Serious-injury assault would be Class 6 felony

Summary#

HB 251 would amend several sections of the Code of Virginia, mainly to make assault and battery causing serious bodily injury a Class 6 felony. Its stated goal is not given in the supplied material. The bill is introduced and is not law; its passage and start date are uncertain.

  • A person who commits assault and battery causing “serious bodily injury” would commit a Class 6 felony, unless the conduct amounts to unlawful or malicious wounding.
  • The new offense would be added to Virginia’s list of violent felonies used in sentencing-guideline rules.
  • The new offense would not be eligible for sealing under the petition process described in the amended law, because that process excludes violent felonies on the list.
  • The bill also updates references in other laws to account for the new subsection. It does not create a new service or program.

What it means for you#

  • People accused of assault and battery: If the conduct meets the serious-bodily-injury threshold and does not amount to unlawful or malicious wounding, the charge could be a Class 6 felony rather than a misdemeanor. The bill does not change the penalty for simple assault.
  • People convicted of the new felony: The conviction would count as a violent felony for the sentencing-guideline rules cited in the bill, and it would be ineligible for sealing through the petition process described there.
  • People who work with, or receive services from, adult substance-abuse or mental-health programs: The bill updates cross-references in background-check laws. The supplied text does not show a new background-check rule for this offense.
  • General public: The bill does not create a new right, ban, or front-line service.

Money#

The bill says it may increase imprisonment or commitment, but the cost cannot be determined from the supplied material.

  • The bill states that a minimum fiscal impact of $50,000 must be assigned for state adult-prison costs when the necessary appropriation cannot be estimated. This is not an estimate of the bill’s actual total cost.
  • The cost of any increase in juvenile commitments also cannot be determined.
  • No estimate of additional prison terms, staffing costs, or other public costs is provided.

What is unclear#

  • “Serious bodily injury” is defined in another section, but that definition was not supplied, so its exact threshold cannot be verified here.
  • The bill does not state when it would take effect.
  • The current versions of the amended code sections were not supplied. I could not verify all changes against current law or confirm how much of the amended wording is already in force.
  • The supplied material does not estimate how many cases would meet the new felony rule or how many additional prison terms might result.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that assault and battery causing serious bodily injury should be treated more severely than ordinary assault and battery, while remaining distinct from unlawful or malicious wounding.
  • Adding the offense to the violent-felony list would make that classification apply in the sentencing-guideline rules that use the list.
  • Excluding the conviction from the sealing process would preserve its record under that process.

Case against#

  • A felony charge can carry more serious consequences than a misdemeanor, but the supplied material does not show how many people would be affected.
  • The bill does not provide a cost estimate, even though it says imprisonment or commitment may increase.
  • The key injury threshold depends on a definition not included in the supplied material, making it harder to assess which conduct would be covered.