Legislative Assembly of Ontario · Committee

Monday, August 10, 2026

Standing Committee on the Interior

The official transcript of the meeting, from Hansard, by heading. Ministers, officials and witnesses appear as the transcript names them; committees have no live transcript, so the record appears once the Assembly publishes it.

Monday, August 10, 2026

Read from the beginning of the meeting

Meeting ended

Bonnefield Financial Inc.; Keystone Farmland; Chatham-Kent Chamber of Commerce

04:31:35Official transcript

Mr. Rory Ring

I think it goes a lot to the comments I made with MPP McCrimmon. It’s, again, to take a look at this sector as an investment in business and the economy. Sarnia–Lambton will have the most commonality of industry with Chatham-Kent. But when you look at Sault Ste. Marie—I was up there for eight and a half years—it’s obviously a very different kind of agriculture that’s required up there. This year, they had 20 feet of snow; summer is like 60 days. But it is a different kind of agriculture. What you’re seeing there is the smaller, micro-based, if you like. A lot of cheese is being produced; honey; things like chaga, which is from a birch tree for medicinal purposes; and very much so, a lot of traditional type of agriculture based on the Indigenous culture. There’s a lot of learning that can be done to advance that. Obviously, the discussion around climate change as well can influence, if you like, an investment in northern Ontario in the agricultural sector, but there’s also lots of opportunity there to explore those innovations and the technology that would allow more food sustainability and security in northern Ontario. I know you know that Sault Ste. Marie is just the beginning of the north. There is a vast geography that many of us in southern Ontario would not understand. So there are going to be some very interesting innovations and technology solutions that are going to be available for that. And then that goes back: Where are you going to find the capital? Let’s be frank: Traditional capital sources in Canada are risk averse. We need that access to capital. I think both the Ontario Chamber of Commerce and the Canadian Chamber of Commerce have addressed this issue at various levels around access to capital being important for innovation and the development of technologies to advance our economy, and I think that’s going to be incredibly required in northern Ontario specifically, again, because of the conditions of those communities, whether they be remote communities or even small-city urban like Sault Ste. Marie. Bill 109 has to make sure that especially the investment side and the source of capital has to understand that capital may not just be to grow product but to process it, add value to it or invest in technologies that allow for that sustainability. That’s where, around that limitation of available capital, it has to be well-defined. It has to be acknowledged that there are friendly sources of capital and there are those that are here to take advantage. We know that. It’s obviously one of the catalysts for this type of legislation. We want to make sure we’re not throwing that baby out with the bathwater. For northern Ontario, I think this is absolutely critical as they start to look at where they will find the sources of capital, because food security up there also is northern sovereignty—northern security, if you like, as well. Because if we are looking to defend the north, we still have to feed those people. We still have to make it economical to feed those individuals that will be securing the north, and right now, it’s a huge challenge. Think about paying $20 for a loaf of bread in the Far North. So there is connectivity. There is connectivity here with 109 and the capital sources that would be required to invest in the innovations, the technology, the transportation—any of those alternatives that can help support the north.

Official source

04:35:09Official transcript

Mr. Steve Pinsonneault

That was actually an amazing answer. It’s nice to get your perspective. Being at Sault Ste. Marie, like you said, you are a long way up north. I know when we were in Timmins there, they were talking about—now, with genetics, they’re growing cash crops up there now. Things are moving forward, and in 10 years from now, it’ll amazing to see what can be grown even farther north, up to Sault Ste. Marie and as far as you want to go up. But that’s all coming in time, I’m sure. Anyway, thanks for the answer.

Official source

04:35:40Official transcript

Mr. Rory Ring

Absolutely, and there is great demand. We even see, in northern Ontario, the brand—just the Canada brand, even just the Ontario brand. I think Richard probably referred to it as well. It captures the imagination in the global markets.

Official source

04:35:56Official transcript

Mr. Rory Ring

That value-added piece is, I think, incredibly important. Again, just to circle back, if you like, the access to capital to allow that to happen is incredibly important.

Official source

04:36:10Official transcript

MPP Paul Vickers

Just a quick question for Rory: You talked about the interest people retiring out of agriculture. When we’re bringing the rules and regulations around Bill 109, who should we make sure is well looked after, the people that are staying in the industry or the people retiring out of the industry?

