Summary#
The Dog Theft (Scotland) Bill is a Member’s Bill that creates the Dog Theft (Scotland) Act 2025; it does not amend a main existing Act. Its stated goal is to create a specific offence of dog theft, add an aggravation for theft of a helper dog, and publish information about the offence. The main provisions start on a date set by Scottish Ministers; the text gives no date.
- Taking a dog from someone’s lawful control, or keeping it from someone entitled to lawful control, would be an offence. The offence also covers causing or inducing a dog to go with someone or stay with someone.
- A person has a defence if they show lawful authority or a reasonable excuse. A separate defence applies in some cases involving a dog believed to be stray, lost or abandoned, if the person takes required steps and does not keep it beyond the stated time limit.
- The offence is aggravated if the dog is an assistance dog or another category Scottish Ministers add by regulations. Courts must record and consider the aggravation when sentencing.
- Scottish Ministers must publish a report on the Act after a three-year reporting period. Police, courts and the Lord Advocate must provide requested information for it.
What it means for you#
- Dog owners and people caring for dogs: If the Act’s main provisions come into force, taking or keeping a dog from someone with lawful control could lead to prosecution. This does not mean every dispute about a dog automatically becomes an offence: the Act includes defences and a specific exception for some former household members.
- People who find or take in a dog: The stray-dog defence requires a belief that the dog was stray, lost or abandoned, reasonable steps to comply with the cited law, and keeping the dog for no more than 96 hours, subject to the stated exception.
- Assistance-dog users: Theft of an assistance dog would be a statutory aggravation, which courts must take into account in sentencing. The Act does not guarantee a particular sentence.
- Police, courts and Scottish Ministers: Police must provide requested information for the report; the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service and Lord Advocate must do so too. Ministers must publish and present the report to Parliament.
- General public: The offence carries a maximum of 12 months’ imprisonment or a fine up to the prescribed amount, or both, on summary conviction; on conviction on indictment, up to five years’ imprisonment or a fine, or both. The available material does not include current law for comparison, so it does not establish how much this changes existing treatment of dog theft.
Money#
No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.
- Police, the courts and the Lord Advocate must provide information in the form and by the time Ministers require. The bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- Ministers may make regulations to add categories of helper dogs and to make supporting provisions. No cost or funding is specified.
What is unclear#
- The text does not define “lawful control” or “reasonable excuse,” or set out how those terms should be applied.
- The bill sets the reporting period at three years and requires a report after it ends. Despite the contents heading “Annual reports,” the operative text does not clearly require reports every year or repeated reports.
- Ministers set the start date for the main provisions, but the bill gives no date.
- The text does not set out an intake, investigation or appeal process specific to the offence.
- It is unclear how the new offence will interact with existing law. The supplied material does not include that law for comparison.
Case for#
- A specific offence could make the law on taking or keeping a dog clearer, including where someone causes or induces the dog to go or stay with another person.
- The offence covers both taking a dog and keeping it from someone entitled to lawful control, addressing more than the initial act of taking.
- Requiring courts to record and consider the helper-dog aggravation could make the impact on assistance-dog users part of sentencing.
- The required report could give Parliament information on recorded cases, prosecutions, convictions and sentences.
Case against#
- “Lawful control” and “reasonable excuse” are not defined in the bill, leaving important questions to be resolved in individual cases.
- The bill does not state a required intent for the offence. This could leave uncertainty about how the offence applies in particular circumstances, alongside its defences.
- The report requirement may provide limited ongoing scrutiny: the text requires a report after a three-year period but does not clearly require regular reports after that.
- The required information-sharing and reporting may take public staff time, but the bill gives no estimate of the cost.