Summary#
The Commissioner for Older People (Scotland) Bill would create a statutory office for people aged 60 and over; it does not amend one main Act, but would add the office to several public-authority laws. Its stated goal is to promote and safeguard older people’s rights and interests. The bill has fallen and is not law.
- The Commissioner would be independent of ministers and Parliament, subject to specific controls by the Scottish Parliamentary Corporate Body (SPCB), including approval of the office budget and staff numbers.
- The Commissioner must promote awareness, review relevant law and practice, promote service-provider best practice, encourage use of older people’s skills and experience, and promote, commission, undertake and publish research. The Commissioner must also have regard to the UN Principles for Older Persons.
- The Commissioner must take reasonable steps to involve older people and consult organisations working with or for them.
- The Commissioner may investigate how a service provider considered older people’s rights, interests and views. The Commissioner may require evidence or documents, and must report findings and recommendations. A recommendation may include a requirement for a written response, but the bill does not require the recipient to follow the recommendation.
- The office would be covered by freedom of information, public-records, public-functions improvement and procurement laws. The bill sets out a proposed start: some provisions would begin after Royal Assent, and most others six months later. The bill has not received Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- Older people: The Commissioner must make reasonable efforts to explain the office’s functions and how people can contact it, and must consult older people about the office’s work. The bill does not create a new individual right, benefit or front-line service.
- Service providers: They could be investigated about how they considered older people’s rights, interests and views when making decisions or taking actions affecting them. The bill does not require every case or complaint to be investigated.
- People asked to give evidence or provide documents: The Commissioner may require this for an investigation, subject to legal privilege and other limits. Without a reasonable excuse, refusing or failing to comply can be an offence punishable by a fine of up to level 5 on the standard scale or up to three months in prison.
- Public bodies and taxpayers: The SPCB would oversee parts of the office’s staffing, budget and administration. The Commissioner would be a new statutory office, not a division of an existing agency.
- People named in investigation reports: Where reasonable and practicable, they must be given a draft and a chance to make representations before the report is finalised.
Money#
The bill requires the Commissioner to prepare an annual budget for SPCB approval, but no cost estimate is included in the supplied material.
- The Commissioner may appoint staff, with the SPCB’s consent on staff numbers, and may pay for advice and other services, subject to SPCB approval.
- The SPCB may set the Commissioner’s pay and may provide pensions and allowances. The bill also provides for staff pensions, subject to SPCB approval.
- The Commissioner may charge reasonable sums for things done or provided in carrying out the office’s functions; money received must be used to meet related expenditure.
- The bill source says a Financial Memorandum was published, but its figures are not included here. No publicly available information on the estimated cost is in the supplied material.
What is unclear#
- The bill does not set out an application or complaint process, investigation timelines, or an appeal process.
- It does not require service providers to act on recommendations; it allows the Commissioner to require a written response and, in some cases, publicise that response or a failure to provide it.
- “Rights and interests” and “particular significance” are not defined in the bill.
- The Commissioner generally cannot investigate a matter that is properly another person’s function, but may do so after consultation if the Commissioner considers it more effective or expedient. The bill does not explain how this would work alongside existing bodies.
- The bill does not explain how older people’s views would affect decisions about investigations or recommendations.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to give older people’s rights and interests a dedicated office with a Scotland-wide remit.
- Investigation powers, including the ability to require evidence and documents, could help the Commissioner examine how service providers make decisions affecting older people.
- Public reports and the option to require a written response could make findings and recommendations visible.
- Involving older people and consulting organisations working with or for them could help shape the office’s priorities around their views and experience.
Case against#
- The bill does not require a service provider to follow the Commissioner’s recommendations, so an investigation may identify a problem without ensuring it is fixed.
- The bill gives the office a broad range of functions but does not set out detailed rules for choosing cases, handling complaints or measuring results.
- The Commissioner’s remit could overlap with other bodies’ functions. The bill limits investigations in those cases, but leaves the decision about when this office should investigate to the Commissioner.
- The bill creates an ongoing office with staffing and operating costs, but the cost figures are not included in the supplied material.