Local bodies could set residency for senior staff

Summary#

Wisconsin SB 1181, titled Residency requirements for certain employees of a local governmental unit, would amend state law by repealing one provision and adding authority for certain local bodies to require some senior employees to live within their jurisdiction. Its stated subject is residency requirements; the bill does not state a broader goal. The bill failed, so it did not change the law.

  • A police, fire, or combined protective services department could require its chief to meet a residency requirement.
  • A city or village could require its administrator to meet one. A city or village that has elected, or is in the process of electing, a city manager could also require the manager to meet one.
  • A county without an elected county executive could require its county administrator to meet one; a school board could require its school district administrator to meet one.
  • Each body could set the requirement’s terms and conditions as it considers appropriate. The bill says the new provisions first apply to an individual hired on the effective date of the relevant provision.
  • The bill would also repeal section 64.09(3). The supplied materials do not show that provision’s text, so its separate effect cannot be verified.

What it means for you#

  • Local governments and school boards: The bill would give the listed bodies permission, not a duty, to set residency requirements for the named employees.
  • People in those jobs, or seeking them: If a listed body chose to set a requirement, it could affect where a covered employee would have to live. The bill does not establish a process for setting or enforcing the requirement.
  • Other public employees and residents: The bill does not directly change residency rules for other employees or create a general residency requirement.

Money#

No cost figure is included in the supplied material; the bill refers to a local fiscal estimate that is not provided here.

  • The bill authorizes residency requirements but does not require local bodies to impose them or specify spending, staffing, fees, or fines.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied text does not include the current wording of the provision the bill would repeal, so the effect of that repeal cannot be checked.
  • The bill leaves the terms and conditions of any residency requirement to the relevant body and gives no limits on them.
  • It does not set out how a body would adopt, apply, or enforce a requirement, or whether there would be an appeal process.
  • The applicability language says the changes first apply to an individual hired on the effective date of the relevant provision. The supplied text does not clarify how that applies to people hired later.
  • The bill failed, so it has no effective date and creates no current authority.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that local bodies could require certain senior officials to live in the communities they serve.
  • Giving the decision to the local body, rather than requiring residency statewide, would let each listed body decide whether a requirement suits its circumstances.

Case against#

  • The bill leaves the terms and conditions to each body’s judgment without setting limits or requiring a particular process.
  • A residency requirement could narrow who is able to take or keep one of these jobs; the bill does not explain how bodies should weigh that effect against local preferences.
  • The bill’s repeal provision cannot be assessed from the supplied materials, which do not include the text being repealed.