Official source

04:36:28Official transcript

Mr. Rory Ring

I think both of these gentlemen—you can just tell by the difference in our ages. This should be the focus of the future: the next generation. Obviously, we have to recognize the commitment that the previous generations have made to making agriculture—and what it means to Canada’s sovereignty over the generations. You need to be able to recognize that. You also need to understand that we’re going to saddle them with one hell of a tax bill when they sell their farm.

Official source

04:36:57Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

And that concludes the government’s time. We’ll move on to the official opposition. MPP Vanthof, floor is yours.

Official source

04:37:04Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

I’m really enjoying this conversation. I’d just like to go back to you for a second, Sean. I don’t think your model is actually the problem, but what’s happening is your model is moving the needle so fast that it’s identifying that there’s going to be a bigger problem. Farm consolidation—the farms that are benefiting from that could very well be 20 miles away. The tiling and the irrigation ponds do not help the infrastructure in that township, the next township or the next township, and that’s something the government is going to have to deal with. I come from northern Ontario. As we talk about developing northern Ontario, that is going to be a big issue. Somebody is going to have to step up to pay for those municipal drains, because they’re not going to get paid. They’re not going to get done. The townships don’t have the wherewithal. One thing I heard you say, Rory—I actually agree; you might be surprised. It doesn’t really bother me where the investment is coming from as long as the rules are in place to protect the farmland itself. And that’s actually not where this bill is going; this bill is concentrating on the investment. We agree with the bill, but it’s not actually concentrating on protecting the farmland itself. Would you agree with that?

Official source

04:38:24Official transcript

Mr. Mitch King

Just to add one thing: I think consolidation in the agriculture industry has been happening since it started, very similar to many other industries where scale and efficiencies are required in order to compete in such a low-margin business. We draw adjacencies to some of the Prairie provinces that maybe have some more restrictive ownership restrictions. And in those jurisdictions, we actually see greater rates of consolidation because it is the ultra-large farms that have that equity base, that can go out and acquire those two quarters when they come up for sale. So our feeling is that supporting young farmers, as Sean said, or supporting those smaller and mid-sized operations that don’t have the equity on their balance sheet to grow, that’s the hope with our model—that we can still provide that strength to that middle sector of the size range, let’s say, to be able to, again, contribute to those communities. But I do think it’s an issue that needs to have larger discussion around rural economic development and what that means, not only in northern Ontario, southwestern Ontario, but across the country, because there are fewer farmers today than there were 10 years ago, and I believe the same will be true 10 years from now. So let’s be realistic about that reality that we are facing and have these discussions, like we are here today, about what can be done to still be able to provide the infrastructure that we need for those farms and the other people that live in those communities to still thrive.

Official source

04:40:04Official transcript

Mr. Rory Ring

Just to reflect on you’re “building a drain” and “no economic impact:” Economic impact shows that if you invest a dollar in an agricultural business, you actually generate $3 in economic activity. So there is a contractor who is going to dig that drain out; there’s going to be a contractor that’s going to fill it with stone; there’s going to be a contractor that did the engineering; there’s going to be a contractor that did the environmental. So there is an impact on that investment, but I do agree with you 110%, it’s very difficult for the property taxpayer to pay to make that investment. It needs to be rethought.

Official source

04:40:50Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

Certainly, as this committee has spent a bit of time talking about developing even farther north that me—and there is lots of potential. I’m proud to be a farmer in northern Ontario—made my living there, proud of it, but the model that developed this area and developed the Little Clay Belt is not going to work farther north. It’s not. Because it’s not going to be 160 acres with a little barn and a homestead; it’s not going to be that. But that’s still what’s kind of in the mindset, I think. And you very well know it’s not going to be that; I know it’s not going to be that. I’m not sure, actually, that the government has really figured this out. And I’m not trying to be controversial or anything. That’s why I’m bringing this up, because I’m the one right now—actually, no, the municipal council is the one right now dealing with the destruction of their model. And I’m still saying he’s got to go and hand in the keys. It’s not directly your fault. It isn’t, right? Because those people sold—and I don’t want my farmland price to drop by half either, and that very well could happen if your model stops. That’s an issue. So I know you don’t have the answer, and I’m not expecting you to come up with the answer, but would you agree—all three of you—that that is an issue, that that is going to impact us?

