Federal Land Release Could Clear Forest Swap

Summary#

H.R. 5866, “To require the Secretary of Agriculture to release a reversionary interest in certain land in the Black River State Forest in Millston, Wisconsin, and for other purposes,” would create a one-time, conditional release of a federal interest in land. It does not amend another Act. Its stated goal is to allow a land exchange between Wisconsin and Deli, Inc., with Deli’s land added to the state forest.

  • If Wisconsin offers a written agreement to exchange about 31.83 acres of state forest land for about 37.27 acres owned or optioned by Deli, the United States’ reversionary interest in the state land must be released.
  • The Secretary of Agriculture must provide the State, as soon as possible, a quitclaim deed (a document releasing the United States’ interest) before the exchange deeds are recorded. The deed conveys any U.S. interest in the state land without payment to the United States.
  • The bill does not require Wisconsin to make the offer or require the exchange to be completed. The Deli land is defined as subject to approval by Wisconsin’s Department of Natural Resources, Natural Resources Board, and Governor.
  • The Secretary may make necessary corrections to the legal description of the state forest land, in consultation with Wisconsin.

What it means for you#

  • Wisconsin and Deli, Inc.: If Wisconsin makes the specified written offer, the federal release must follow. The bill itself does not transfer the land; the exchange would require conveyances by the State and Deli.
  • Black River State Forest: The exchange would add Deli’s land to the forest and allow the state forest land to be conveyed to Deli without the federal reversionary restriction. The current restriction requires that land to be used for public purposes in perpetuity.
  • The public: The bill does not set public-access rules for the land Deli would receive, or require the State to make the exchange. It describes certain existing easements and public water use on Lee Lake, but does not set broader access terms.
  • Federal government: The Agriculture Secretary would have a duty to provide the deed if the condition is met. The bill was introduced in the House and is not law; whether it passes is uncertain.

Money#

No cost estimate is available in the supplied material.

  • The United States would release its interest without consideration (without payment to the United States).
  • The bill gives no valuation of either parcel and does not say whether the land is equal in value.
  • The Secretary would have to prepare and provide a deed, but no administrative cost estimate or appropriation is stated. No publicly available information.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not require Wisconsin to make the offer or say what happens if the exchange is not completed after an offer.
  • It gives no deadline for the Secretary beyond “as expeditiously as possible.”
  • The bill does not provide parcel valuations or require equal acreage or equal value.
  • The referenced map is not included in the supplied material, so the parcel boundaries could not be checked against it.
  • The bill does not set public access, monitoring, or other conditions for the land conveyed to Deli beyond the listed easements and restrictions.

Case for#

  • A possible argument for the bill is that the exchange would add Deli’s approximately 37.27 acres to Black River State Forest.
  • Releasing the federal reversionary interest would remove a legal obstacle to Wisconsin’s proposed exchange, while the State would receive land for the forest in return.
  • The bill makes the release conditional on a written exchange offer and requires the federal deed to be provided before the exchange deeds are recorded.

Case against#

  • One concern is that land currently subject to a requirement for public use in perpetuity could be conveyed to a private business without that federal restriction.
  • The bill does not require a public-access condition for the land Deli would receive or establish a process for public input.
  • The bill does not require an appraisal or explain whether the parcels are comparable in value; their stated acreages are also different.
  • The release is required once Wisconsin makes the specified offer, but the bill sets no deadline for the overall exchange to be completed.