Candidates Could Seek Paperless Vote Recounts

Summary#

Texas HB 1146 is an introduced bill that would amend the Texas Election Code; it is not law. It would allow an initial recount of paperless electronic voting system results without a stated ground, subject to limits on which candidates may seek one. Its stated goal is not provided; the bill’s title describes the subject.

  • A candidate may seek an initial recount if election returns show they were not nominated or elected.
  • A candidate shown as nominated or elected may also seek one if an opposing candidate’s approved recount petition covers only some, not all, voting system precincts, under a provision of the Election Code not included in the supplied material.
  • The Texas secretary of state must prescribe procedures needed for recounts that do not require a specific ground.
  • The bill does not require a recount in every election, and it does not create a voter-initiated recount process.

What it means for you#

  • Candidates: A candidate who lost, according to the returns, could seek an initial recount without first stating a specific ground. The bill does not say that a recount must change the result.
  • Candidates shown as winners: They could seek an initial recount only in the stated circumstance involving an opponent’s approved recount that does not cover every voting system precinct.
  • Voters: The bill does not directly change how you vote or require you to take action. It could affect how results in an election are checked.
  • Election officials and the secretary of state: The secretary of state must set procedures. The bill does not specify the full recount process or who carries it out.
  • The supplied material does not include the current Election Code text, so it is not possible to verify the exact recount grounds or procedures under current law.

Money#

The bill requires the secretary of state to prescribe procedures, but no cost estimate is available.

  • No appropriation, fee, fine, or payment to candidates is stated.
  • The cost of writing procedures or conducting any additional recounts is not stated.

What is unclear#

  • What grounds or other rules current law requires, and exactly how this bill would change them, could not be verified without the current Code text.
  • The bill does not define “paperless electronic voting system.”
  • It does not set deadlines, explain how a candidate requests a recount, or specify how recounts are conducted.
  • The referenced provision governing an opponent’s partial recount was not supplied, so its scope could not be checked.
  • The bill does not estimate how often recounts might be requested or what they might cost.
  • The bill would take effect September 1, 2027, if enacted. As an introduced bill, it may not become law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a candidate would not have to identify a specific ground before seeking an initial recount of paperless electronic voting results.
  • Allowing a candidate shown as losing to request a recount could provide another way to check those results.
  • Requiring the secretary of state to prescribe procedures could give officials rules for handling recounts without a specific ground.

Case against#

  • One concern is that recounts could be requested without a stated reason to question the results, potentially adding work and cost for election officials.
  • The bill does not set process details or explain how the secretary of state’s procedures would address the added requests.
  • It is unclear how the exception for candidates shown as winners would work alongside the referenced partial-recount provision.