Dolly Parton Statue Would Face Ryman

Summary#

HB-4 would amend Tennessee Code Annotated, Title 4, by adding a section about a Dolly Parton statue; it is not yet law, and passage is uncertain. Its stated goal is to honor Parton for her contributions to Tennessee.

  • The State Capitol Commission must develop and carry out a plan to commission a statue on the Capitol grounds, facing toward the Ryman Auditorium.
  • The commission must seek public and other interested parties’ input, including proposed design concepts.
  • Non-state sources must cover all costs of planning, designing, building and placing the statue.
  • The bill creates a Dolly Parton fund within the state general fund. It would receive gifts, grants and other donations from non-state sources.
  • After the statue is completed, remaining fund money must be used for its upkeep and maintenance until it runs out.

What it means for you#

  • The State Capitol Commission: Must develop and carry out the plan at its regularly scheduled meetings and seek public input. The bill does not set a deadline or require the commission to adopt any particular public suggestion.
  • People who want to give input: The commission must solicit input, including design concepts. The bill does not create a formal application or approval process.
  • Donors: Gifts, grants and other donations from non-state sources would go into the fund for the statue. The bill does not require anyone to donate.
  • Tennessee taxpayers: The bill requires non-state sources to cover all costs related to the plan and statue. It does not create a tax, fee or fine.
  • Current law: The materials do not include the existing law governing the commission, so I could not verify what duties or statue-related rules already apply.

Money#

The bill requires non-state sources to cover the listed costs, but the available materials give no cost estimate.

  • The fund would receive non-state gifts, grants and donations. Unspent amounts would carry forward each fiscal year.
  • The state treasurer must invest the fund’s money; investment earnings and interest must return to the fund.
  • After the statue is completed, remaining money must pay for upkeep and maintenance until exhausted.
  • The bill does not estimate planning, construction or maintenance costs, or say how costs would be handled if donations are insufficient.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “upkeep and maintenance” or say what happens if the fund runs out while costs remain.
  • It does not set a timeline, design criteria, or a process for choosing among public suggestions.
  • It does not explain whether or how the commission would proceed if non-state donations do not cover the required costs.
  • It does not explain how any staff time or other commission expenses would be paid for.
  • The existing law on the commission was not supplied, so how this duty would fit with its current duties is unclear.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to recognize Dolly Parton’s contributions to Tennessee with a statue on the Capitol grounds.
  • Requiring public input could give people a chance to contribute ideas about the statue’s design.
  • Requiring non-state sources to cover the listed costs could limit the direct cost to state funds.
  • Keeping remaining donations and investment earnings in the fund could provide money for maintenance after the statue is completed.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill requires the commission to carry out a plan without explaining what happens if donations are not enough to pay for it.
  • The bill does not set a timeline, design-selection rules or a process for resolving competing public suggestions.
  • The fund would pay for maintenance only until its money is exhausted; the bill does not say what happens after that.
  • The bill does not explain how commission staff time and other expenses would be covered, despite requiring non-state sources for the costs it lists.