Summary#
The Disability Commissioner (Scotland) Bill is a Member’s Bill that would have established a new, independent office: the Disability Commissioner for Scotland. Its stated short title is the Disability Commissioner (Scotland) Act 2024; it does not amend an existing Act. Its goal is to promote and safeguard disabled people’s rights, but the bill was withdrawn and did not create the office.
- The Commissioner would promote awareness and best practice, review relevant law, policy and practice, and promote, commission, undertake and publish research.
- The Commissioner would have to involve disabled people, pay particular attention to people who may find it harder to express their views, and make reports accessible in a range of formats so far as practicable.
- The Commissioner could investigate service providers’ regard for disabled people’s rights, interests and views. General investigations would need to concern an issue of particular significance; individual investigations would concern a decision or action affecting a disabled person.
- The Commissioner could require evidence and relevant documents. Refusing or failing to comply without a reasonable excuse, or deliberately altering, hiding or destroying required documents, could be a criminal offence punishable by a fine or up to three months’ imprisonment.
- The Commissioner could recommend action and require a written response, but could not require a person to follow a recommendation. The Commissioner would be appointed on the Scottish Parliament’s nomination and would generally be independent of Ministers and Parliament.
What it means for you#
- Disabled people: The Commissioner would have to consult disabled people and organisations working with and for them. You would not gain a new individual right to a particular service or benefit under this bill. The bill does not set up a guaranteed complaint or investigation process for each person.
- Service providers: The Commissioner could investigate how a provider considered disabled people’s rights, interests and views when making decisions or taking actions affecting them. General investigations would normally be public; individual investigations would be private. The bill excludes people providing services because of family, community, neighbourhood or friendship ties rather than principally for payment or as part of employment.
- People asked to give evidence or provide documents: The Commissioner could require this for an investigation, subject to legal privileges and limits on what the Scottish Parliament could require. Offences could also apply to responsible officers of a body or partnership in specified circumstances.
- Public bodies and Parliament: The Commissioner would have to report annually and prepare a four-year strategic plan with objectives, a timetable and cost estimates. A report on a general investigation would have to be laid before the Scottish Parliament; one on an individual investigation could be.
- Taxpayers: The bill would create an office that needs a budget, staff and resources, but does not set a total budget or staff number.
Money#
No publicly available information.
- The bill would require the Commissioner to prepare a budget for approval by the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body. The Commissioner would have to use resources economically, efficiently and effectively.
- The Corporate Body could pay the Commissioner and could approve staff numbers; it would also have to indemnify the Commissioner for liabilities incurred in carrying out the role. The bill gives no cost estimate.
- The Commissioner could charge reasonable sums for things done or provided and retain those sums to meet related expenditure.
- If enacted, most provisions would start six months after Royal Assent. Because the bill was withdrawn, that start date did not take effect.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set out how people could raise concerns, how cases would be selected, or timelines for investigations.
- It leaves terms such as “particular significance” and “reasonable steps” open to interpretation.
- It does not say how the Commissioner’s work would fit with other people or bodies that investigate similar matters, beyond restricting investigations that properly belong to another person unless the Commissioner consults them and considers it more effective or expedient to investigate.
- The bill does not require a person to carry out a recommendation. It does not specify further consequences for failing to do so; where a response is required, the Commissioner could publish or publicise the response or non-compliance in the circumstances set out in the bill.
- The available material mentions a Financial Memorandum but does not provide its contents, so the proposed office’s estimated cost is not available here.
Case for#
- An independent office could focus on disability rights across law, policy and service practice, rather than on a single service or decision.
- Its duties to consult disabled people and make information accessible could help the Commissioner hear from people whose views are harder to communicate or convey.
- Investigations, published findings and recommendations could draw attention to patterns affecting disabled people and prompt public responses.
- Research and promotion of best practice could add evidence and guidance for service providers.
Case against#
- The Commissioner could require evidence and documents, with criminal penalties for some failures to comply. The bill creates these powers but does not set out a general process for reviewing or appealing an investigation decision.
- The Commissioner could make recommendations without being able to require the person investigated to act on them.
- Key investigation tests are open to judgment, and the bill does not set out case-selection rules or deadlines.
- The bill would establish an office with staffing and budget needs, but the available material does not provide its expected cost.