Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Climate Change (Emissions Reduction Targets) (Scotland) Act 2024 amends the Climate Change (Scotland) Act 2009. It replaces annual and interim emissions-reduction targets with targets based on Scottish carbon budgets; its stated purpose is to change how greenhouse-gas reduction targets are set. The supplied material says the Act comes into force the day after Royal Assent, but does not give the date of Royal Assent.

  • Scottish Ministers must set five-year carbon budgets, covering every year from 2026 to the net-zero target year, and must ensure each budget target is met. The budgets are set by regulations that require Parliament’s approval.
  • Ministers must consider the target-setting criteria and the latest advice from the relevant body when preparing budget regulations. If they set a budget that differs from that advice, they must explain why.
  • Ministers must continue to report on emissions each year and report whether each carbon-budget target was met after its budget period.
  • The Act adds requirements for climate change plans, including a public consultation lasting at least six months and measurable estimates of how policies are expected to contribute to targets.
  • Climate change plans must set out proposals for assessing how major capital projects affect budget targets. The Act does not itself define which projects count; the plan is to define them.

What it means for you#

  • People and organisations taking part in climate-plan consultations: Ministers must consult the public when preparing a climate change plan. Before consulting, they must tell Parliament how they plan to consult, how they will alert interested people, and how long the consultation will run. It must last at least six months.
  • Taxpayers and the public: The Act does not directly create a tax, fee, benefit, or individual emissions-reduction duty. Its main changes are duties on Scottish Ministers and new requirements for climate planning and reporting.
  • Scottish Parliament: It must approve the regulations setting carbon budgets. Ministers must also respond within three months to relevant parliamentary reports or resolutions on draft climate change plans.
  • For current-law comparison: The supplied material shows the changes to the 2009 Act, but not the full Act as it stood before amendment. I could not verify the complete previous legal position.

Money#

No publicly available information on the Act’s cost is in the supplied material.

  • The Act requires consultations, plans, assessments and reports, but gives no cost estimate or staffing figure.
  • The regulations setting carbon budgets are to be approved by Parliament; the text provides no budget amounts because those are to be set later.

What is unclear#

  • The carbon-budget levels are not set in this Act; they will be set in later regulations.
  • The supplied material does not identify the “relevant body” whose advice Ministers must consider, or provide the full 2009 Act definitions and rules.
  • The Act does not set out the policies that will meet the budgets. Those are to be developed through climate change plans.
  • The plan will define “major capital projects”; the Act does not specify which projects will be included.
  • The material does not give the expected cost of the new planning, consultation and reporting duties.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the change is that multi-year budgets give a longer period for measuring emissions reductions than annual targets.
  • The system keeps annual emissions reporting while also requiring a report on whether each budget target was met.
  • Requiring Ministers to consider expert advice and explain departures from it could make target-setting more transparent.
  • Public consultation, measurable policy contributions and reporting on major projects could make climate plans more open to scrutiny.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the Act sets up the system but does not set the carbon-budget levels or say which policies will meet them. Those important choices come later.
  • Ministers have a duty to ensure each budget target is met, but the Act does not specify the policies or enforcement steps that will secure that result.
  • Five-year targets may give less direct focus to whether emissions are on track in each individual year, even though annual reporting continues.
  • The Act requires new planning and reporting work, but the supplied material gives no estimate of its cost.