Ethics rules loosened for legislative panel

Summary#

S.J.R. 16, Joint Rules Resolution - Legislative Ethics Amendments, amends Utah’s Joint Rules, Title 6, on legislative ethics and ethics complaints. Its stated goal is to change rules for the Independent Legislative Ethics Commission and the legislative ethics committees; it does not create a new commission. The resolution says it takes effect upon final passage, and the supplied status says it passed the Legislature.

  • Removes the limit of two full terms for commission members; their four-year terms remain.
  • Allows the commission to dismiss a complaint if the complainant and legislator agree to corrective actions after good-faith negotiation. The commission may reopen the complaint if either fails to comply.
  • Changes complaint paperwork requirements, including affidavits for complainants, respondents, and listed witnesses, made under penalty of perjury.
  • Clarifies when the commission and ethics committees can issue subpoenas, and allows a chair to designate a member with legal expertise to preside over an evidence ruling.
  • Changes complaint privacy rules: commission recommendations and related records are private, and the resolution removes provisions that called for publicly releasing the recommendation, complaint, and response. Ethics committee meetings remain subject to open-meeting rules but may be closed for specified reasons.

What it means for you#

  • Legislators: The resolution changes how ethics complaints are screened and handled. It does not itself establish a new complaint intake or appeal system.
  • Complainants, respondents, and witnesses: Affidavits must meet specified requirements and be true and correct under penalty of perjury. People covered by the confidentiality rule must not disclose protected complaint information, subject to listed exceptions.
  • Ethics commission and committee members: A chair may designate a member with legal expertise to rule on evidence. The commission’s term limit is removed. Committee subpoenas must follow state legislative subpoena law.
  • Public: Commission-stage complaint materials and recommendations are not to be publicly released under the amended rules. Ethics committee meetings are subject to open-meeting law, though a committee may vote to close a meeting for listed purposes, including legal, evidentiary, or procedural discussions and deliberations.

Money#

The resolution appropriates no money; it does not establish that the changes have no cost.

  • Commission staff must examine complaints within five business days, in consultation with the commission chair and vice-chair.
  • No publicly available information on added staffing costs or other implementation costs.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied materials do not include the full current Joint Rules, so the full extent of the changes compared with current rules could not be verified.
  • The resolution does not define what counts as good-faith negotiation or specify what corrective actions an agreement may require.
  • It does not set out how the privacy rules interact with access to records outside the complaint process. The resolution does specify that committee meetings remain subject to open-meeting law, with possible closures.
  • No publicly available information on how any added staff work would be funded.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that an agreement on corrective actions could resolve some complaints without a full committee review.
  • Removing the term limit could let experienced commission members continue serving, if reappointed.
  • Requiring detailed, sworn affidavits could help make complaints and responses more specific and accountable.
  • Keeping complaint records private could protect people while a complaint is reviewed.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the resolution removes public-release provisions without setting out another way for the public to learn the substance of commission findings.
  • The bill does not define corrective actions or set standards for deciding whether the parties negotiated in good faith.
  • Removing term limits could reduce turnover on the commission; the resolution does not add a new limit or other safeguard for that change.
  • New or clarified staff duties may require resources, but the resolution provides no cost estimate or additional appropriation.

Votes

4 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1649429

    Passed28 members voted

    Senate/ passed 3rd reading

    FOR · 27AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    27For

    • Republican20
    • Democratic6
    • Independent1

    1Against

    • Republican1

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.

  2. Division No. 1648206

    Passed26 members voted

    Senate/ passed 2nd reading

    FOR · 25AGAINST · 1

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    25For

    • Republican18
    • Democratic6
    • Independent1

    1Against

    • Republican1

    3 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  3. Division No. 1640968

    Passed7 members voted

    Senate Comm - Substitute Recommendation

    FOR · 7

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    7For

    • Republican5
    • Democratic2

    0Against

    2 members were paired and sat out the vote.

  4. Division No. 1640969

    Passed8 members voted

    Senate Comm - Favorable Recommendation

    FOR · 8

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    8For

    • Republican6
    • Democratic2

    0Against

    1 member was paired and sat out the vote.