Children (Withdrawal from Religious Education and Amendment of UNCRC Compatibility Duty) (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Children (Withdrawal from Religious Education and Amendment of UNCRC Compatibility Duty) (Scotland) Act 2026 amends the Education (Scotland) Act 1980 and the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (Incorporation) (Scotland) Act 2024. Its stated goals are to involve pupils in decisions about withdrawal from religious observance and to set out when a public authority’s incompatible action is not unlawful because legislation requires or permits it. The Act has received Royal Assent, but its main changes will start only on dates set by Scottish Ministers.

  • For religious instruction, it removes parents’ right to elect that their child not receive it.
  • For religious observance, a school operator must inform the pupil, hear and consider the pupil’s views, and discuss an objection with the pupil and parent. If the pupil still objects after that discussion, the operator must not act on the parent’s withdrawal request.
  • The operator must act impartially and not try to influence the pupil. If a pupil is withdrawn, the education authority or grant-aided school managers must provide suitable, purposeful educational activity during that time.
  • Ministers must issue guidance, report each school year on how many pupils were withdrawn from religious observance, and review how the amended education provisions operate within three years. Ministers may—but do not have to—make regulations giving pupils their own right to request withdrawal from religious observance.
  • The Act creates exceptions to the UNCRC compatibility duty for specified cases where legislation requires or entitles a public authority to act incompatibly. It also adds notification and court-participation provisions.

What it means for you#

  • Pupils and parents: Parents can request withdrawal from religious observance, but a pupil’s objection prevents the request from taking effect after the required discussion. The Act does not give pupils a direct right to start a withdrawal request; Ministers may create one later by regulations.
  • Pupils withdrawn from religious observance: The education authority or grant-aided school managers must provide suitable, purposeful educational activity during the period of observance.
  • Public and grant-aided schools: Their operators must provide parents written information about the withdrawal process and follow the pupil-involvement rules. They must have regard to Ministers’ guidance.
  • Public authorities: In the specified cases, an incompatible action or failure to act will not be unlawful under the 2024 Act’s compatibility duty if the authority was required—or, in some cases, entitled—to act that way under legislation. Listed authorities must notify Ministers and two rights bodies when they consider that this exception applies because compliance is not possible.
  • The public: This Act does not itself require Ministers to create an independent pupil withdrawal right. Its education and UNCRC changes start only when Ministers appoint commencement dates.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • Schools and education authorities must carry out new duties, and Ministers must produce guidance, reports and a review. The materials give no cost or staffing estimate.
  • No new tax, fee, fine or benefit is set out.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the full current texts of the 1980 and 2024 Acts. I could not verify all the changes against current law.
  • No commencement dates are given for the main changes.
  • The Act does not set out detailed procedures, timelines or an appeal process for withdrawal requests.
  • The pupil-right regulations are optional; the Act does not say whether or when Ministers will make them.
  • The effect of the UNCRC exceptions depends on the wording and legal status of other enactments. The supplied material does not explain how those cases will be handled in practice.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the pupil-involvement rules is that a child’s own views will be heard before a parent’s request to withdraw them from religious observance is acted on.
  • The impartiality duty and required discussion may help make those decisions fairer, while the required educational activity gives pupils something purposeful to do during observance.
  • Annual reporting and a review that must assess inclusiveness give Ministers a way to examine how religious observance is delivered and what action may be needed.
  • The UNCRC exceptions may avoid treating an authority as acting unlawfully under the 2024 Act when legislation requires or entitles it to take the incompatible action.

Case against#

  • The Act removes parents’ right to elect that their child not receive religious instruction. This is a direct loss of a withdrawal option.
  • A pupil’s objection blocks a parent’s request to withdraw from religious observance, but the Act does not give the pupil a direct request right unless Ministers later make regulations.
  • The UNCRC exceptions mean that some actions incompatible with children’s rights requirements will not be unlawful under the 2024 Act. The circumstances depend on other legislation.
  • Schools and authorities have new duties, but the Act provides no cost estimate or detailed process for carrying them out.