Legislature urges federal action on Star Act

Summary#

House Concurrent Resolution 30 asks the U.S. Congress to pass the federal Major Richard Star Act. It does not amend West Virginia or federal law; its stated goal is to end an offset between certain veterans’ Department of Defense retirement pay and Department of Veterans Affairs disability compensation. The resolution is introduced and referred to the House Rules Committee, so it has not been adopted.

  • The West Virginia Legislature would urge Congress to pass the named federal bill.
  • The House Clerk must send copies of the resolution to the President, Vice President, House Speaker, Senate Majority Leader, and West Virginia’s members of Congress.
  • The resolution describes the federal bill as expanding eligibility for veterans to receive retirement pay and disability compensation without an offset. The federal bill text is not included, so its detailed rules cannot be verified here.

What it means for you#

  • Veterans: This resolution would not change anyone’s benefits or eligibility. It asks Congress to act; any change to federal benefits would depend on federal legislation.
  • West Virginia’s members of Congress and other named federal officials: They would receive copies. The resolution does not require them to vote for the federal bill.
  • West Virginia residents: The resolution does not create a state program, benefit, tax, or new service.

Money#

The resolution provides no cost estimate for the federal bill or for forwarding copies.

  • It does not appropriate money or direct spending on a benefits program.
  • No publicly available information on the federal bill’s cost is included in the supplied material.

What is unclear#

  • The resolution says the federal bill would expand eligibility, but the federal bill text is not supplied. Its exact eligibility rules and benefit changes are unclear.
  • The resolution asserts that current federal law requires an offset for medically retired veterans with fewer than 20 years of service, and gives estimates of affected veterans and lost monthly benefits. Those claims cannot be checked against the underlying federal law or other supporting material here.
  • No publicly available information on the federal bill’s fiscal effects is included in the supplied material.

Case for#

  • The resolution’s case is that some medically retired veterans lose retirement pay because of an offset, even though the resolution says retirement pay and disability compensation recognize different forms of service and sacrifice.
  • If the federal bill addressed that offset as the resolution describes, it could increase compensation for veterans who meet its eligibility rules.
  • A state resolution can formally ask Congress to address the issue, while leaving the benefit rules to federal law.

Case against#

  • The resolution itself would not change veterans’ payments. Its effect depends on Congress passing separate federal legislation.
  • The federal bill’s detailed rules and costs are not provided, so it is not possible to assess who would qualify or the full financial effect.
  • The resolution does not explain how its estimates about affected veterans and lost benefits were calculated.