Prisoners (Early Release) (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Prisoners (Early Release) (Scotland) Bill is a Government Bill that has received Royal Assent and is now the Prisoners (Early Release) (Scotland) Act 2025. It amends the Prisoners and Criminal Proceedings (Scotland) Act 1993 and the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995. Its stated purpose is to change the rules for automatic early release; the main provisions start on a date set by Scottish Ministers, and no date is given in the supplied material.

  • Most short-term prisoners would become entitled to automatic release after serving two-fifths of their sentence, rather than one-half.
  • Prisoners serving sentences for specified sexual offences or domestic abuse offences would remain subject to release after one-half of the sentence.
  • Similar two-fifths and one-half thresholds would apply to children detained under the relevant court powers. Fine defaulters would become eligible for release after two-fifths rather than one-half of the period.
  • Scottish Ministers could change release timing by regulations. They must consult named public bodies and victim-support providers, and make a statement to Parliament about their reasons, consultation and victim information.
  • Ministers could make decisions about how certain people transferred to Scotland from outside the UK are treated for release purposes. The Act also requires a report on its operation after a two-year review period.

What it means for you#

  • Prisoners and detained children: If the new rules apply to your sentence, the release point would generally be two-fifths rather than one-half. The listed sexual offences and domestic abuse offences remain at one-half. For short-term prisoners, release is unconditional unless an extended sentence or supervised release order applies.
  • People affected by a prisoner’s release: Ministers must say what information will be available to victims about a proposed change to release timing and releases under it. The Act does not set out a full victim-notification process.
  • Prisoners whose release date moves earlier: The Act provides for some releases to happen in phased periods after commencement. A person cannot, under that arrangement, be released later than their original release date.
  • The public: This changes release timing rules; it does not itself create a new prison service or a new benefit. Ministers can later propose further changes, but regulations changing the timing need Parliament’s approval.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The Act gives Ministers powers to make regulations and requires a report, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate or staffing figure.
  • It does not set a fee, fine, tax or specific spending amount.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material gives no commencement date for the main provisions.
  • The existing Acts being amended were not supplied, so the full current law and how much of the final wording carries forward existing rules could not be checked.
  • The Act does not set detailed rules for Ministers’ decisions about transferred prisoners; it allows further rules to be made by regulations.
  • The exact practical arrangements for phased releases depend on when the provisions start and which release-date group a prisoner falls into.
  • The report must include specified prison-population and release data, but the Act does not require an assessment of the effects of the changes on reoffending or public safety.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it sets an earlier automatic release point for most short-term prisoners, while keeping a later point for the specified sexual and domestic abuse offences.
  • Ministers would have a way to adjust release timing through regulations if they consider a different point necessary. The power comes with required consultation and parliamentary approval.
  • The required report could give Parliament and the public information about prison numbers and people released under the changes.

Case against#

  • Earlier automatic release means most affected short-term prisoners would spend a smaller share of their sentence in prison. The Act does not make release depend on an individual risk assessment.
  • The Act lets Ministers change release timing, including for some people already serving a sentence or on licence. Consultation and Parliament’s approval are required, but the Act does not set limits on the possible timing changes.
  • The Act requires information about releases and prison numbers, but does not require the report to measure reoffending or other effects that could help judge the policy’s results.