Wellbeing and Sustainable Development (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Wellbeing and Sustainable Development (Scotland) Bill is a Member’s Bill that would create a new law; it does not amend an existing Act. It would require public bodies to have due regard to promoting wellbeing and sustainable development, and establish an independent Future Generations Commissioner for Scotland. Its stated goal is to promote the wellbeing of future generations. The Bill has fallen, so it is not law and these changes will not take effect through this Bill.

  • Public bodies exercising functions in or as regards Scotland, where those functions do not relate to reserved matters, would have to have due regard to the need to promote wellbeing and sustainable development. They would also have to consider the Commissioner’s published guidance.
  • The Bill defines wellbeing through factors including dignity, safety, health, meaningful activity, an adequate standard of living and access to the natural environment. Scottish Ministers could change those factors by regulations, subject to approval by the Scottish Parliament.
  • The Commissioner’s office would issue guidance, promote awareness and best practice, review law and policy, and conduct research.
  • The Commissioner could investigate whether public bodies considered wellbeing and sustainable development. Investigations could require evidence or documents, subject to limits and legal privileges; failure to comply without a reasonable excuse could lead to a fine or up to three months’ imprisonment.
  • The Commissioner would report findings and recommendations to Parliament. A report could require a public body to explain its response, but the Bill does not require the body to follow a recommendation.

What it means for you#

  • Public bodies: They would need to take the duty and the Commissioner’s guidance into account when exercising relevant functions. The Bill does not require them to choose a particular outcome just because it would promote wellbeing.
  • People and groups affected by investigations: The Commissioner would have to take appropriate steps to bring an investigation and its terms of reference to the attention of people likely to be affected. The Bill does not create a general application or complaint process.
  • General public: The Commissioner’s investigation reports and annual reports would be published. The office would be independent of Ministers and Parliament, except for specific controls set out in the Bill, including budget approval and some staffing and reporting rules.
  • Courts and tribunals: They are excluded from the definition of public body, and the Commissioner could not investigate matters relating to court or tribunal proceedings.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The Bill would require the Commissioner to prepare a budget for approval by the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body, and a strategic plan with cost estimates. No figures are supplied here.
  • The Commissioner could appoint staff, with the Corporate Body’s consent as to staff numbers, and could charge reasonable sums for some services. The Bill does not estimate staffing or other costs, or expected income.

What is unclear#

  • The Bill does not define “due regard”; guidance from the Commissioner would help explain how public bodies should apply the duty.
  • It does not set out a complaint or application process for individual investigations, or detailed rules for choosing which matters to investigate.
  • It is unclear how public bodies would balance the duty with other duties when they conflict.
  • The Bill does not provide an estimate of the office’s cost or explain in detail how its work would be funded.
  • The supplied material does not establish how this duty would interact with any similar duties already in force.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the Bill is that decisions by public bodies can affect future generations, and the duty would require those bodies to consider that longer-term impact.
  • An independent Commissioner could investigate whether public bodies gave that consideration, publish findings and recommend changes.
  • The definition of wellbeing covers several parts of people’s lives, giving public bodies and the Commissioner a shared set of factors to consider.

Case against#

  • One concern is that “due regard” is not defined, so public bodies may be uncertain about what the duty requires in practice.
  • The Commissioner could require evidence and documents, but the Bill does not set out detailed procedures for starting individual investigations or selecting matters.
  • Recommendations would not have to be followed. A public body could explain why it would take no action, so the Bill does not guarantee that investigations would change decisions.
  • The Bill creates an office and allows it to appoint staff, but the available material gives no cost estimate.