Scottish Parliament (Recall of Members) Bill

Summary#

The Scottish Parliament (Recall of Members) Bill is a Member’s Bill that would create recall processes and amend the Scotland Act 1998 and the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000. Its stated goal is to provide for the recall and removal of MSPs. The supplied material says the Bill has fallen, so it is not law and would not change the rules unless enacted.

  • An MSP could face a recall process after Parliament imposed a qualifying sanction for exclusion from Parliament’s proceedings or premises, or after a qualifying conviction and prison or detention sentence or order.
  • For a constituency MSP, the returning officer would have to run a petition. The MSP would be recalled if at least 10% of those entitled to sign validly signed it.
  • For a regional MSP, the returning officer would have to run a poll. The MSP would be recalled if a majority of votes cast were for recall; the Bill sets no minimum turnout.
  • A successful recall would make the MSP’s seat vacant. It would not stop that person standing in future Scottish Parliament elections.
  • The Bill would require the Electoral Commission to report on completed recall processes and allow accredited observers to observe the counting of signatures or votes.
  • Scottish Ministers would have to review, within 18 months of Royal Assent, whether to introduce legislation about removing MSPs barred from regulated roles with children or adults.

What it means for you#

  • MSPs: A recall process could start if Parliament sanctioned an MSP for exclusion for at least 10 sitting days, or at least 14 days if the period is not expressed in sitting days. It could also start after an MSP was convicted of an offence and sentenced or ordered to imprisonment or detention, including a suspended sentence or order, once the appeal period had ended without the conviction or sentence being materially overturned. The offence could have been committed before the person became an MSP.
  • Constituency electors: Eligible people could sign in person, by post or by proxy during a 20-working-day period. The Bill would also allow someone under 16 to sign if they turned 16 before that period ended and otherwise met the voting conditions. A valid signature could not be withdrawn.
  • Regional electors: People entitled to vote in an election in any constituency within the MSP’s region could vote for or against recall, in person, by post or by proxy.
  • People signing or voting: Signing the same petition more than once, or certain knowing acts of signing both personally and by proxy, would be offences. A court would have to impose an electoral-restrictions order after conviction unless it found that inappropriate. By default, the order would last three years and restrict voting and standing for specified Scottish Parliament and local elections; the court could shorten or limit it.
  • Returning officers, the Presiding Officer, courts and Scottish Ministers: The Bill would assign them duties to run or support processes, pass on relevant information, make regulations or conduct the required review. It would not create a separate recall agency.
  • The Bill does not make recall automatic after a sanction or conviction: the specified petition or poll must still meet its success test.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • Returning officers would have duties to arrange petitions or polls, but no staffing or cost estimate is given.
  • Regulations could set detailed rules for running processes and campaigning, including campaign-spending limits and reporting requirements. The Bill gives no figures for those limits or resulting costs.
  • The Bill sets a maximum fine for double-signing offences at level 5 on the standard scale, but the supplied material gives no cash amount.

What is unclear#

  • The Bill leaves many practical rules to later regulations, including detailed procedures for signing and voting, postal and proxy arrangements, and how irregularities would be handled.
  • The Bill would allow later regulations to create offences and rules for campaign spending, but does not set out those detailed rules itself.
  • The supplied material does not include the current text of the Scotland Act 1998 or the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000. I could not verify against current law what provisions or processes already exist beyond the amendments printed in the Bill.
  • The Bill does not set a start date for most of its provisions. Scottish Ministers would set that date by regulations if the Bill became law.
  • No details are given on how the required review of MSPs barred from regulated roles would be carried out beyond its deadline and publication requirements.

Case for#

  • The Bill appears intended to provide a way for voters to remove an MSP after serious parliamentary sanctions or a qualifying conviction and prison or detention sentence.
  • A constituency petition and a regional vote give the two types of MSP different recall tests. The petition requires support from at least 10% of eligible signers; the poll requires a majority of votes cast.
  • The Bill sets out notice, timing and accessibility duties, and requires the Electoral Commission to report on each completed process.
  • The Bill preserves a recalled person’s eligibility to stand in future elections, rather than imposing a permanent ban just because of recall.

Case against#

  • A recall process could end an MSP’s seat, but the Bill does not set a minimum turnout for a regional poll. A majority of votes cast could therefore decide the result even if few eligible voters took part.
  • Important rules, including campaign-spending rules and much of the process, would be left to later regulations. The Bill itself does not show the final protections or limits.
  • Running petitions and polls would require work by returning officers and other public bodies, but the available material gives no cost estimate.
  • The default electoral-restrictions order for double-signing offences could restrict voting and standing for elected office for three years, as well as affect an office the person already holds. The court could make it shorter or narrower, but the Bill makes an order the default after conviction.