Diploma pathways proposed to earn verified credits

Summary#

HB 1171, titled “Standard Diploma; Board of Education shall develop alternative graduation pathways to earn,” would direct Virginia’s Board of Education to develop other ways for students to earn verified credits toward a Standard Diploma without passing the relevant Standards of Learning (SOL) tests. Its stated goal is to expand opportunities to complete those credit requirements. The bill text provided does not amend an existing Act or make the pathways available to students now.

  • The Board must develop at least one pathway that lets a student earn verified credit through a non-test demonstration of competence instead of passing the applicable SOL test.
  • The Board may expand the meaning of “verified credit” to include a Board-approved demonstration, if it meets rigorous standards set by the Board.
  • The Board must consult educators, school leaders, parents, students, education associations and other stakeholders it considers necessary.
  • The Board must consider options such as projects, portfolios, work-based learning, dual-enrollment courses, alternative assessments, credentials, apprenticeships and community service, with attention to English learners and students with limited or interrupted formal education.
  • The Board must ensure the pathways, if implemented, do not affect or replace current requirements for a Standard Diploma or an Advanced Studies Diploma.
  • By January 1, 2027, the Board must report to the Governor and specified legislative committee chairs on its progress, the pathways developed, stakeholder input and possible approval and implementation steps.

What it means for you#

  • Students and families: The bill would not immediately give students a new way to earn a diploma. It directs the Board to develop possible alternatives; it does not itself put them into use or change existing diploma requirements.
  • English learners and students with limited or interrupted formal education: The Board must consider their needs when developing pathways. The bill does not specify particular supports or guarantee a particular pathway for any student.
  • Schools and educators: The Board must consult them and develop pathways. The bill does not set up student applications, decisions, appeals or school-level procedures.
  • Taxpayers: The bill creates work for the Board, but does not specify a budget or staffing level.

Money#

No publicly available information on the cost is included in the supplied material.

  • The Board must develop pathways and prepare a report, but the bill does not provide a cost estimate or appropriate money for this work.
  • The bill does not set fees, fines or a new benefit.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define what counts as a “rigorous” demonstration of competence; the Board would set the standards.
  • It directs the Board to develop pathways and consider approval and implementation steps, but does not require a start date or set an approval process.
  • The Board must report on stakeholder perspectives, but the bill does not specify how consultation must be conducted or how input must affect decisions.
  • The supplied material does not show the current diploma rules in full, so I could not verify how the proposed alternatives would fit with every existing requirement.
  • The supplied status says the bill passed the House of Delegates. The material does not show that it became law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that students could demonstrate academic or career skills in ways other than passing a standardized test.
  • The listed options include practical work, projects and other learning experiences, which could give the Board a range of methods to consider.
  • The bill requires attention to English learners and students with limited or interrupted formal education.
  • Keeping current diploma requirements in place would preserve existing routes while the Board develops alternatives.

Case against#

  • The bill does not set the standards for non-test demonstrations; the Board would decide what is sufficiently rigorous.
  • It requires development and a progress report, but does not require the Board to implement a pathway by a set date.
  • The bill does not provide funding or explain how much staff time the development and consultation work may require.
  • It is unclear how the pathways would work in practice, including who would decide whether a student’s demonstration earns verified credit.