Prostitution (Offences and Support) (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Prostitution (Offences and Support) (Scotland) Bill is a Member’s Bill that would create a new offence, repeal an offence in the Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982, quash certain past convictions, and require support for people in prostitution. Its stated goal is to make these changes and provide support; that goal is not a guaranteed result. The Bill has fallen and is not law.

  • A person would commit an offence if it could reasonably be inferred they obtained or intended to obtain an in-person sexual act, and they or someone else paid or promised payment for it. The offence would carry up to six months in prison on summary conviction, or up to 12 months on conviction on indictment, and/or a fine.
  • Payment would include financial or material benefits, directly or indirectly. The offence would not cover striptease, pole dancing, lap dancing or other erotic performances.
  • The Bill would repeal the offence of soliciting or importuning by prostitutes under the 1982 Act. It would also quash past convictions under that offence and require criminal records to be amended.
  • Scottish Ministers would have to ensure assistance and support for people who are or have been in prostitution. Support would require the person’s agreement and could not depend on them being a witness in criminal proceedings.
  • Ministers could make regulations on eligibility, conditions, which public bodies carry out support functions, and administrative procedures.

What it means for you#

  • People paying for sexual acts: If the Bill became law, paying or promising payment for a covered act could be a criminal offence, including where another person paid and the buyer knew before obtaining the act. The person performing the act would not commit this offence by helping or encouraging the buyer to commit it.
  • People who are or have been in prostitution: Ministers would have to ensure you are offered assistance and support, which could include safe accommodation, financial or other material help, healthcare, information, translation, and legal help. You would have to agree to receive it.
  • People with past convictions for soliciting or importuning: Convictions for the repealed offence would be quashed automatically when that part of the law came into force. Ministers would have to require Police Scotland and the Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service to amend records. You could request a confirmation letter from Ministers.
  • Police, courts and public bodies: The new offence and repeal would change the law they apply. Regulations could give support functions to named public bodies, including local authorities and health bodies.
  • The Bill would not itself set out an application or assessment process for support, or change other people’s entitlement to support under other laws.

Money#

No publicly available information. The supplied material says a Financial Memorandum was published, but does not include its cost estimates.

  • The Bill would allow support to include financial assistance, but gives no amount or funding allocation in the text supplied.
  • Ministers would have to ensure support is provided, but the Bill gives no staffing or delivery cost estimate.

What is unclear#

  • The Civic Government (Scotland) Act 1982 is not supplied, so the existing wording and operation of the offence being repealed could not be checked against the current law.
  • The Bill does not set out how people would access support, how needs would be assessed, or what minimum support must be provided.
  • Ministers could set eligibility criteria and conditions by regulations. The Bill does not say what those criteria or conditions would be.
  • The Bill does not define “in prostitution” beyond linking it to a person who has been in the position of the person performing a covered act at least once, whether or not compelled.
  • The Bill does not say how support would be funded, or how the new offence would be investigated and enforced.
  • The offence and support provisions would start on dates set by Ministers, not automatically on Royal Assent. The Bill does not set those dates.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the Bill is that it would make paying for covered sexual acts a criminal offence while not criminalising the person performing the act under this offence.
  • Quashing past convictions and repealing the related offence could remove legal penalties and records for people convicted of soliciting or importuning.
  • A legal duty to provide support could give people in prostitution access to help, including accommodation, healthcare and legal assistance.
  • Support could not be made conditional on giving evidence in a criminal case, and it would have to take account of safety and protection from harm.

Case against#

  • The new offence could be difficult to apply consistently: it depends on what can be “reasonably inferred,” while the Bill does not set out an investigation or decision process.
  • The Bill creates a duty to provide support but leaves key details, including eligibility, conditions and delivery, to later regulations.
  • The Bill does not set a funding amount or minimum level of support, so the scale and availability of assistance are unclear.
  • The Bill does not explain how the new offence would interact with other laws or how support would fit with existing services.