USDA Would Fund Forest Conservation Easements

Summary#

The Forest Conservation Easement Program Act of 2025 would amend the Food Security Act of 1985 and repeal the Healthy Forests Reserve Program in a separate law. It would require the Agriculture Secretary to establish a new program that funds forest conservation easements and related work. Its stated goals include protecting working forests and forest habitats; those goals are not guaranteed results. The bill is at an early stage and is not law.

  • USDA would help eligible state and local agencies, Tribes, and conservation organizations buy forest land easements. The landowner would keep the right to continue forest production and related uses under a forest management plan.
  • USDA would also acquire forest reserve easements directly from landowners, including Tribal landowners. These are for eligible land where conservation would benefit specified threatened, endangered, or at-risk species.
  • Forest reserve easements would require a plan developed jointly by the landowner and the Secretary. USDA would have to provide financial and technical assistance for the plan’s conservation work.
  • Federal cost-sharing for forest land easements would generally be 50% of fair market value, and could be up to 75% for certain forests or land owned by socially disadvantaged forest landowners. For forest reserve easements, compensation and some project payments depend on the easement’s duration and type.
  • The bill would preserve existing Healthy Forests Reserve Program agreements, easements, payments, and assistance, while moving the program into a new legal structure. It would also give the Secretary limited powers to subordinate, modify, exchange, or terminate easement interests, with stated conditions and required consent for each action.

What it means for you#

  • Private and Tribal forest landowners: The bill does not take land or require an owner to participate. An owner would have to make an offer for a forest reserve easement, or work with an eligible entity applying for a forest land easement. Easements must allow continued forest production and related uses under applicable plans.
  • Landowners in the reserve program: For a permanent easement, payment would equal the difference between the land’s fair market value before and after the easement. For other allowed terms, compensation would be 50% to 75% of that amount. USDA would also fund eligible plan activities, subject to a $500,000 limit per easement or contract.
  • Eligible agencies, Tribes, and conservation organizations: They could apply for federal cost-share funding to buy forest land easements. They would need to provide the non-federal share, which can include cash, a landowner donation, and certain transaction costs.
  • Landowners and easement holders: Forest management plans and easement terms would set limits and duties. For forest land easements, the Secretary’s enforcement right could be used only if the eligible entity does not enforce the terms. Inspections by the Secretary are limited to specified circumstances and require advance notice and an opportunity for the entity and landowner to take part.
  • General public: The bill does not itself require public access to enrolled land.

Money#

The bill authorizes up to $100 million per year for fiscal years 2025 through 2029, but does not itself appropriate that money. No publicly available information on an estimated total program cost is in the supplied material.

  • The federal share of a forest land easement would usually be 50% of its fair market value, and could be no more than 75% in specified cases. The eligible entity must provide the balance.
  • USDA payments for forest reserve easement plans would vary by easement type and are capped at $500,000 per easement or contract.
  • The bill allows certain prior-year funds to support existing Healthy Forests Reserve agreements. It does not state the amount available.

What is unclear#

  • The current text of the Food Security Act and Healthy Forests Restoration Act was not supplied, so the exact differences from current law cannot be independently checked beyond the changes and transition rules stated in this bill.
  • Congress would still need to provide funds. The bill does not say how much would actually be appropriated or how funds would be divided between the two easement types.
  • The Secretary would set application requirements and selection criteria. The bill does not set application timelines, appeal rights, or a reporting schedule.
  • Some terms, including “working forest” and “forest of special environmental significance,” are not defined in the bill.
  • The bill allows existing Healthy Forests Reserve Program land to count as enrolled in the new program, but does not explain how the programs’ rules would interact in every case.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to protect forests from conversion to nonforest uses while allowing continued forest production.
  • A possible argument for using easements is that they can protect land and habitat without requiring the landowner to give up all forest-related uses.
  • Federal cost-sharing and technical assistance could help eligible entities and landowners take on conservation work that requires substantial planning or expense.
  • The reserve easement priorities focus first on benefits to endangered or threatened species, while also allowing consideration of biodiversity, forest restoration, and carbon storage.

Case against#

  • One concern is that the bill authorizes significant federal spending but does not provide a cost estimate or guarantee that Congress will fund the program.
  • Selection rules and several key terms would be left to the Secretary, so applicants may not know in advance how proposals will be ranked or what standards will apply.
  • The bill allows forest production and, in some cases, subsurface mineral development on easement land. That could create trade-offs between continued land use and conservation goals.
  • A possible trade-off is that the Secretary could approve changes to, exchanges of, or termination of easement interests under specified conditions. Consent is required, but the bill leaves important judgments—such as whether an action is in the public interest—to the Secretary.