Official source

04:42:30Official transcript

Mr. Sean Dobbelaar

I’ll step in if it’s appropriate. We do not actively invest in northern Ontario today, but I’m certainly very familiar with northern Ontario, having hunted, fished up there with many friends. It’s beautiful. And it is something I hear quite often, Temiskaming Shores—doesn’t matter where you’re at, right?

Official source

04:42:54Official transcript

Mr. Sean Dobbelaar

It doesn’t matter where you’re from in northern Ontario; there is a huge infrastructure gap. And if Bill 109, specifically around the development of the Clay Belt, is not handled correctly, there is going to be huge downward pressure on local townships and municipalities, and they are going to need both provincial and federal support to develop that infrastructure, because it cannot be borne on the back of the taxpayer 100%. I also want to make a comment about—20 miles away or however many miles away—most of our farmers that are renting our land are living in these communities. They’re not coming from multiple hours away to farm these assets. Everybody buys fertilizer for roughly the same price. Everyone pays—

Official source

04:43:48Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

And that concludes the official opposition’s time. We’ll move to the third party. MPP McCrimmon, the floor is yours.

Official source

04:43:57Official transcript

Mrs. Karen McCrimmon

This is both for Mr. King and Mr. Dobbelaar: What we want is that we want access to responsible, long-term credit for farms, but that at the same time protects that farmland and keeps it in Canadian hands. So can you tell me: Does your model achieve that?

Official source

04:44:17Official transcript

Mr. Mitch King

Yes. I would agree—I would agree. And even, as it has over the last number of years for us, the source of the capital, whether it comes from a Canadian individual investor or a Canadian institutional investor—we don’t treat that any differently, and we feel that the way that that limited partnership is set up provides those safeguards, because they really are passive investors. And I think that’s also just around some of our recommendations on relying on that Investment Canada Act, which is legislation that already exists, to help to kind of direct the direction that we want to go in with the final version of Bill 109, which will provide those protections and ensure that, whether or not the source of the capital, it’s controlled by a Canadian-owned and Canadian-managed organization. For us, that is the really, really critical piece here.

Official source

04:45:20Official transcript

Mr. Sean Dobbelaar

We’re providing that capital that is needed to not only protect this farmland, but enhance the value creation it has. So again, transitioning it to higher-value crops—there were comments of more soybeans in northern Ontario. Often, in some cases, we’re providing land-lease financing, because at the traditional financing levels, you would not believe in a business plan. And so, they’re looking at a farmland asset that’s giving an X cash return. They go to their local credit union, the bank, the crown corporation—literally farm credit—and they don’t believe in the business plan. But they believe in the business plan, and often it is value creation, so it could be expanding a processing line; it could be expanding a livestock business to do direct-to-consumer in northern Ontario. These folks know the industry. They know where the returns are, and if they can’t have what I think is a very—remember, I lived in this world, in both the crown corporation and a top-five bank. There is not a lot of risk that’s taken on. Those that need the money do not get the money; those that don’t need the money, they’re opening up the golden gate and welcoming them in. So again, if we don’t have the proper programs, the proper support, the proper forms of capital to support farmers in developing and adding additional value—really, this is all about value creation. It’s about keeping a few more jobs in Temiskaming Shores; it’s about supporting contractors to improve the value of the land and the productive capacity. All we are is another form of capital, but we’re not some big, bad, foreign actor; we’re managing this farmland responsibly, with local operators. We don’t take any sort of control over how they grow their crops, who they sell their crops to, what colour of machinery they run on the farm. We are only providing land-lease financing. Our tenants—and I can’t speak for Mitch’s business, but I can tell you that often, we are not taking the top bidder on our farmland. We are looking for people who are strategically aligned in how we run our business. That means soil-sampling the land as soon as we acquire it, identifying ways that we can improve it from an environmental standpoint, from a productivity standpoint. We want farmers that are incorporating cover crops, that are incorporating proper crop rotations, that have the succession plans. I want to be very clear in our model. If we remove this capital, it is going to be detrimental to our industry, to our productive capacity as a province and to, most importantly, our young farmers, who, again, are going to be the ones that pick up the torch and continue to carry on this $50-billion-plus-a-year industry.

Official source

04:48:40Official transcript

Mrs. Karen McCrimmon

Okay. Just a quick one, Mr. King: You referred to, in the act, where it’s proposed “directly and indirectly.” You say the use of the word “indirectly” gives you some concern. Is there an alternative, or do we just take the word “indirectly” out of that?

