Summary#
This is Toronto City Council’s adopted decision on an objection to the proposed designation of 39 Wynford Drive under Part IV of Ontario’s Ontario Heritage Act. It affirms Council’s earlier intention to designate the property and authorizes the City Solicitor to introduce a designation by-law; it does not itself complete the designation. The stated goal is to protect the property’s identified heritage value.
- The property is already on Toronto’s Heritage Register. Council had previously stated its intention to designate it; the owner objected.
- City staff say the property meets six of Ontario’s nine heritage criteria. The proposed statement of significance identifies the four-storey building, its exterior features and placement, and certain views of it as heritage attributes.
- If a designation by-law is passed and takes effect, Council may review proposed alterations, enforce heritage property standards and maintenance, and refuse demolition.
- The owner’s objection argued that designation is premature while planning applications and studies are ongoing, and that the proposed attributes include later building additions that its heritage consultant says lack heritage value.
What it means for you#
- Property owner: This decision advances the designation process but does not, by itself, complete designation. If a designation by-law is later passed and takes effect, the City would have the powers described above. The report says an appeal may then be made to the Ontario Land Tribunal.
- People interested in the site’s future: The designation decision does not approve or reject the owner’s proposed redevelopment. The report says planning and heritage-permit processes address development proposals and changes to heritage properties.
- General public: The decision does not create a new service, benefit, tax, or fee.
Money#
The City report says the recommendations have no financial implications for the current or future budget years.
- The materials give no estimate of possible staffing, administration, or owner costs.
- The decision does not set a fee, fine, or funding program.
What is unclear#
- The supplied material does not include the final designation by-law, so it does not establish whether one has been passed or whether its final heritage attributes would differ from the proposed statement.
- The owner’s consultant says only the original two floors have heritage value; City staff support the proposed statement covering the four-storey building. The final scope is not shown here.
- The materials do not explain how the designation would interact in practice with the site-specific planning application or other planning policies.
- The report describes possible City powers over alterations and demolition, but this decision does not set out the detailed process or timing for future applications.
Case for#
- A possible argument for the decision is that heritage value can be assessed separately from whether a proposed development is suitable. City staff say designation should identify and describe that value before planning for changes to the site.
- Staff say the building reflects Flemingdon Park’s Modernist design, is linked to the area’s development, and helps define the character of Wynford Drive.
- Designation could give the City tools to review changes and address demolition and maintenance, rather than relying only on the property’s Heritage Register listing.
Case against#
- One concern is that the proposed attributes cover the full four-storey building, although the owner’s heritage consultant says only the original two floors have heritage value.
- The owner argues that designation should be coordinated with ongoing planning work and its development application. City staff disagree that those planning matters should delay designation.
- A possible trade-off is that designation gives the City powers over alterations and demolition before the planning processes have resolved how the site may change. The materials do not show the final scope or how those processes will fit together.