Crofting and Scottish Land Court Bill

Summary#

The Crofting and Scottish Land Court Act 2026 amends the Crofters (Scotland) Act 1993 and the Crofting Reform (Scotland) Act 2010, among other laws. It also provides for the Scottish Land Court to take over the Lands Tribunal for Scotland’s work. Its stated goals include reforming crofting law and joining the two bodies’ work; these are aims, not guaranteed results.

  • Crofters’ duties would expressly allow certain actively managed environmental uses, but not using a croft to generate, transmit or store energy. The Crofting Commission would gain new enforcement steps, and ministers could later make rules for monetary penalties.
  • The Commission would get new powers over common grazing used for woodland or environmental purposes. A grazing committee must seek the landowner’s consent; if the owner does not decide within eight weeks, consent is treated as granted. The Commission must then assess the decision.
  • Many croft changes, including assignations, divisions and subletting, would require the croft to be registered first. A person acquiring land with a croft, owner-occupied croft or common grazing must notify the Commission within a month.
  • The Land Court would take over the Tribunal’s jurisdiction, staff, property, rights and obligations on a date set by ministers. The Court would also hear specified appeals and matters, including some relating to access rights and community rights to buy.
  • The Act requires reviews and consultations on crofting law, common grazings and the Court’s expanded work. Some important details—including monetary penalties and rules for transferring owner-occupied crofts—are left for later regulations.

What it means for you#

  • Crofters and owner-occupier crofters: Their duties would include cultivating the croft, using it for an environmental or other purposeful use, and keeping it fit for cultivation, subject to stated exceptions. The Commission could give notice of suspected non-compliance, consider representations and undertakings, and in some cases pause action on applications in which the person has an interest.
  • People taking on crofts: A proposed assignee must be made aware of crofter duties before consent can be granted. Some family assignations must be approved if the listed conditions are met, including that the landlord has not objected within 28 days. Crofts let by the Commission would generally be subject to a 10-year restriction on assignation and acquisition, unless exceptional circumstances apply.
  • Common-grazing users and owners: The Act sets out a route for woodland and environmental uses, including limits on when an owner can refuse consent and a Commission determination. If a determination requires fencing or enclosure, the Act specifies who must meet that cost.
  • Land Court users: The Court would handle the transferred Tribunal work and other listed cases. The Act does not itself set a start date for most provisions; ministers must bring them into force by regulations.
  • Tenants of crofts: A tenancy that includes a croft cannot be a private residential tenancy. The Act also says a crofter may not sublet without Commission consent and registration, subject to an exception for letting a dwelling or other building to holiday visitors.

Money#

No publicly available information on the Act’s total public cost is in the supplied material.

  • The Scottish Courts and Tribunals Service must pay Court members’ salaries and allowances; those sums are charged on the Scottish Consolidated Fund. The Service may also pay Court expenses, and the Act permits it to pay Court expenditure.
  • The Act transfers the Tribunal’s staff and other assets and obligations, but gives no estimate of staffing or transition costs.
  • Monetary penalties are not set by the Act itself. Later regulations may set amounts up to the maximum penalty for a level 1 offence on the standard scale.

What is unclear#

  • The Crofters (Scotland) Act 1993 and Crofting Reform (Scotland) Act 2010 were not supplied in their current form. I could not verify which provisions restate existing law and which make a change in practice.
  • Most provisions require ministers to set commencement dates. The supplied material does not give those dates.
  • The Commission must publish working-practice policy and guidance, but the Act does not set decision times for individual applications.
  • Ministers may make regulations on penalties and transfers of owner-occupied crofts. The future rules, processes and safeguards are not yet set out here.
  • The Act does not specify the overall cost, how many staff the transferred work will need, or how the new Court’s workload will be managed.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to let crofters meet their duties through specified environmental uses as well as cultivation, while retaining conditions on how the land is managed.
  • A staged enforcement process gives people notice and a chance to make representations or undertake to comply before some further action is taken.
  • The new common-grazing process provides a route for environmental or woodland use, while setting out reasons an owner may refuse and allowing the Commission to assess the decision.
  • Bringing Tribunal work and the Land Court’s work together could provide one court for the listed land-related matters and appeals.

Case against#

  • The Act gives the Commission broad enforcement tools, including pausing action on applications that involve a person suspected of breaching duties. The practical effects depend in part on how those powers are used.
  • Key rules are postponed to regulations, including penalty amounts and arrangements for transferring owner-occupied crofts. The Act alone does not show the full safeguards or practical process.
  • The Court’s jurisdiction would expand, but the supplied material does not estimate costs, staffing needs or the effect on delays.
  • Common-grazing environmental projects may involve costs for crofters or committees, including fencing where required. The Act does not estimate those costs.