Official source

04:48:59Official transcript

Mr. Mitch King

We did provide, I think, our exact recommendations around the wording or how we would like to change those designations. I don’t have them off the top of my head here, but I know our compliance department would be more than happy to provide those to you again.

Official source

04:49:22Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

Thank you very much. That concludes this round of presentations, so thank you so much for your preparation and for being here today.

Official source

Ms. Monique Spanjers; Ms. Geraldine Pennings

04:49:32Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

We will move onto our next round. An advisory for the members: We have an additional presenter, Geraldine Pennings, who will be joining Monique Spanjers in the next round. So I will call up Ms. Spanjers and Ms. Pennings to the floor. I’ll ask all members to return to their seats. I will now call on Monique Spanjers. Please state your name for Hansard and you may begin.

Official source

04:50:00Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

Good afternoon, Chair and members of the committee. Thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak today about Bill 109. My name is Monique Spanjers. I was a dairy cow farmer for 20 years in the Netherlands, and for the past 11 years I have been a dairy goat farmer here in Ontario. Farming has always been a big part of my life. What I enjoy most is working with my animals and taking care of them. Over time in the Netherlands though, more and more of my time was spent on paperwork, protocols and regulations, and less time was spent actually farming. That was one of the reasons for me to move to Canada. I’m not against regulations. Good regulation is important, but it has to make sense in practice and fit in the reality of the farm. Because I have worked in both cow dairy and goat dairy, I also know how different these two sectors are. What works for dairy cows does not automatically work for dairy goats. We saw that recently with the somatic cell count regulations. Concerned dairy goat farmers and Ontario Goat raised concerns because goat milk is biologically different from cow milk and needs to be looked at using goat-specific science. Government listened and paused SCC penalties while the issue is being reviewed. To me, that is a good example of why regulation should be developed with real producer input—before they are put in place, not afterwards. I believe the same kind of reality check should now be applied to the establishment of the Dairy Goat Farmers of Ontario. Recently, dairy goat farmers were asked through an expression-of-opinion vote whether they supported the creation of DGFO. What was presented to producers was an organization built around four main pillars: advocacy, business risk management, research and education, and consumer awareness. But Bill 109 could create a framework where DGFO may later receive authorities that go well beyond those four pillars. Those possible authorities were not part of what producers were asked to support. DGFO could potentially be empowered to enter and inspect farms, demand and review farm records, take and test milk samples, detain or dispose of milk, administer penalties, collect money owed, influence compliance and licensing consequences. Bill 109 does not automatically give DGFO all these authorities, but it creates the possibilities that some of them could be delegated later. This is a serious issue because dairy goats are not supply managed. We operate in a competitive market. Every producer has to find and negotiate their own market. A future DGFO would be run by fellow dairy goat farmers. They are our colleagues but they also are our competitors. I do not think dairy goat farmers should be inspecting each others’ farms or have access to sensitive business information that could affect another farmer’s negotiation position. There is also a concern about the independence. The process leading to DGFO has to a large extent been driven by two main milk brokers in the Ontario dairy goat industry, and those brokers are still providing administrative support to the development committee. If DGFO could later receive inspection, information-gathering or enforcement powers, producers need to be confident that the organization is truly independent from commercial interests. Right now, dairy goat producers are being asked to fund and accept a mandatory organization before we even know what regulatory inspection, enforcement or financial authorities may eventually be attached to it. I do not think government should establish a mandatory organization first and figure out its authorities afterwards. In my view, DGFO should be paused until Bill 109 has completed the legislative process and the regulatory framework is clear. My request to this committee is simple. First, pause the establishment of DGFO until the bill is finalized. Second, once the possible authorities are clear, go back to the dairy goat producers and have a new and transparent consultation about whether DGFO is still something producers want and need. Third, make sure dairy goat regulations are actually designed for the dairy goat sector and are not simply adapted from cow dairy. If dairy goat producers do not support a mandatory DGFO once its possible authorities are fully understood, then government should not move forward with it. I would also like to invite the Minister of Agriculture, Food and Agribusiness, Trevor Jones, to meet directly with concerned dairy goat farmers and not only with sector stakeholders who may have commercial interests in our industry. We are the dairy goat farms who will have to live with these regulations every day.

