Summary#
The Right to Addiction Recovery (Scotland) Bill is a Member’s Bill that would create a new Act; it does not formally amend the National Health Service (Scotland) Act 1978, but says treatment under the Bill is to count as a service under that Act. Its stated goal is to give people diagnosed with drug or alcohol addiction a right to a treatment decision and to the treatment selected for them. The Bill has fallen and is not law.
- A person diagnosed by a relevant health professional would have a right to a treatment determination and to the treatment chosen as appropriate by that professional.
- The professional would have to explain the listed options—residential or community rehabilitation, residential or community detoxification, stabilisation, substitute prescribing and any other suitable treatment—and involve the patient in an in-person decision meeting.
- Patients could ask for one or more listed treatments. The professional would have to consider each request; if no treatment or a requested treatment were judged inappropriate, the patient would get written reasons and a right to one second professional’s determination.
- The chosen treatment would have to be made available as soon as reasonably practicable, and no later than three weeks after the determination. It could not be refused for the listed reasons, including cost, substance-misuse history, criminal-justice involvement, mental-illness history, or existing opioid-replacement or substitute-prescribing treatment. A professional’s assessment of the patient’s best interests is the stated exception.
- Scottish Ministers would have to secure delivery, lay draft regulations setting out delivery arrangements, issue a code of practice and publish yearly progress reports. Regulations could give functions to Health Boards, Special Health Boards, the Agency, local authorities or integration joint boards.
What it means for you#
- People diagnosed with addiction: If the relevant provisions were brought into force, you would have the rights described above. A second professional would have to make their own determination, but the Bill does not give a further statutory right to another second opinion.
- Health professionals: Medical practitioners, nurse independent prescribers and pharmacist independent prescribers would make treatment determinations and follow the required decision procedure.
- Health and local public bodies: The named bodies would have to follow the code of practice. Ministers could propose giving them functions through regulations; the Bill does not itself set out each body’s delivery role.
- Other members of the public: The Bill does not directly change tax, criminal penalties or treatment for people without the specified diagnosis.
Money#
The supplied material gives no cost estimate; it names a Financial Memorandum, but does not include its contents.
- Ministers would have to secure delivery, and treatment could not be refused solely because of its cost. The Bill does not state a budget, staffing level or funding allocation.
- The Bill requires treatment to be provided within the stated time limit, but gives no estimate of the resulting public or provider costs.
What is unclear#
- The Bill does not define “addiction” or “best interests,” or set out residency or other eligibility rules.
- It does not specify how patients access services, how capacity shortages are handled, or what remedy applies if a right or deadline is not met.
- The core rights and treatment duties would start on a date set later by Scottish Ministers. The Bill does not set that date.
- The Bill allows regulations to add treatments and to add reasons that cannot be used to refuse treatment. Their eventual content is not in the Bill.
- The current law and the 1978 Act’s relevant provisions were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify how much of the proposed right would be new or how it would interact with existing services.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the Bill is that a legal right could make access to addiction treatment less dependent on a person’s circumstances or on cost being used as a reason to refuse treatment.
- Requiring clinicians to explain options, hear patients’ views and give written reasons could make decisions clearer and give patients a way to seek a second professional determination.
- The three-week limit and public reporting requirements could make delays and delivery gaps more visible.
Case against#
- One concern is that the Bill sets a treatment deadline and limits reasons for refusal without specifying the funding, staff or service capacity needed to meet those duties.
- It is unclear how the broad treatment choices and the “best interests” exception would be applied consistently across areas.
- The Bill does not set out a clear enforcement or remedy process if treatment is late or not provided, despite creating legal rights and duties.