Preserve Julian Scott's birthplace

Summary#

H.R. 18 is a Vermont House resolution about preserving the Julian Scott birthplace in Johnson; it does not create or amend a law. It supports the town’s preservation efforts and urges the governor to direct the Division for Historic Preservation to work with the town, and to publicly endorse the effort. The stated goal is to preserve the house.

  • The resolution expresses the House’s support for the Town of Johnson’s efforts; it does not require the town to adopt a preservation plan.
  • It urges the governor to direct the Division for Historic Preservation to work with the town. It does not itself require the governor or the Division to act.
  • It also urges the governor to publicly endorse preservation of the birthplace.
  • The House Clerk would send copies to the Johnson Town Clerk, the State Historic Preservation Officer, the governor and Vermont’s congressional delegation.
  • The resolution was introduced and referred to a committee. It has not yet become law, and the material does not say whether it has since advanced.

What it means for you#

  • Town of Johnson: The resolution supports the town’s effort to develop an alternative to demolition. It does not approve a plan or require the town to preserve the house.
  • Governor and historic-preservation staff: The resolution asks the governor to direct the Division for Historic Preservation to work with the town. It does not make that direction a legal duty or set a deadline.
  • Residents and taxpayers: The resolution does not create a new service, tax, fee or benefit. It does not itself stop demolition or change the federal buyout decision described in the material.

Money#

The resolution includes no spending authorization or cost estimate.

  • It does not set aside money for preservation or say who would pay for a preservation plan or any work on the house.
  • If the governor directs the Division to work with the town, staff time may be involved, but the resolution provides no estimate of that cost.

What is unclear#

  • The material does not say what preservation plan the town proposed or what it would cost.
  • It does not say whether the governor or the Division will act on the resolution.
  • The material says FEMA granted a 90-day delay, but does not say what happened after that period or whether demolition remains planned.
  • It does not explain what approvals, property arrangements or funding would be needed to preserve the house.
  • It does not describe how preservation would interact with the federal buyout program.

Case for#

  • The resolution appears intended to give the town support in trying to preserve a birthplace connected to Julian Scott, a Vermont artist and Medal of Honor recipient.
  • Asking the state historic-preservation office to work with the town could bring relevant state expertise into the town’s planning.
  • The delay described in the material gives the town time to develop an alternative proposal before demolition.

Case against#

  • The resolution does not require anyone to preserve the house, provide funding or halt demolition. Its practical effect may depend on decisions made outside the resolution.
  • The material says the house was severely damaged and that the State Historic Preservation Officer cited public danger and changes to the building. It does not explain how a preservation plan would address those concerns.
  • Without a stated plan or cost, it is unclear whether preservation is feasible or what public resources it might require.