Bail Decisions Would Weigh Mental Health

Summary#

HB 240, “Admission to bail; fixing terms of bail, mental health considerations,” would amend and reenact parts of the Virginia Code on bail. Its stated goal is not provided in the supplied text; the bill sets out rules for bail decisions, including consideration of mental health information. The bill is not law, and the available material does not show which of the listed rules would change current law.

  • Before a bail, release, or detention hearing, a judicial officer would have to try, as far as feasible, to obtain and review the person’s criminal history and any provided emergency custody or temporary detention order or involuntary admission record.
  • A law-enforcement officer who knows the person is or recently was subject to such an order or admission would have to tell the judicial officer.
  • In deciding whether to admit someone to bail, and in setting bail terms, a judicial officer would consider listed factors that include mental health history and certain orders or admissions, as well as evidence that the person is pregnant, recently gave birth, or is nursing.
  • A magistrate conducting a hearing on a warrant or capias for a jailable offense would have to record the information considered on a form and send it to the court. For an act of violence, the magistrate would also have to send it to the prosecutor within 24 hours.
  • The text also includes rules for notifying prosecutors when bail is granted for an act of violence, and for a bail bondsman to request and review a person’s Virginia criminal history record.

What it means for you#

  • People in custody: The bill’s text says a person must be admitted to bail unless there is probable cause to believe they will not appear or their release would pose an unreasonable danger to themselves, family or household members, or the public. A judicial officer must consider the listed factors. Because the current code text was not supplied, it is unclear whether this would change the existing rule.
  • People whose mental health information is considered: The text makes mental health history and certain mental-health orders or admissions relevant to bail decisions. It does not require treatment, create a mental health screening program, or say every person’s records must be obtained.
  • Law-enforcement officers: An officer bringing someone before a judicial officer must provide information about a relevant order or admission if the officer knows of it.
  • Magistrates and courts: Magistrates would have to complete and send the specified form. For an act of violence, a copy would also go to the prosecutor within 24 hours.
  • People charged with an act of violence: If admitted to bail, the person’s prosecutor would have to be notified at the same time. The text does not define a new process for contesting or correcting information considered.
  • Bail bondsmen: If a person has a secured bond and uses a licensed bondsman, the magistrate must provide the person’s Virginia criminal history record on request if it is readily available. The bondsman may use it only to set reporting requirements, must review it at the magistrate’s premises and promptly return it, and must pay a $15 fee.
  • People who post bond: If the accused appears and meets bail conditions, the bond cannot be used to pay fines and costs unless the person who posted it agrees.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The text requires magistrates to complete and transmit forms, but gives no estimate of staff time or cost.
  • It includes a $15 fee payable to the state treasury and credited to the Literary Fund when a bondsman requests a criminal history record. The materials do not establish whether this fee is new.
  • The text gives no estimate of other public, court, or law-enforcement costs.

What is unclear#

  • The current versions of the amended Virginia Code sections were not supplied, so it is not possible to verify which rules are new and which restate existing law.
  • The bill does not define “recent past” or explain how a judicial officer must decide what is feasible when seeking records.
  • It does not set out a process for correcting disputed information, or timelines for most record searches.
  • It does not say what privacy or handling rules apply to mental health information recorded on the form sent to a court or, in violence cases, to a prosecutor.
  • The supplied text gives no effective date.

Case for#

  • Considering mental health history alongside other listed facts could give judicial officers more information when deciding whether someone is likely to appear or pose a danger.
  • Requiring officers to share known information about specified orders or admissions could help judicial officers consider information already available to law enforcement.
  • A written form could make the information considered at a magistrate’s hearing clearer to the court reviewing the case.
  • Prompt notice to prosecutors in violence cases could help them learn about a bail decision when it is made.

Case against#

  • Mental health history or a past order could affect a person’s chance of release, even though the text does not explain how much weight it should receive or how old information should be treated.
  • The bill does not set out safeguards for the mental health information recorded on forms sent to courts and prosecutors.
  • The required record searches and forms could add work for officers, magistrates, and courts, but the text provides no cost or staffing estimate.
  • Without the current code text, readers cannot tell how much of the bill would change existing bail rules.