Paraquat Pesticides Would Face a Ban

Summary#

HB 1375 would amend and reenact § 3.2-3939 of the Code of Virginia. The bill’s stated aim is to prohibit pesticides containing paraquat. The supplied status lists it as introduced, so it is not law on the information provided.

  • The proposed text makes it unlawful to manufacture, distribute, sell, offer for sale, use, or offer for use a pesticide containing paraquat.
  • It defines paraquat to include a specified herbicide and its salts, including methyl viologen and paraquat bismethylsulfate.
  • The Department may seize pesticides that violate the proposed ban; the bill does not require the Department to seize them.
  • The current version of § 3.2-3939 was not supplied, so it is not possible to verify how much of the proposed wording is new.

What it means for you#

  • Manufacturers, distributors, sellers and users: If the bill becomes law, the listed activities involving pesticides containing paraquat would be unlawful. The text does not set out an exception or transition period.
  • Virginia Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services: The Department may seize pesticides in violation of the ban, using a process in another section of the Code.
  • Other pesticide users and the public: The bill’s proposed change is specific to pesticides containing paraquat. It does not otherwise change the pesticide rules shown in the supplied text.

Money#

No publicly available information on cost.

  • The bill provides no cost estimate or staffing estimate. It gives the Department a power to seize products but does not require a specific level of enforcement.
  • The supplied text does not set a new tax, fee, fine, or public benefit.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of § 3.2-3939 was not supplied, so the change from current law cannot be fully checked.
  • The bill does not set a start date, phase-in period, or process for handling products already held or in use.
  • It does not explain how the Department would decide which products contain paraquat or how seizure would work; it refers to another Code section, whose text was not supplied.
  • The proposed amendment does not state a penalty range. The available materials do not show what penalties or other consequences may already apply.
  • No publicly available information explains how the bill’s ban would interact with other pesticide rules or programs.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that a ban gives a clear rule: the listed manufacture, distribution, sale, and use of pesticides containing paraquat would be unlawful.
  • A broad prohibition could avoid having to distinguish among uses of products containing the named chemical and salts.
  • The Department’s seizure power could help remove products that violate the ban, although the bill does not require seizure or describe enforcement levels.

Case against#

  • The prohibition covers manufacture, distribution, sale, and use, with no exceptions or phase-in stated in the proposed text.
  • The bill does not explain how people and businesses would handle existing stocks or whether any alternative arrangements are intended.
  • The Department may seize violating products, but the amendment does not spell out the process or give an enforcement-cost estimate.
  • Without the current law and the text of the referenced seizure section, readers cannot fully assess what would change or how the ban would be enforced.