Contract (Formation and Remedies) (Scotland) Bill

Summary#

The Contract (Formation and Remedies) (Scotland) Act 2025 creates statutory rules for how contracts are formed and what can happen after a breach. It also amends the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945. Its stated purpose is to make provision about contract formation and remedies; that is a goal, not a promised result.

  • The Act sets default rules for offers, acceptance, and when contract notices take effect. Parties can agree to use different rules for formation.
  • It says an agreement can form a contract even if some matters remain unsettled, unless a party explicitly requires agreement on a particular matter.
  • When a contract is lawfully rescinded (ended for breach), the Act sets rules for returning benefits received, including payment for some use or changes in value.
  • A party may temporarily withhold or suspend a counterpart obligation after a breach or, in some cases, in anticipation of one. The withholding must not be clearly disproportionate.
  • It changes the 1945 Act so a breach of contract can count as fault when deciding whether damages should be reduced for contributory negligence (where a claimant’s own fault contributed to the loss).

What it means for you#

  • People and organisations making contracts: Unless the parties agree otherwise, acceptance must show unqualified agreement; silence alone is not acceptance. In some circumstances, starting specified performance forms a contract even without notifying the other party.
  • People making or receiving offers: An offer can be revoked only before acceptance, agreement shown by statements or conduct, or the start of specified performance. Offers to the public or a group generally must be revoked using the same method used to make them, unless the offer specifies another method.
  • People sending contract notices: A notice generally takes effect when it reaches the person, including when an electronic notice becomes available to access. The rule that a postal acceptance takes effect when posted is abolished.
  • Parties to a contract after breach: A party may temporarily hold back a counterpart obligation, including in anticipation of a material breach. For an anticipated breach, the party must notify the other party before withholding begins or as soon as reasonably practical after it starts. A court may refuse withholding if it is inequitable.
  • Parties ending a contract for breach: Subject to the Act’s conditions, benefits received may have to be returned or paid for. The Act also sets rules on compensation for reduced value and payment for use or improvements.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The Act does not specify an appropriation, tax, fee, fine, or cost estimate.
  • The Scottish Ministers must make regulations to set the start date for most provisions. The material gives no estimate of the cost of doing so.

What is unclear#

  • The material says the Act has reached Royal Assent, but does not give the date when most provisions start. Those provisions start on a date set by Scottish Ministers; some general provisions start the day after Royal Assent.
  • The current contract-law rules and the text of the amended 1945 Act were not supplied. So it is not possible to verify which rules are new and which restate existing law. The Act does expressly abolish the postal-acceptance rule.
  • Terms such as “fundamental change of circumstances” and “clearly disproportionate” are not fully defined in the supplied text.
  • The Act does not set out a general process, timetable, or appeal route for resolving disagreements about these rules. It preserves other laws and rules, so some interactions will depend on those sources.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the Act is that it gives parties clearer default rules for when an agreement is formed and when a notice takes effect.
  • Allowing an agreement to form with some matters unsettled may let parties make a binding deal without settling every detail at once—unless a party has explicitly required agreement on a specific matter.
  • The rules for returning benefits after rescission spell out how money, transferable benefits, use, and changes in value may be dealt with.
  • Temporary contractual retention may let a party respond to a breach without immediately ending the contract, while limits on disproportionate withholding provide a safeguard.

Case against#

  • The Act leaves parties free to agree different formation rules, and many questions may still turn on what their statements and conduct show. That may leave room for disputes.
  • The test against clearly disproportionate withholding is not fully defined in the supplied text, so parties may disagree about how much they can withhold.
  • The return-of-benefits rules can involve valuing performance, use, or improvements. The material does not set out a process for resolving those valuation disputes.
  • The Act preserves other laws and rules and allows courts to refuse inequitable withholding. That may make the overall rules harder to predict without knowing how they interact in particular cases.