Ecocide (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Ecocide (Scotland) Bill is a fallen Member’s Bill, so it did not become law. It would create a new criminal offence and amend the Environment Act 1995 and Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995. Its stated goal is to create the offence of ecocide; that does not mean the bill would make all environmental harm a crime.

  • A person would commit ecocide by causing severe environmental harm while intending to cause environmental harm or being reckless about whether environmental harm is caused. Harm would have to have serious adverse effects and be widespread or long-term.
  • A court could convict an organisation and, in some cases, also a responsible individual who consented to or allowed the offence. An employer or principal could also be liable for an employee’s or agent’s offence, subject to a defence.
  • An individual convicted on indictment could face up to 20 years in prison, or imprisonment and a fine. Other convicted persons could be fined. Courts would have to consider financial benefit from the offence when setting a fine.
  • Courts could order compensation for harm and costs of preventing, reducing, repairing or limiting harm. They could also order publicity about a conviction and sentence.
  • The Scottish Environment Protection Agency (SEPA) would gain enforcement powers in relation to ecocide by extending powers it already has under the Environment Act 1995. Scottish Ministers would have to report on the law’s operation after a five-year review period.

What it means for you#

  • Businesses and other organisations: An organisation could face a fine if it committed ecocide. A responsible individual could also be guilty if the offence involved that person’s consent or connivance (knowingly allowing or agreeing to it).
  • Employers and principals: They could be liable for ecocide committed by an employee or agent acting in that role. They could defend themselves by showing they did not know, no reasonable person could have suspected the offence, and they took all reasonable precautions and used due diligence to prevent it.
  • Individuals: The offence would require severe environmental harm and intent or recklessness. A person charged could argue that the conduct was necessary and reasonable to prevent greater harm; financial loss would not count as the greater harm for this defence. The person would have to establish the defence on the balance of probabilities.
  • People and communities affected by environmental harm: A court could order the convicted person to pay compensation, including costs of environmental repair or mitigation. This would be a court’s power, not an automatic payment.
  • General public: The bill would not itself create a new independent agency, a general ban on environmentally harmful activity, or an application process. It would add ecocide to SEPA’s existing enforcement powers; the exact scope of those powers cannot be checked from the bill alone.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would require SEPA to use its enforcement powers in relation to ecocide, but gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • Fines, compensation and any money recovered through the Proceeds of Crime Act could bring in money, but the bill does not estimate amounts.
  • A court could impose a fine on a person who fails to comply with a publicity order: up to £40,000 on summary conviction, or a fine on indictment.
  • The Scottish Ministers would have to prepare and publish a report and lay it before Parliament. No cost estimate is provided.

What is unclear#

  • The bill uses the meaning of “environmental harm” in the Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Act 2014, but that Act was not supplied, so that definition and its relationship to current law could not be checked.
  • Terms such as “serious adverse effects,” “limited geographic area” and “significant number” are not defined in the bill.
  • The bill does not set out how SEPA would investigate ecocide or how its added enforcement powers would work in practice. The Environment Act 1995 was not supplied, so the existing powers being extended could not be verified.
  • The bill does not explain how the offence would interact with other environmental offences or existing enforcement processes.
  • The offence would start only on a date set by Scottish Ministers in regulations. The bill gives no start date; in any case, this bill fell and is not law.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to address severe environmental harm by creating a specific criminal offence with a high threshold: serious adverse effects, plus widespread or long-term harm, and intent or recklessness.
  • A possible argument for the design is that it reaches beyond the organisation itself: responsible individuals and, in some cases, employers or principals could also be liable.
  • Courts could take financial benefit into account when setting a fine, and could order compensation for repair or mitigation costs.
  • A required report would gather information on reported crimes, prosecutions, convictions, sentences, money recovered and damage linked to convictions.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves important terms undefined. That could make it harder for organisations and individuals to know in advance what conduct falls within the offence.
  • The employer or principal liability provision could reach a person or organisation for an employee’s or agent’s offence unless all parts of the defence are established.
  • The necessity defence puts the burden on the person charged to prove it on the balance of probabilities.
  • The required report would assess damage and public costs linked to acts resulting in convictions. It is unclear how much it would show about serious harm that was reported but did not lead to a conviction.