Official source

04:54:44Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

We are the ones who can explain from first-hand experience how they will affect our farms. In short, talk to us and hear what we are saying. Thank you for your time and consideration.

Official source

04:54:56Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

Thank you very much for the presentation. We will move forward with Geraldine Pennings. The floor is yours; you will have seven minutes.

Official source

04:55:04Official transcript

Ms. Geraldine Pennings

Good afternoon and thank you for the invitation to speak to this committee about Bill 109, Protecting Ontario’s Food Independence Act. I appreciate this opportunity to explain the effects this bill may have on the Ontario dairy goat industry. I have been a dairy goat farmer since 2013. Growing up, I worked on my family’s 400-head meat goat operation. My husband came from a cow dairy background and so we combined our experience and became goat milk producers. Out of 198 goat dairy farmers in Ontario, approximately 90 farms sell to Gay Lea Foods, another 90 ship with the ODGC and the other 18 to 20 producers sell independently or process their own milk. The two main brokers, both Gay Lea Foods and the Ontario Dairy Goat Co-operative, buy and sell milk from 90% of Ontario’s dairy goat farmers. Over the past five to seven years, I have noticed a discernable shift in the attitudes and priorities of the main dairyers in our industry. Their mandate is to negotiate a fair price for their members and sell the members’ milk. But lately, these brokers are acting like they represent the interest of the farmers in their co-operatives. More than that, over the last year and a half, the two main brokers are proposing a new start-up organization to act in the best interest of dairy goat farmers. The Dairy Goat Farmers of Ontario was initially proposed as a response to the tariff threat from the United States. The fear of goat milk being penalized along with cow milk prompted widespread concern that the goat milk industry could be decimated overnight. We are not supply-managed, we do not have a guaranteed income, and we cannot shut off the supply of milk like a tap. The tariff threat was both an economic issue and an animal welfare crisis. During the CETA negotiations, access to the cheese market was expanded for importers. Goat cheese sales were impacted by this agreement, but government compensation money went only to cow dairy farmers, not goat dairies. During a joint membership meeting between ODGC and the Gay Lea Co-operative, it was decided to petition the government to move goat milk out from under the cow milk HS code. When the threatened 250% tariff on milk products failed to be implemented, goat milk farmers relaxed. We still wanted the HS code changed, but the urgency lessened. Dairy Goat Farmers of Ontario was relegated to the background with the understanding that it was still lobbying agricultural officials for the change in HS code. It was a surprise when the proponents of Dairy Goat Farmers of Ontario—the original four members of Ontario Dairy Goat Co-operative and four members of Gay Lea—brought forward a proposal requesting appointment as a local board to collect a licence fee on every litre of goat milk produced in Ontario with the intent of setting up an office, hiring a business manager, funding research, educating farmers and consumers, and advocating on behalf of all of Ontario’s dairy goat farmers. Dairy Goat Farmers of Ontario propaganda claims that it was initiated by farmers, will be led by a board of farmers and will work for farmers. In June of this year, the Honourable Trevor Jones approved the formation of DGFO, but he approved it as a marketing board. I would like to quote from an address given by the agricultural minister, the Honourable Trevor Jones. He said: “Consultation and collaboration with those who work every day to feed our province is integral to the development of good legislation. I am proud that the measures of the Protecting Ontario’s Food Independence Act were informed by our very farmers and food producers.” But I believe the Honourable Trevor Jones is mistaken. While he thought he was talking to farmers and food producers, he may have actually been speaking with the mouthpiece for the two largest brokers in the goat milk industry. Goat farmers voted in favour of a local board. The agricultural minister approved a marketing board. Goat farmers voted based on a proposal put forward by the DGFO working committee, but we have since learned that the Ontario Farm Products Marketing Commission will decide what authoritative powers DGFO will be given. Bill 109 proposes to set out a framework to support administration and enforcement, inspection, investigation and compliance. It also specifies offences under the act with regards to records, quality and associated penalties. Bill 109 is a mechanism for the ag minister to place more authority with the commission, who will then be able to expand the powers of the Dairy Goat Farmers of Ontario to inspect our farms, investigate our records for births, deaths, treatments, tagging and traceability requirements, movement reporting. They will demand our milk volumes, enforce SCC testing based on thresholds that do not apply to goat milk and demand compliance through penalties.

