Summary#
The Freedom of Information Reform (Scotland) Bill would amend the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002; it would not create a separate FOI law. Its stated goal is to change who is covered, how information is published, and how FOI duties are enforced. The Bill was a Member’s Bill and has fallen, so it did not become law.
- When deciding whether to use a non-absolute exemption (an exemption that does not automatically block disclosure), a public authority would have to apply a presumption in favour of disclosure.
- Parliament could designate certain people or service providers as public authorities for FOI purposes, after a committee consults them and others it considers appropriate. The designation would cover only specified public functions or services.
- Public authorities would have to take reasonable steps to organise and update information they hold, and make it publicly available. They would also have to follow a publication code prepared by the Scottish Information Commissioner and approved by Parliament.
- Each public authority would have to designate a freedom of information officer, give that officer the resources needed for specified duties, and protect them from conflicting instructions or penalties for doing their FOI work.
- The Commissioner would gain powers to require information from authority staff and agents, and to enforce compliance with certain codes. The Bill would also change rules on response times, enforcement and offences involving records.
What it means for you#
- People requesting information: Authorities would have to respond promptly and no later than 20 working days, subject to existing exceptions and a pause while waiting for further information from the requester. A presumption in favour of disclosure would apply when considering non-absolute exemptions, but would not remove those exemptions.
- People seeking information about public services: A person or contractor providing a service that is a public authority’s function could be brought under FOI for that specified service. The Bill would not automatically make all information held by that person subject to FOI.
- Public authorities: They would have new duties to publish information and appoint and resource an FOI officer. The officer would advise staff and the authority, report on compliance, and assist the Commissioner.
- The Scottish Information Commissioner and Parliament: The Commissioner would prepare the publication code and could require information from authority staff and agents for specified functions. Parliament would gain a power to designate some additional authorities and would have to debate and vote on reports about Ministers’ use of their existing designation power.
- The public generally: The Bill would not itself guarantee that every record is published or that every information request is granted.
Money#
No cost information is in the available material.
- The Bill would require authorities to provide necessary resources for FOI officers, but it gives no staffing or cost estimate.
- It would give the Commissioner new duties and powers, but the supplied material does not estimate their cost or explain how they would be funded.
What is unclear#
- The text of the current 2002 Act and the Bill’s financial memorandum were not supplied, so the existing rules and the full scale of the changes cannot be verified against them.
- The Bill does not define “reasonable steps” or say how the Commissioner’s publication code would set the public-interest information authorities must publish.
- It does not set out the detailed process or criteria for Parliament to designate a person or service provider, beyond consultation and the limits in the Bill.
- The Bill does not set out how authorities should select FOI officers or how disputes about their independence and resources would be handled.
- The Bill would change the offence of destroying records and the time limit for proceedings, but the supplied text does not establish who is covered by the existing offence or the penalty.
Case for#
- A presumption in favour of disclosure could make authorities give greater weight to openness when an exemption is not absolute.
- A publication duty and common code could make useful information easier to find without requiring people to submit requests.
- Extending FOI to specified contracted services could allow public access to information about services that a public authority has arranged for someone else to provide.
- Designated, resourced FOI officers could give authorities clearer responsibility for meeting FOI duties.
Case against#
- The Bill leaves important standards, including “reasonable steps,” to later guidance or decisions, so the practical duties are not fully clear from the Bill alone.
- New publication, staffing and enforcement duties could require public resources, but the supplied material gives no cost estimate.
- Parliament could bring some private people or contractors under FOI, while the Bill does not explain the detailed designation process or how disputes would be resolved.
- A disclosure presumption could increase pressure to release information where an exemption is not absolute; the Bill does not remove those exemptions, but authorities would have to apply the new presumption when considering them.