Post Office (Horizon System) Offences (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Post Office (Horizon System) Offences (Scotland) Act 2024 is a new Scottish law. It automatically quashes certain Scottish convictions and requires deletion of records of certain alternatives to prosecution; it also amends the Criminal Justice Act 1988 so the quashed convictions count for one part of its compensation rules. Its stated goal is to address convictions for dishonesty connected to post office businesses while the Horizon system was in use.

  • A conviction is covered if it relates to embezzlement, fraud, theft, uttering, or an offence linked to one of those offences; the alleged offence was between 23 September 1996 and 31 December 2018; the person ran or worked in a post office business; and Horizon was in use for that business at the relevant time.
  • Covered convictions are quashed automatically when the Act comes into force. The definition of “conviction” also includes certain findings in criminal proceedings.
  • Scottish Ministers must take reasonable steps to identify quashed convictions, notify the convicting court and affected people or, where appropriate, their personal representatives. Courts must replace the conviction record with a record that it was quashed.
  • Ministers must direct Police Scotland to delete criminal-history database details of qualifying warnings, offers, work orders and other alternatives to prosecution.
  • Ministers may require people who hold information they consider necessary to provide it. They must also publish a report on the Act’s operation after one year.

What it means for you#

  • People convicted of a covered offence: The conviction is quashed by the Act, without an individual application being required. The law does not quash every conviction connected to a post office; the offence, time period, work connection and Horizon-use conditions must all be met.
  • People given an alternative to prosecution: If Ministers consider that a qualifying alternative was given for a relevant offence, they must direct Police Scotland to delete its details from the specified criminal-history database and take reasonable steps to notify the person or an appropriate representative.
  • People seeking compensation: A quashed conviction is treated as if the High Court quashed it on the person’s appeal. The Act also includes it in a reference to convictions quashed on an out-of-time appeal in the Criminal Justice Act 1988. This does not itself guarantee compensation.
  • Scottish Ministers, Police Scotland and courts: Ministers must identify and notify cases and direct deletion of qualifying records. Police Scotland must delete them after a direction; courts must update conviction records after notification.

Money#

No cost estimate is included in the supplied material.

  • The Act requires work by Scottish Ministers, Police Scotland and courts, but gives no staffing or cost figures.
  • It allows Ministers to require information from people who hold information they consider necessary.
  • The Act may make covered convictions relevant to compensation under the Criminal Justice Act 1988, but it does not set out a compensation amount or guarantee payment.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not give the Royal Assent date, so it does not establish the calendar date the Act came into force.
  • It does not set out how Ministers will identify cases, decide whether an alternative to prosecution qualifies, or handle disputed cases.
  • It does not specify how long notification and record updates may take beyond requiring them as soon as reasonably practicable.
  • The report must cover conviction notifications and identification steps, but the Act does not require it to report on deletion of alternatives to prosecution.
  • The current text of the Criminal Justice Act 1988 and the other laws it refers to was not supplied, so the full effect on existing rules and compensation eligibility cannot be checked here.

Case for#

  • The Act can quash qualifying convictions without requiring each affected person to pursue an individual appeal.
  • It also addresses qualifying alternatives to prosecution by requiring deletion of their details from the specified police database.
  • Treating quashed convictions as if they were quashed on appeal may allow the compensation rules to apply to them, subject to those rules.
  • The Act requires Ministers to identify cases, notify people and courts, and report to Parliament on its operation.

Case against#

  • The Act quashes convictions based on set criteria, not an individual reassessment of the evidence in each case. A possible concern is that the criteria may not reflect the circumstances of every case.
  • Identification depends on Ministers taking reasonable steps. The Act does not set a deadline for completing the work or a detailed process for resolving claims that a case was missed.
  • It is unclear how decisions about qualifying alternatives to prosecution will be made or challenged.
  • The Act requires public bodies to do work but gives no cost or staffing estimate.