Noncompete Limits Would Cover More Workers

Summary#

HB-949, “Covenants not to compete; exceptions, civil penalty,” would amend Virginia’s Code section on employee non-compete agreements. Its stated goal, as indicated by its title, is to set limits and exceptions for those agreements and provide penalties. The supplied text appears to merge old and proposed wording in places, and the current Code section was not supplied, so I cannot verify every change from current law.

  • Employers could not enter into, enforce, or threaten to enforce a non-compete against a “low-wage employee” or an employee who does not perform any of the listed customer-sales, management, key-employee, or professional duties.
  • The proposed definition says a non-compete does not prevent an employee from serving an employer’s customer if the employee does not initiate contact or solicit that customer.
  • A non-low-wage employee could agree in writing to a time-limited ban on soliciting certain customers, but only customers with whom the employee had material contact, and only for similar products or services.
  • The proposed wording appears to let an employee—not only a low-wage employee—sue over an unlawful non-compete. A court could order remedies including an injunction, damages, lost compensation, liquidated damages, and legal fees.
  • Employers would have to post the law or a state-approved summary. The bill provides penalties for failing to post and a $10,000 civil penalty for each violation of the ban on non-competes for low-wage employees.

What it means for you#

  • Employees: The bill does not ban every non-compete. Under its wording, the ban covers low-wage employees and employees who do not perform any of the listed kinds of work. Employees outside those groups may still face non-competes.
  • Employees with customer relationships: A non-low-wage employee could agree to a written, time-limited customer non-solicitation restriction, limited to customers with whom they had material contact and to similar products or services. The bill’s definition also says an employee may serve an employer’s customer without initiating contact or soliciting the customer.
  • Employees considering a lawsuit: The proposed wording appears to allow any employee to sue over an unlawful covenant. The time limit is two years from the latest of the listed events, including signing, learning of the covenant, ending employment, or an enforcement step.
  • Employers: Employers would have to post the law or an approved summary. They could face penalties for violations and may have to pay court-ordered remedies and legal costs.
  • General public: The bill does not directly change taxes, benefits, or public services.

Money#

No publicly available information on the bill’s fiscal or compliance cost.

  • The bill authorizes civil penalties: $10,000 for each violation of the low-wage employee ban; for missing workplace notices, a written warning for the first violation, up to $250 for the second, and up to $1,000 for each later violation.
  • Courts could order employers or other people who attempt to enforce an unlawful covenant to pay remedies and legal costs. The bill provides no estimate of how often that would happen or what it would cost.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied bill text appears to combine old and proposed wording, including phrases such as “low-wage an employee.” The current Code section was not supplied, so the exact changes from current law cannot be verified.
  • The bill does not define key terms such as “material contact,” “high level,” or “selective or specialized skills.”
  • It does not set out how the Commissioner would decide violations or how employees would bring claims beyond the stated court action and time limit.
  • The bill says it applies to contracts entered into, amended, or renewed on or after July 1, 2026. How that rule would apply to particular existing agreements is not explained.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would protect low-wage employees and employees outside the listed customer-sales, management, key, and professional roles from restrictions on competing after leaving a job.
  • Allowing employees to serve a customer who contacts them, without the employee initiating contact or soliciting the customer, could limit restrictions on their ability to work.
  • The customer non-solicitation rule is limited to a stated period, customers the employee had material contact with, and similar products or services.
  • A civil action and penalties could give employees and the Commissioner ways to respond when employers violate the rules.

Case against#

  • One concern is that important terms, including “material contact” and parts of the “key employee” definition, are not precisely defined, which could leave disputes about who is covered.
  • The bill gives no details about how violations would be assessed or how the Commissioner would apply the penalties.
  • The proposed wording appears to broaden who may sue, but the merged text makes that change difficult to verify against current law.
  • Employers would have to meet posting requirements and could face penalties and court-ordered costs, but the bill provides no estimate of those costs.