Intellectual Disability Would Bar Death Sentences

Summary#

SB 409 is a Texas bill titled “Relating to the applicability of the death penalty to a capital offense committed by a person with an intellectual disability.” It would amend the Code of Criminal Procedure and add a new chapter setting out when and how a judge decides whether a defendant in a capital case has an intellectual disability; its stated goal is to restrict the death penalty in those cases. The bill is introduced and is not law.

  • A defendant found by the judge to have an intellectual disability could not be sentenced to death. The bill defines the condition using intellectual-functioning and adaptive-behavior criteria tied to prevailing medical standards.
  • The defendant’s attorney may request a hearing within one year of indictment. For a timely request, the judge must hold a hearing within the bill’s stated timing limits.
  • On either party’s request or on the judge’s own motion, the judge must appoint a qualified, disinterested expert. The judge may order an examination, which must be limited to assessing intellectual disability.
  • The defendant must prove intellectual disability by a preponderance of the evidence (meaning more likely than not); the state may offer rebuttal evidence.
  • The state may appeal an order issued under the new chapter. The appeal would go directly to the Court of Criminal Appeals, which must review it expeditiously.

What it means for you#

  • Capital-case defendants and their attorneys: The attorney may seek a judge’s decision on intellectual disability. A late request or later evidence may lead to a hearing only if the judge allows it and the attorney shows good cause.
  • Judges and courts: A judge must hold a timely requested hearing, issue a decision with reasons and evidence cited, and appoint an expert when either party asks or the judge chooses to do so.
  • The state: It may challenge an order under the new chapter through a direct appeal. The bill says the appeal must be reviewed expeditiously but sets no review deadline.
  • Juries: If the judge finds no intellectual disability, the jury may not be told that the judge held a hearing. The defendant may still present intellectual-disability evidence if otherwise permitted by law.
  • The bill applies to trials starting on or after September 1, 2027, regardless of when the alleged offense occurred. It does not itself require a hearing in every capital case.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the supplied material.

  • The bill requires appointment of an expert in specified circumstances, but does not say who pays the expert or provide staffing or court-cost estimates.
  • The supplied material identifies no appropriation, fee, fine, or tax change.

What is unclear#

  • The current Code of Criminal Procedure was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which appeal rules or other procedures would be new compared with current law.
  • The bill does not say how expert costs would be paid.
  • It does not define “prevailing medical standards” or specify who decides which standards apply.
  • It does not set a deadline for the Court of Criminal Appeals to finish an appeal, despite requiring expeditious review.
  • It does not explain the trial and sentencing procedure after a judge finds intellectual disability, beyond barring a death sentence.
  • Because the bill is introduced, whether it will pass and become law is uncertain.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to prevent a person with an intellectual disability from being sentenced to death.
  • A pretrial hearing, expert assessment, and written findings could give the judge a structured way to decide the issue before trial.
  • Requiring evidence to follow prevailing medical standards could help anchor the decision in recognized diagnostic standards.
  • The state would have a route to appeal an order under the new chapter.

Case against#

  • The defendant carries the burden of proving intellectual disability, and the bill does not specify who pays for the required expert.
  • The request deadline and hearing schedule could make it harder to raise the issue if relevant information emerges late; a late hearing depends on the judge finding good cause.
  • “Prevailing medical standards” may change or be disputed, and the bill does not explain how disagreements about those standards are resolved.
  • The state’s appeal could affect the timing of a case; the bill requires expeditious review but sets no deadline.