PFAS ban would curb product sales

Summary#

Wisconsin SB 1138, titled “Banning products containing intentionally added PFAS and providing a penalty,” failed and did not create these rules. It would have created a new section of state law, not amended an existing law. Its stated goal, reflected in its title, was to ban sales of products containing intentionally added PFAS in stages.

  • Starting January 1, 2032, sellers and distributors could not sell or distribute listed products containing intentionally added PFAS, including food packaging, cleaning products, cosmetics, juvenile products and textile furnishings. DNR could add product categories by rule.
  • By January 1, 2032, manufacturers of products containing intentionally added PFAS would have to give DNR product and manufacturer information, including the purpose and amount of each type of PFAS. They would have to update it for new products and significant changes.
  • DNR could require a manufacturer to provide PFAS test results within 30 days if the department had reason to believe a product contained intentionally added PFAS.
  • Starting January 1, 2038, sales and distribution of any product containing intentionally added PFAS would be prohibited unless DNR had found by rule that its use was unavoidable.
  • The bill exempted certain products and sales, including used products, firefighting foam regulated under another law, and specified medical products. It also allowed an exemption for uses DNR found unavoidable.
  • A person violating the 2032 or 2038 sales prohibitions would face a civil forfeiture of $100 per violating product, for each day the violation continued.

What it means for you#

  • Consumers: Because the bill failed, it does not change what products may be sold in Wisconsin. If it had passed, the listed products would have faced restrictions starting in 2032, followed by a broader ban in 2038, subject to exemptions.
  • Manufacturers: The bill would have required PFAS information for covered products and, when directed by DNR, test results within 30 days. The bill does not set a testing method.
  • Sellers and distributors: They would have been barred from selling or distributing products covered by the bans. Used-product sales would have been exempt.
  • DNR: The department could have added product categories, set dates for those added restrictions, identified unavoidable uses by rule, and directed manufacturers to test products.
  • Taxpayers: The bill did not set up a new agency or directly appropriate money. It would have assigned duties to DNR.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill would have required manufacturer reporting and could have required testing, but it provides no estimate of those costs.
  • It gives no estimate for DNR’s costs to make rules, receive information or direct testing. The bill source says a fiscal estimate would be printed as an appendix, but no estimate was supplied here.
  • The forfeiture is $100 per violating product per day; expected collections are not given.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “significant change” in manufacturer reporting or specify how PFAS testing must be done.
  • It allows DNR to request additional manufacturer information, but does not set limits or a process for those requests.
  • The bill does not explain how DNR would decide that a PFAS use is unavoidable beyond the definition in the bill, or how often such decisions would be reviewed.
  • It does not set out an application process, decision deadlines or appeals for exemption decisions.
  • The penalty section covers violations of the listed-product and broad 2038 bans, but does not expressly specify a penalty for violating a restriction DNR adds under the separate rulemaking power.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would first restrict named product categories, then apply a broader ban, giving manufacturers time before each start date.
  • Manufacturer disclosures and possible testing could give DNR information about which products contain intentionally added PFAS.
  • The unavoidable-use exemption and other listed exemptions could allow specified uses to continue where the bill’s conditions are met.
  • DNR’s power to add product categories could let the restrictions cover products beyond the initial list.

Case against#

  • The 2038 restriction would apply broadly to products containing intentionally added PFAS unless DNR found the use unavoidable; the bill does not require DNR to make that finding for any particular product.
  • Manufacturers could face reporting and testing costs, while the bill gives no cost estimate or testing standards.
  • Important decisions—including added product categories and unavoidable-use findings—would depend on DNR rules, whose process and timing are not detailed in the bill.
  • The bill does not expressly state a penalty for violating a restriction DNR adds under its separate power to prohibit additional categories.