Summary#
The Schools (Residential Outdoor Education) (Scotland) Act 2024 amends the Education (Scotland) Act 1980. Its goal is to make residential outdoor education available to pupils in public and grant-aided schools; it does not guarantee that every pupil will take part.
- Education authorities and grant-aided school managers must, so far as reasonably practicable, provide or arrange one course for each pupil. A course must include at least five days and four overnight stays, which may be non-consecutive, and be suitable for the pupil.
- Pupils’ participation is voluntary. Authorities and grant-aided school managers may require parents to contribute an amount they consider appropriate.
- Scottish Ministers must publish guidance on matters including course standards, access, costs, parental contributions, year groups, Gaelic-medium provision and support for pupils with additional support needs. Schools and authorities must have regard to the guidance.
- Ministers must report on provision after a five-year reporting period, including compliance, equality of access, pupil outcomes and effects on the education workforce.
- When making certain decisions about pupils attending independent schools, education authorities must consider how far those schools provide residential outdoor education. The bill does not impose the same course-provision duty on independent schools.
What it means for you#
- Pupils in public and grant-aided schools: Their school or education authority must arrange a suitable course for them, so far as reasonably practicable. Pupils are not required to attend.
- Parents and carers: A school or authority may ask you to contribute financially. The bill sets no maximum amount or means test, but the guidance must address contributions and equality of access.
- Pupils with additional support needs: Courses must be suitable for their needs. Guidance must cover support for participation, and the later report must assess access for these pupils.
- Independent-school pupils and families: The bill does not require independent schools to provide a course. Authorities must consider the extent of provision when making certain existing decisions involving independent schools. The parent Act was not supplied, so I could not verify the full scope of those decisions against current law.
- Schools, authorities and staff: They would have new provision duties, and authorities and grant-aided school managers would have to follow the Ministers’ guidance. The bill does not set out an application or approval process for pupils.
Money#
No cost estimate or funding amount is included in the available material.
- Authorities and grant-aided schools must provide or arrange courses, but only so far as reasonably practicable. The bill does not specify how much this will cost or how many staff may be needed.
- Parents may be asked to contribute. The bill does not set an amount or say that contributions must cover the full cost.
- Ministers’ guidance must address reasonable costs and possible funding sources, including self-directed support. The bill does not itself provide that funding.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not define “reasonably practicable” or “residential outdoor education” beyond the minimum course features it lists.
- It leaves year groups to be addressed in guidance, rather than naming which pupils must receive a course in which school years.
- The bill does not specify how schools should decide what parental contribution is appropriate or what happens if a family cannot pay.
- The start date for the main duties depends on regulations. Ministers must make those regulations no later than 30 September 2027; the supplied material does not give a specific start date.
- The supplied text says guidance is due within three months of the main provisions coming into force, but does not say what resources will be available to prepare it or deliver the duties.
Case for#
- The bill creates a duty to make a qualifying course available, rather than leaving provision entirely to local choice.
- Requiring courses to suit each pupil’s age, ability, aptitude and additional support needs could help make provision more appropriate.
- Guidance on costs, financial contributions and access could help schools and authorities consider how to support participation.
- Reporting on access, outcomes and workforce effects would give Parliament and the public information about how the duties are working.
Case against#
- The duty is limited by “so far as reasonably practicable,” and the bill does not define that limit. Provision may therefore vary.
- Schools and authorities may ask parents to contribute an amount they consider appropriate. The guidance must address equality of access, but the bill does not set a cap or require a particular approach for families who cannot pay.
- The bill creates duties without specifying funding or staffing, so meeting them could put pressure on school and authority resources.
- The bill requires provision, but does not require pupils to attend. The course duty alone therefore does not ensure that every pupil experiences residential outdoor education.