Prevention of Domestic Abuse (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Prevention of Domestic Abuse (Scotland) Bill is a withdrawn Member’s Bill, so it did not become law. It would have created a new Act and amended four existing Acts: the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995, the Prisoner and Criminal Proceedings (Scotland) Act 1993, the Community Justice (Scotland) Act 2016, and the Management of Offenders etc. (Scotland) Act 2005. Its stated goal was to prevent domestic abuse.

  • Some people convicted of specified domestic-abuse offences would have to give the police personal details, including their address and passport information, and keep them updated. The notification period would depend on the sentence.
  • Police Scotland would have to include these offenders in existing arrangements for assessing and managing offender risk.
  • Courts and prison-related processes would require reports or assessments of some offenders’ suitability for rehabilitation services.
  • Police, prosecutors and relevant charities would have duties to collect specified demographic data about victims. Individuals could decline to provide their data; charities could also omit collection in certain circumstances.
  • Scottish Ministers and education authorities would have to promote, facilitate and support domestic-abuse education in schools. Parents could withdraw a pupil, who could not be disadvantaged for doing so.

What it means for you#

  • People convicted of specified offences: If sentenced to at least 12 months in prison, or given a community payback order with an offender supervision requirement, they would have to notify the police. For prison sentences of 12 to 30 months, the period would be three times the sentence; sentences over 30 months would mean indefinite notification. People under 18 at conviction would have shorter periods under the bill’s rules. Failing to comply without a reasonable excuse, or knowingly giving false information, could lead to imprisonment or a fine.
  • People subject to indefinite notification: The chief constable would have to review the requirement after 15 years for an adult, or 6 years for someone convicted under 18. It could be continued for up to 15 years at a time if the chief constable found, on the balance of probabilities, a risk of relevant harm. The offender could appeal.
  • Victims: Police and prosecutors could request demographic information from victims, but victims could refuse. Relevant charities would generally have to collect it, but could decide not to in some cases; individuals could still refuse.
  • Schools and parents: Education authorities would have to support domestic-abuse education. Ministers would have to issue guidance, and could set standards by regulations. Parents could withdraw pupils without disadvantage to them.
  • General public: The bill would not itself guarantee access to rehabilitation services; it would require assessments or reports about suitability and make provision for services in specified processes.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require work by police, local authorities, the Scottish Ministers, courts, prosecutors, charities and education authorities, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate or staffing figures.
  • It would require annual public reports on collected victim data, and reports on progress in school education.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not include the parent Acts or explanatory and financial memoranda. I could not verify the full current-law position or compare every proposed change with existing processes.
  • The bill leaves details to later regulations, including some notification information, submission deadlines for victim data, and possible school education standards.
  • It does not set out how rehabilitation services would be provided, what services would be available, or how local authorities would assess suitability.
  • It does not specify how data collection would be modified for victims under 16; Ministers could set that out in regulations.
  • The bill was withdrawn, so it did not set a start date in practice or create working requirements.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to help police keep track of some people convicted of domestic-abuse offences and to connect them with existing risk-management arrangements.
  • Requiring rehabilitation-suitability reports at sentencing and in prison-related processes could help decision-makers consider support aimed at reducing further offending.
  • Collecting and publishing anonymised demographic data could help show which groups are affected, while allowing individuals to refuse to provide their information.

Case against#

  • The notification duties would require people to report detailed personal information, with criminal penalties for some failures. A concern is that the bill does not explain how the system would be resourced or how police would use the information.
  • It requires assessments and reports but does not guarantee that suitable rehabilitation services will be available. The practical effect could therefore depend on resources and later decisions.
  • Charities would have a data-collection duty, although they could make exceptions for impracticality or unreasonable circumstances. The bill does not explain how this duty would affect their work or costs.