Superintendent Mentorships Target Teacher Vacancies

Summary#

HB 613 would amend the Code of Virginia by adding a section that establishes the Teacher Recruitment and Retention Mentorship Pilot Program. Its stated goal is to help school divisions with high teacher vacancy rates improve recruitment and retention through mentorship between division superintendents.

  • The Virginia Department of Education must establish and administer the program in coordination with the Virginia Association of School Superintendents.
  • The program must connect a superintendent from a low-vacancy division with one from a high-vacancy division to discuss plans, strategies, and practices for improving recruitment and retention.
  • The Department and the association must set program rules, including guidance on meeting frequency and duration, ways to encourage participation, and oversight of mentorships.
  • Each mentorship must report annually to the Department on its activities, strategies discussed, outcomes, changes in recruitment and retention rates, and any recommendations or needed supports.
  • The Department must report annually by November 1 to the Governor and the chairs of the House and Senate education committees. The act’s provisions expire July 1, 2029.

What it means for you#

  • School division superintendents: A superintendent in a high-vacancy division may be connected with one in a low-vacancy division. The bill does not require every superintendent or division to participate.
  • Participating superintendents: Each mentorship must submit an annual report. The bill does not specify how superintendents are selected or require them to adopt the strategies discussed.
  • Teachers: The bill does not directly change teacher pay, benefits, licensing, or job conditions. It aims to improve recruitment and retention through superintendent mentorships.
  • Taxpayers: The Department and the association would have program administration and reporting responsibilities, but the bill does not state a funding amount.

Money#

No cost estimate is provided in the available material.

  • The bill assigns program administration and reporting duties to the Department, working with the Virginia Association of School Superintendents, but does not specify added funding, staffing, or other costs.
  • It creates no tax, fee, fine, or direct benefit payment.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “high” or “low” teacher vacancy rates, or say how divisions would qualify.
  • It does not set participation rules, explain how mentorship pairs would be chosen, or say what incentives might be offered.
  • It requires policies and procedures but does not set their details, including how results will be measured beyond reporting data on recruitment and retention rates.
  • The supplied material does not include the current Code of Virginia, so it is not possible to verify whether existing programs overlap with this pilot or how the new section would interact with them.

Case for#

  • A superintendent from a low-vacancy division may have practical strategies to share with a superintendent facing higher vacancies.
  • Required reports could help show what strategies were tried and whether recruitment or retention rates changed.
  • The reports may also identify barriers and additional supports that high-vacancy divisions say they need.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define which divisions count as high- or low-vacancy, making eligibility and pairing rules dependent on later policies.
  • Participation is encouraged, not required, and the bill does not ensure that a mentorship will lead to changes in recruitment or retention.
  • The program creates administration and reporting work without specifying funding or staffing.
  • The pilot is set to expire on July 1, 2029; the bill does not say what happens after that date.