Official source

05:00:02Official transcript

Ms. Geraldine Pennings

Oh. Dairy Goat Farmers of Ontario will be spearheaded by select members of the two largest for-profit brokers in Ontario. The general managers of those two brokers are now and will be leading the organization. These general managers are employed by the brokers. Bill 109 is proposing to give extraordinary oversight of dairy goat farmers’ businesses and will give enforcement powers to a sham organization which is merely a front for two brokers who are competitors and who set prices for 90% of the goat milk farmers in Ontario. That is creating a monopoly. When authority moves to a single organization, it leads to less collective responsibility, less scrutiny, less transparency. Allowing Bill 109 to give Gay Lea Foods and the Ontario—

Official source

05:01:46Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

That concludes your time. Thank you so much for your presentation, Ms. Pennings, and you will be getting some questions, I am sure, from the members. We’ll move to the official opposition. MPP Vanthof, the floor is yours.

Official source

05:02:18Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

Thank you, both of you, for coming to the committee. I think you’ve given all of us a lot of new information. My background is—I am a dairy farmer. Before I had this job, I had an honourable job; I was a dairy farmer. I was kind of keeping track. Was there a vote among all goat producers to create Dairy Goat Farmers of Ontario?

Official source

05:03:04Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

Yes, there was a vote. But 60% of dairy goat farmers are Amish and Mennonites, and they don’t vote because of culture or religious reasons. So 60% did not vote. The other 40% did vote, but we don’t know the exact results of this vote. We asked if we could see how many were in favour and how many leaders were in favour. But the commission is not giving that information.

Official source

05:03:56Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

Okay. So, if I heard you correctly, 60% of goat milk producers are Amish?

Official source

05:04:07Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

Yes—or Mennonites. The way this voting works is that somebody that does not vote is actually a yes voter. Because the remaining that vote only need 66% of that amount, so it could be that there are only 25 in favour and they decide for 200.

Official source

05:04:41Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

I’m not trying to be facetious but that’s how provincial elections work too.

Official source

05:04:51Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

Yes. But in our case, when you have 60% Amish and Mennonites—which everybody knows they are not really into regulations from government—they are automatically counted as a yes vote.

Official source

05:05:17Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

Forgive my ignorance. When I was a dairy producer, the regs were set by Dairy Farmers of Ontario and enforcement was done by Dairy Farmers of Ontario. Who sets your regs now? Are there inspections now?

Official source

05:05:50Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

Okay. And under this proposal, it would go to Dairy Goat Farmers of Ontario?

Official source

05:06:01Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

OMAFA at this moment has a problem. They cannot monetarily penalize us because we don’t have an organization under OMAFA. Our association, Ontario Goat, is totally separate from the column in which OMAFA is. So they kind of need Dairy Goat Farmers of Ontario so they can start penalizing us. Our penalization now goes to our milk progress. They penalize us on the quality. That money goes into the brokers. That will be taken out and going to this new organization. So the brokers are going to have a hard time too.

Official source

05:07:13Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

Okay. I’m just trying to get this through my head. In your estimation, the brokers are the two main groups who are pushing for this to happen?

Official source

05:07:34Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

Yes. It’s even this way that, in the annual report of 2025 of Gay Lea, it is stated that their business department came up with this idea and has pushed it forward. So it did not start from the goat farmers. They just selected some goat farmers among their members that they could use to get this through. There are even processes behind this.

Official source

05:08:30Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

No. I’m an independent, so I don’t belong to any of those two brokers. That places me in a very vulnerable position because these brokers try to get us out of the business and get our market.

Official source

05:08:57Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

We’re just five farmers and we, together, negotiate with a processor. But there are only a few processors in Ontario. So, if one broker comes along that represents 90 members, they try to push us out. And if they get control of this DGFO, I will never be a board member in this new organization because I have maybe four other farmers that will vote for me. Everybody has got to pick out of their own team, so we’re just shoved to the side.

Official source

05:10:00Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

I can’t speak for the government—I’m in the opposition—but not all parts of a bill have to be enacted right away. That happens with other bills too. Bills are passed, and portions of them aren’t enacted. So let’s just hypothetically say that that isn’t enacted. If that in Bill 109 isn’t enacted, what power does DGFO have now?

Official source

05:10:28Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

They say they only are going to do the four pillars—advocacy, consumer awareness, research and education, and business risk management, I think, off the top of my head—but the fact that this is hanging above us is like the sword of Damocles.

