenses totalling no more than £700 are exempt from this restriction. Some unpaid electronic campaign material published by a relevant third party must identify the promoter and any person it is published for. Exceptions include paid advertisements and qualifying journalism.
- Voters and election candidates: Election officials may postpone some elections. In specified cases, a Scottish Parliament or council by-election may be put off or not held, leaving the seat vacant until a later election. Ministers must maintain a fund to support disabled candidates’ election-related costs that are reasonably attributable to their impairment.
- Election administrators: The Electoral Management Board can employ staff and must prepare budgets and plans. The Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body must pay its properly incurred expenses covered by an approved budget.
- General public: Ministers may fund activities intended to increase democratic engagement, including automatic voter registration at educational establishments. The Act does not require Ministers to fund any particular activity.
Money#
The Act requires the Electoral Management Board’s properly incurred, budgeted expenses to be paid, but no overall cost estimate is available.
- Ministers may provide grants, loans, guarantees or indemnities for democratic-engagement activities; the Act sets no amount.
- Ministers must maintain the Access to Elected Office Fund and set rules for payments. They may decide how much to pay into it. An existing administrative fund may fulfil this duty.
- The Board may appoint and pay staff, subject to approval of their terms and conditions. No staffing level or cost is given.
- No publicly available information.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the parent Acts’ full current text, so it is not possible to verify all changes against the law immediately before this Act. In particular, the precise practical effect of the changes to foreign-national candidacy rules cannot be confirmed from the supplied text alone.
- The Act does not set out the detailed rules for the required MP and peer disqualifications; Ministers must provide these in regulations.
- It does not set a budget for the Access to Elected Office Fund or say how much democratic-engagement funding will be provided.
- The Act gives powers to postpone elections “for any reason” where the stated tests apply, but does not provide a detailed list of reasons or a general appeal process.
- Most provisions start on dates appointed by Ministers. The supplied material does not say which provisions have started.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the Act is that it gives election officials options to respond to disruption while requiring consultation and public reasons for many postponement decisions.
- Disqualification rules could prevent people covered by specified court orders or convictions from holding elected office, while the appeal period and the exception for unjust cases limit some effects.
- Spending rules and electronic-material notices could help identify who is behind some election campaigning and clarify which spending is controlled.
- The disabled-candidate fund and voter-registration pilots could help address barriers to taking part in elections. The Act requires evaluation of registration pilots before Ministers can make similar rules permanent.
Case against#
- The Act gives officials broad discretion to postpone elections, and in some cases to cancel by-elections. A vacancy may therefore last longer, or remain until the next ordinary election.
- The disqualification rules can remove a person’s ability to stand for office based on covered orders or requirements; the Act’s three-month appeal arrangements do not resolve every case immediately.
- The new rules depend on later regulations, funding decisions and administrative arrangements. The Act gives no cost estimates or detailed funding plans.
- Campaign-material rules may be difficult to apply where material’s electoral purpose is not explicit. The Act requires Electoral Commission guidance, but the detailed guidance is not included in the supplied material.