Summary#
The Desecration of War Memorials (Scotland) Bill is a withdrawn Member’s Bill. It would amend the Criminal Law (Consolidation) (Scotland) Act 1995 by adding a specific offence of destroying, damaging or desecrating a war memorial. Its stated goal is to create that offence; the bill is not law and has no effect.
- A person would commit the offence if, without a reasonable excuse, they wilfully or recklessly destroyed, damaged or desecrated a war memorial.
- “Desecrating” would include, but not be limited to, spitting, urinating or defecating on a memorial, or defacing it temporarily or permanently.
- The definition would cover structures, objects and planted or grown things with a commemorative purpose relating to armed conflict. Flowers, wreaths and other tributes placed on, at or near a memorial would count as part of it.
- On summary conviction, the maximum penalty would be 12 months’ imprisonment, a fine up to the statutory maximum, or both. On conviction on indictment, it would be up to 10 years’ imprisonment, a fine, or both.
- If enacted, the Act would start six months after Royal Assent.
What it means for you#
- Anyone in Scotland: The bill would create a specific criminal offence for the conduct described above. It would apply only where the person acted wilfully or recklessly and had no reasonable excuse.
- People responsible for memorials or tributes: The bill would not require them to register memorials, apply for protection, or take other steps.
- The public: The bill would not create a new service or organization. It would not change who owns a memorial or require its transfer.
- Current law: The bill would add wording to the 1995 Act. The current Act was not supplied, so the materials do not show how this offence would differ from offences already in force or how it would overlap with them.
Money#
No publicly available information on the bill’s costs is included in the supplied material.
- The bill text does not set out spending, staffing, or a new enforcement body.
- A financial memorandum is listed as an accompanying document, but its contents were not supplied.
What is unclear#
- “Reasonable excuse” and “desecrates” are not defined in the bill. The bill gives examples of desecration but says the list is not limited to those examples.
- The definition covers memorials commemorating people or animals who died in armed conflict, including memorials with more than one purpose. The bill does not explain how disputed cases would be decided.
- The bill does not set out investigation, prosecution, or sentencing procedures beyond the stated penalties.
- The materials do not explain how this offence would interact with existing offences or protections.
- The bill is listed as withdrawn, so it will not take effect in this form. It would need to be brought forward again and passed to become law.
Case for#
- The bill appears intended to make it clear that damaging or desecrating war memorials is a distinct criminal offence.
- A possible argument for the specific offence is that it expressly covers temporary defacement and conduct such as spitting, urinating or defecating, not only physical destruction.
- Including flowers, wreaths and other nearby tributes could make clear that these items are covered too.
- The offence would apply to wilful or reckless conduct, rather than making every accidental act an offence.
Case against#
- The bill leaves key terms, including “desecrates” and “reasonable excuse,” undefined. That could leave uncertainty about how the offence applies in particular cases.
- The maximum penalty on indictment is up to 10 years’ imprisonment, but the bill does not explain what factors would guide the choice between summary and indictment proceedings or the sentence.
- The bill creates a new offence without the supplied materials explaining whether existing offences already cover some of the same conduct.