Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The official short title is the Restraint and Seclusion in Schools (Scotland) Act 2025. It creates duties and powers about restraint and seclusion in schools; the stated goal is to make provision about restricting pupils’ movement or isolating them. The supplied material lists the Act at Royal Assent, but its main provisions start only on a date set by Scottish Ministers, no later than 31 July 2028.

  • Scottish Ministers must issue and review guidance on restraint and seclusion. Education providers must have regard to that guidance.
  • Schools’ responsible persons must inform a pupil’s parent about an incident and its details by the end of that school day, or within 24 hours if that is not reasonably practicable. Regulations may exempt specified types of restraint or seclusion.
  • Education providers must record incidents, subject to any types later exempted by regulations. Education authorities, independent-school proprietors and grant-aided-school managers must report incident numbers to Ministers.
  • Ministers must publish an annual report on incident numbers. They may also set up reporting to another specified person.
  • Ministers may develop training standards and keep lists of people who meet them, or list standards developed by others and people who meet those standards. They do not have to create these lists.

What it means for you#

  • Pupils and parents: A parent must generally be told when a pupil is restrained or secluded, with details of the incident. If the parent indicates that another person may receive this information, the school may tell that person instead. The Act does not itself set out a complaint or appeal process, though guidance must cover complaints and steps to resolve them.
  • Schools and education providers: They must follow the recording and reporting duties and have regard to Ministers’ guidance. The duties apply to education authorities, independent schools and grant-aided schools. Some types of incidents may later be exempted by regulations.
  • Teachers and other staff: The Act’s definitions cover staff and anyone acting under an education provider’s authority. It does not itself require staff to use restraint training from a listed provider.
  • Scottish Ministers: They must issue guidance and report yearly to Parliament. They may change the definitions by regulations, after consulting people they consider appropriate.
  • General public: The Act does not itself ban restraint or seclusion, create a direct right to compensation, or set a new fine. The supplied material does not establish how these rules compare with current law.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated costs or funding.

  • The Act requires providers to record incidents and some providers to report them; this entails administrative work, but no cost estimate is given.
  • Ministers must prepare annual reports and guidance. The Act gives no staffing or budget figures.

What is unclear#

  • The start date for the main duties has not been set in the supplied material. Ministers must set it by 31 July 2028.
  • The Act leaves key details to regulations, including exemptions from recording, reporting and parent notification, and the timescales and formats for any additional reporting.
  • The terms “significantly restricting” movement and “significant risk of harm” are not fully defined in the Act. Guidance may explain the first term, and Ministers may change either definition by regulations.
  • The Act does not set out a complaint process, decision rules, appeals or a required response time for complaints. Guidance must address complaints and possible remedies.
  • The supplied material does not include current law or explain how these duties would interact with existing rules.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the Act is that required guidance can give schools clearer direction on appropriate and inappropriate restraint, alternatives, prevention and safeguarding.
  • Required notification to parents and incident records could make individual incidents more visible and support monitoring.
  • Annual reporting to Parliament could provide a regular picture of how often restraint and seclusion are used.
  • The option to develop or recognise training standards could help identify training providers that meet standards Ministers consider appropriate.

Case against#

  • The Act leaves important rules to future regulations, including which incidents can be excluded from records, reports or parent notification. The scope of public reporting could therefore depend on later decisions.
  • The Act requires providers to have regard to guidance, but does not itself make every part of the guidance a binding rule.
  • The Act sets no cost estimate, staffing requirement or dedicated funding for the new recording, reporting and guidance duties.
  • The Act does not itself establish a complaint or appeal route, or explain how a complaint must be investigated and resolved.