Grizzly bear actions curbed by bill

Summary#

SF-170, “Grizzly bear management prohibition,” would amend Wyoming’s Game and Fish law by adding limits on the Game and Fish Commission and Department. Its stated aim is to limit their grizzly bear management actions; the bill failed and is not law. The current text of the Act was not supplied, so I could not verify how the proposed rule would change existing powers.

  • The Commission and Department could not take or engage in grizzly bear management actions unless a statute expressly requires the action or it is necessary for public safety and welfare.
  • The restriction would last until grizzly bears are delisted in Wyoming under the federal Endangered Species Act and primary management is returned to the state.
  • The Commission would have to make rules needed to implement the bill.

What it means for you#

  • Wyoming Game and Fish Commission and Department: If the bill had become law, they would have been subject to the restriction and the Commission would have had to make implementing rules.
  • Wyoming residents and visitors: The bill does not create a new public service, benefit, fine, or individual right. It allows management action when necessary for public safety and welfare, but does not set out a process for making that decision.
  • General public: The bill failed, so it does not change current law.

Money#

No cost estimate is in the available material.

  • The bill requires the Commission to make rules, but gives no estimate for rulemaking or staffing costs.
  • No tax, fee, fine, or appropriation is specified.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “management actions or activities,” or explain how necessity for public safety and welfare would be determined.
  • It does not set out procedures, timelines, oversight, or appeals for decisions under the exceptions.
  • The text does not explain when delisting and the return of primary management to the state would be considered complete.
  • The current text of the amended law was not supplied, so the existing powers this proposal would restrict could not be checked.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that it would limit state agency action on grizzly bears until the stated federal delisting and return-of-management conditions are met.
  • The exceptions preserve actions expressly required by statute and actions necessary for public safety and welfare.
  • Requiring the Commission to make rules could provide implementation details, though the bill does not specify what those rules must contain.

Case against#

  • The restriction covers management actions and activities broadly, without defining those terms. It could therefore limit actions that are not expressly required by statute or considered necessary for public safety and welfare.
  • The bill does not explain who decides whether an action meets the safety-and-welfare exception or how that decision can be reviewed.
  • The restriction’s end depends on both federal delisting in Wyoming and primary management returning to the state, but the bill gives no process for determining when those conditions have been met.