Gun transfer waiting periods proposed

Summary#

S-329, An act relating to criminal procedures involving firearms, would amend existing Vermont laws, mainly in Title 13. Its stated goal is to change firearm-related criminal procedures and restrictions; the bill does not guarantee any particular safety outcome. It has passed the Vermont Senate but is not yet law.

  • It would make firearm transfers wait until 72 hours after a dealer receives a NICS identification number for the transfer, or until seven business days after the dealer starts the background check, whichever happens first. Some transfers would be exempt.
  • It would bar firearm possession by some people subject to court treatment or hospitalization orders, with an exception if the Family Division grants relief from the firearms restriction. The Court Administrator would have to report certain court findings to the federal background-check system within 48 hours.
  • It would set a maximum penalty of three years in prison, a $5,000 fine, or both, for a second or later offense of possessing a firearm while prohibited under specified laws.
  • It would prohibit possession of machine guns, with an exception for items registered in the federal firearms registry or otherwise not subject to that registration requirement. The existing prohibition on bump-fire stocks is also included.
  • It would prohibit knowingly possessing a firearm on premises licensed to serve alcohol, with listed exceptions. Owners or operators would have to post notice at each public entrance.

What it means for you#

  • People buying or receiving firearms: A dealer-facilitated transfer generally could not happen until one of the bill’s two waiting-period limits is reached. The bill lists exceptions for transfers that do not require a background check. For mailed firearms, the 72-hour period could start when the order is placed if the buyer provides the dealer with a receipt and verified tracking information showing the purchase and mailing dates.
  • People subject to court orders: The bill would prohibit firearm possession for people meeting the treatment, hospitalization, or other court-order conditions in the text. A person covered by the new treatment-related rule could ask the Family Division for relief. The text does not establish how that petition would be decided.
  • People already prohibited from possessing firearms: A second or later violation of the listed prohibitions would carry a maximum of three years in prison or a $5,000 fine, or both. The bill also sets penalties for violating the waiting-period, machine-gun, and alcohol-premises rules.
  • People at licensed alcohol-serving premises: The prohibition would have exceptions for certain licensed premises and events, public sidewalks or highways through some outside-consumption areas, and specified officers, service members, government workers, and the premises’ license holder. It would not apply to every alcohol-serving location in the same way.
  • General public: The bill does not create a new agency or a general firearm application or review process. It does not change who may buy a firearm except through the restrictions and transfer rules described above.

Money#

No publicly available information on estimated costs is included in the supplied material.

  • The Court Administrator would have to report certain court findings to the federal background-check system within 48 hours; the bill gives no staffing or cost estimate.
  • Owners or operators of covered premises would have to post notices. The bill gives no cost estimate.
  • The bill sets possible fines, but does not estimate how much revenue they might produce.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material contains two different text sequences. The Senate-passed sequence includes the waiting-period and federal reporting rules, but does not include the proposal in the earlier sequence to make theft of any firearm grand larceny. The earlier sequence also has different treatment-related wording. The material does not explain these differences.
  • No parent Act text was supplied, so I could not verify all changes against current Vermont law. In particular, the supplied material does not show how much of the waiting-period rule or other repeated text is new.
  • The text refers to treatment, hospitalization, and nonhospitalization orders under other laws. The supplied material does not explain how those orders are made or how long the resulting firearm restriction lasts.
  • The machine-gun section refers to a voluntary bump-fire-stock collection process before an effective date of October 1, 2018, while the bill’s effective-date section says the act takes effect on passage. The supplied material does not explain this date mismatch.
  • The bill does not set a start date beyond passage or describe oversight or reporting on how the new rules are used.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to reduce access to firearms by people covered by specified court findings and by people already prohibited under law.
  • A waiting period could give time for a background check to be completed before a covered transfer, while the seven-business-day limit means the bill does not require an indefinite delay.
  • The court-reporting duty could help make specified court findings available to the federal background-check system.
  • The exceptions for certain premises and public-service roles limit the alcohol-premises rule rather than making it apply without qualification.

Case against#

  • The bill would add restrictions and criminal penalties, but the supplied material does not explain how the treatment-related rules would apply in practice or how long a restriction would last.
  • The waiting-period rule could delay transfers even when a background check has not returned a result; the bill does not explain how dealers should handle delays beyond the stated limits.
  • The bill requires new reporting and signage but gives no cost or staffing estimate.
  • The alcohol-premises exceptions may make the rule difficult to explain and apply consistently; the bill does not describe how disputes about premises or exceptions would be handled.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 1695895

    Passed30 members voted

    Read 3rd time & passed on roll call, requested by Senator Ingalls, Passed -- Needed 15 of 30 to Pass -- Yeas = 17, Nays = 13

    FOR · 17AGAINST · 13

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    17For

    • Democratic17

    13Against

    • Republican13
  2. Division No. 1695222

    Passed30 members voted

    Recommendation of amendment by Committee on Judiciary agreed to on roll call, requested by Senator Ingalls, Passed -- Needed 15 of 30 to Pass -- Yeas = 17, Nays = 13

    FOR · 17AGAINST · 13

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    17For

    • Democratic17

    13Against

    • Republican13
  3. Division No. 1695223

    Passed30 members voted

    3rd reading ordered on roll call Passed -- Needed 15 of 30 to Pass -- Yeas = 17, Nays = 13

    FOR · 17AGAINST · 13

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    17For

    • Democratic17

    13Against

    • Republican13