Systematic Voter Removals Face Election Cutoff

Summary#

HB-28 would amend three existing sections of the Code of Virginia on voter registration. Its stated goal is regular review of voter registration records; the bill also sets a 90-day cutoff for certain voter-removal programs before elections. The supplied text does not include current law, so it is not possible to verify which of the rewritten rules are new. The bill has passed the Virginia House of Delegates, but the supplied material does not show that it has become law.

  • The Department of Elections would have to complete systematic programs to remove voters it identifies as ineligible at least 90 days before a primary or general election. The restriction covers programs based on systematic third-party submissions, but has exceptions, including some removals triggered by a recent death, felony conviction or incapacity order.
  • The Department would have to run a voter-address review at least once a year, using Postal Service change-of-address information or other reliable sources. That review must be completed at least 90 days before a federal primary or federal general election.
  • For a voter reported as possibly not a U.S. citizen, the registrar would give the voter 28 days to submit a sworn statement of citizenship before cancelling the registration. The registrar must also email the notice and try to contact the voter by phone if those details were provided.
  • The bill’s text appears to change the time for registrars to remove a name after Department notification from 30 to 60 days. The amendment formatting is not preserved in the supplied text, so that before-and-after change cannot be independently confirmed.
  • A voter identified as having moved outside their county or city would be sent a notice and return card. If the registrar does not receive the card within 30 days, the voter’s registration would be placed on inactive status.

What it means for you#

  • Voters: A systematic effort to remove voters as ineligible would have to be completed before the 90-day cutoff. This is not a ban on every removal during that period: the bill lists exceptions, and it allows corrections that do not remove a voter.
  • Voters whose citizenship is questioned: The proposed response period is 28 days. A registrar must not send a removal notice or remove the voter if the registrar has evidence the person is a citizen.
  • Voters whose address may have changed: The address-review process could lead to a record update, transfer, or inactive status, depending on the information received and whether the voter returns a card.
  • Registrars and the Department of Elections: They would have to carry out the review and notice duties described in the bill. The text does not require a voter to apply for a review.
  • General public: The bill does not itself change who is eligible to vote or create a new benefit, tax, fee, or fine.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill assigns duties to the Department of Elections and general registrars, but does not give a cost estimate or specify extra staffing or funding.
  • The supplied material does not say whether these duties would require new public spending or change existing costs.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the Code of Virginia is not supplied, so the exact difference between existing law and the bill cannot be checked.
  • “Other reliable sources” is not defined in the supplied text. The Department’s choice of sources could affect which voters are flagged for address review.
  • The bill does not set out a full process for challenging an address-based inactivation or an eligibility determination, including timelines for resolving a challenge.
  • The text does not estimate the number of records affected, the staff needed, or the cost of the reviews.
  • The supplied material says the bill passed the House, but does not show whether it passed the Senate or became law.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that regular address reviews could help keep registration records current.
  • The 90-day cutoff could reduce the risk of large, systematic removals close to an election, while leaving specified exceptions in place.
  • Giving a voter 28 days to respond to a citizenship report, and requiring additional contact attempts, could give the voter more time and ways to correct a mistaken record.
  • The text calls for an annual review, rather than leaving the timing of address checks open-ended.

Case against#

  • Address and eligibility data can be wrong. The bill does not explain how the Department will judge whether a source is reliable or how disputed matches will be resolved.
  • A voter who does not receive or return an address card could be placed on inactive status; the bill says failure to receive the notice does not prevent that result.
  • If the apparent change from 30 to 60 days is intended, a registrar could take longer to remove a name after Department notification.
  • The bill assigns review and notice duties but gives no cost estimate, staffing plan, or detailed process for oversight and appeals.