Summary#
HCR-23 is a House concurrent resolution, not a bill that changes state law. It asks the Joint Committee on Government and Finance to study how West Virginia could provide more Firefighter I and II instruction; its stated goal is to address problems with firefighter recruitment, retention and training.
- The study is to identify areas with recruitment, retention or training problems.
- It is to consider the appropriate number and locations of Firefighter I and II education programs.
- It is to determine how many instructors should be employed statewide.
- It is to estimate the costs of establishing and sustaining the programs.
- The resolution says the study, report and drafting of necessary legislation would be paid for from legislative appropriations to the Joint Committee on Government and Finance.
What it means for you#
- Firefighters and fire departments: The resolution would not itself open training programs, hire instructors or change who can become a firefighter. It requests a study of where instruction and recruitment may be lacking.
- State lawmakers: If adopted, the Joint Committee on Government and Finance is asked to conduct the study, prepare a report and draft any legislation considered necessary.
- Residents and taxpayers: The resolution does not directly change 911 response, firefighter staffing or training. It also does not establish or fund the proposed training programs.
- The resolution is introduced and has not yet been adopted. Its passage is uncertain.
Money#
The resolution provides for study-related expenses from legislative appropriations, but gives no cost estimate.
- The study is to estimate what it would cost to establish and sustain training programs.
- No amount is specified for the study, report or legislation drafting.
- The resolution does not appropriate money to operate training programs or employ instructors.
What is unclear#
- It sets no deadline for the study or report.
- It does not specify how the committee must conduct the study or what evidence it must use.
- It does not define “appropriate” program locations, program numbers or instructor numbers.
- It does not say whether the committee must recommend particular programs or propose legislation.
- The materials do not provide current figures on training locations, instructors, costs or firefighter shortages. No publicly available information.
Case for#
- The study could identify where instruction is lacking before lawmakers decide whether or how to expand it.
- Considering program locations and instructor numbers statewide could help lawmakers compare different ways to provide more training.
- Estimating both start-up and ongoing costs could give lawmakers information about the financial commitment involved.
Case against#
- A study would not itself provide training or address delayed or unanswered 911 calls.
- The resolution sets no timeline, so it is unclear when lawmakers or the public would receive findings.
- It does not specify how the study will measure recruitment, retention or training needs, or how it will choose among possible solutions.
- Study expenses would use legislative appropriations, but the resolution gives no estimate of those expenses.