Constitutional amendment would curb redistricting between censuses

Summary#

HJR-7009, titled “A RESOLUTION to propose an amendment to the Constitution of Tennessee, regarding the composition of congressional districts,” is a proposal to amend the state constitution; it is not law. It would require the General Assembly to set congressional district boundaries after each decennial census and generally bar changes between censuses. Its goal is to limit when those boundaries can change.

  • Between decennial censuses, district boundaries could change only if needed to remedy a specific violation of the U.S. Constitution or the Voting Rights Act of 1965.
  • Any change to remedy such a violation would have to be narrowly tailored and limited to the least change necessary.
  • The resolution directs that the proposal be referred to the next General Assembly and published on the Secretary of State’s and General Assembly’s websites.

What it means for you#

  • General Assembly: If the amendment takes effect, it would have to establish congressional district boundaries after each decennial census. Between censuses, it could change them only under the stated exception.
  • Tennessee residents: The proposal does not itself change any district boundaries or directly change voting eligibility. It would set a constitutional limit on when congressional districts may be changed if adopted.
  • The resolution is at the introduced stage, so it has not changed the law; passage is uncertain.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The resolution directs state offices to publish the proposal and deliver a copy, but gives no cost estimate or funding amount.

What is unclear#

  • The Tennessee Constitution’s current text was not supplied, so I could not verify how much of this proposal would be new compared with current law.
  • The resolution refers to the amendment process in Article XI, Section 3, but the full process and requirements are not included in the material.
  • The proposal does not define who determines whether a specific violation exists or whether a boundary change is the least change necessary.
  • It does not set out a process, timeline, or review method for making or challenging a change under the exception.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the amendment is that it would make congressional district boundaries more stable between censuses.
  • The exception would still allow changes needed to remedy a specific violation of the U.S. Constitution or the Voting Rights Act.
  • Requiring the least change necessary could limit how much district boundaries change when a remedy is required.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the proposal allows changes between censuses only for the stated legal violations; other reasons for changing boundaries are not listed.
  • The terms “specific violation” and “least change necessary” are not defined, and the resolution does not explain who would decide whether they are met.
  • It is unclear how the limits would interact with existing law or with any process for challenging district boundaries.