Legislature Could Define Health Care

Summary#

SJ-7, “Right of health care access-separation of powers,” is a proposed amendment to the Wyoming Constitution, not a new health care program or a change to a specific medical service. It would give the legislature power to define “health care” for the constitutional right of health care access and say that laws regulating health care are reviewed by courts under the “rational basis” standard. Its stated goal is to clarify the legislature’s role and when it may regulate health care; the resolution failed, so it did not become law or go to voters.

  • The proposal would let the legislature—not the courts—define what counts as “health care” for this constitutional right.
  • It would make health care regulations subject to judicial review under the rational basis standard, with the bill text linking those laws to protecting health and general welfare or other purposes in the Wyoming Constitution.
  • It would not itself define health care, set specific restrictions, or change access to a named service.
  • The resolution proposed sending the amendment to voters at the next general election, but it failed before that could happen.

What it means for you#

  • Wyoming residents: Because SJ-7 failed, it did not change your constitutional rights or health care access.
  • Wyoming legislature: If voters had approved the amendment, the legislature could have defined “health care” for this right and enacted related laws. The proposal did not require the legislature to do so.
  • Courts: The proposal would have limited the courts’ role in defining “health care” for this right and specified rational basis review for health care regulations.
  • Current law: The supplied material says the Constitution gives each competent adult the right to make health care decisions. The current constitutional text was not supplied, so the exact change to its existing wording could not be verified.

Money#

No cost estimate or fiscal information is included in the supplied material. No publicly available information.

  • The proposal does not appropriate money, set fees or fines, or create a program or new agency.

What is unclear#

  • The amendment does not define “health care”; it would leave that definition to the legislature.
  • It does not say what limits, if any, the legislature would place on that definition.
  • It does not specify which health care laws might be enacted or how they would affect particular services or people.
  • The supplied material does not explain how courts would apply the rational basis standard to specific laws.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the amendment is that elected lawmakers, rather than courts, should decide what counts as health care for this constitutional right.
  • It could make the legislature’s authority to regulate health care clearer while leaving courts to review laws under the stated standard.
  • The proposal connects health care laws to protecting public health and general welfare, or to other purposes in the state Constitution.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the amendment leaves “health care” undefined, giving future legislatures room to set its scope.
  • Shifting the definition from courts to lawmakers could reduce the courts’ role in resolving disputes about what the constitutional right covers.
  • The proposal does not spell out limits on future health care laws or explain how the review standard would apply in particular cases.

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 1632454

    Passed31 members voted

    Failed Introduction 20-11-0-0-0

    FOR · 20AGAINST · 11

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    20For

    • Republican20

    11Against

    • Republican9
    • Democratic2