Official source

05:10:51Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

We’ll move to the third party. MPP McCrimmon, the floor is yours.

Official source

05:10:56Official transcript

Mrs. Karen McCrimmon

Thank you both for being here. I’m trying to look at the bill and find out exactly where it fits in the bill, but I can do that later. First of all, this is an awesome summary. This is exactly like a two-pager, actually. You put your issue down quite clearly, and we know what you want. I would ask Geraldine, have you seen this? Had you seen this before you came?

Official source

05:11:28Official transcript

Mrs. Karen McCrimmon

So you agree with how Monique has presented this and what your aim for is here at the committee, what you’re asking for?

Official source

05:11:39Official transcript

Mrs. Karen McCrimmon

Okay. Well, that makes it really easy for me, and I hope it makes it easier for the government side as well. I think this is what you’re trying to say: You want to have a say.

Official source

05:11:54Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

Especially because we don’t have a government supporting us. For example, traceability is now an issue at the moment. It’s going to be forced upon us. Cow farmers say, “It’s just a little bit,” but a cow farmer has one cow producing 30 litres, for example. For that amount, we have 10 goats. You put a $4 tag in one cow; for the same amount of litres, we have to spend $40. That works everywhere, in everything we do. We are a niche market. Goat milk tastes different than cow milk. If it didn’t, why would we milk goats? Because the cow milk is way easier. I have been a farmer for 20 years. I thought I knew something when I came here. I started to raise goats. I knew nothing; they are totally different. That’s what I want to make clear to a committee like this. We are not cow farmers. If you talk with a cow farmer about SCC, they say, “Oh, that’s mastitis.” In goats, it’s not. There are 10 reasons why goats will have a raised SCC, and only one of them is mastitis. In the rest it’s stress, it’s breed, it’s seasonal. If you chase a dog into a pen, our SCC is going to be through the roof the next day. We will be penalized for that, so we might as well shoot our dogs. You know what I mean?

Official source

05:13:40Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

They just put, “Oh, it’s already for years in cows.” Milk is milk. If it’s cold and white, it should be milk, but it could be snow.

Official source

05:13:51Official transcript

Mrs. Karen McCrimmon

But you rely upon your reputation, I would imagine, especially as a small goat milk farmer.

Official source

05:14:01Official transcript

Mrs. Karen McCrimmon

That’s right. So if your milk wasn’t up to standard, you would lose your customers, right?

Official source

05:14:09Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

We have to stand out in quality, the five of us—we have to stand out. We have the processes; you need to ask for the milk because it’s such a high quality. We want to go to a pick-up like cow farmers—every other day—because it will make our quality go up, but to do that, we need to have a certain amount in the tank because transportation is going through the roof at the moment.

Official source

05:14:42Official transcript

Mrs. Karen McCrimmon

Okay. So if they put 109 through the way it’s currently written, you want to have a new vote on whether to have the DGFO. Is that right?

Official source

05:14:54Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

Yes, and I want the farmers to be educated on what it can do because thus far, it has been stripped from all the things the two brokers didn’t want. You could ask that, but it was always, “No, that’s not the case. That cannot happen.” But this bill shows us that it can happen. I want the other farmers to realize what can happen, what they will be regulated upon. I worry about our Amish and Mennonite goat farmers. We have farmers that cool milk with ice. Will that still be allowed if this bill goes through? We have goat farmers that have a dripping system to make their agitator go around. It’s the charm from our sector. If we get regulated like cow farmers, the whole niche and the charm will disappear.

Official source

05:15:56Official transcript

Mrs. Karen McCrimmon

All right. And people count on you to produce a quality product. How much more difficult would this make your ability to create that quality product?

Official source

05:16:09Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

It’s not that our quality is an issue with this establishment; it is the oversight that my fellow farms will have of my farm. I have to bargain for my milk price.

Official source

05:16:25Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

If I need to put information into an organization—how many goats I have, how much milk I produce, how much open capacity I have—they know exactly what we’re doing. They know how much we supply. They know how much market there is for them to gain. It’s not that they will do that, but as my mom said, “If you tie a cat on the bacon, it might take a bite out of it.”

Official source

05:16:57Official transcript

Mrs. Karen McCrimmon

All right. Thank you. It’s so important to have people that are on the ground to come here and tell us exactly what’s happening because, of course, we’re influenced by brokers who have lots of know-how, lots of money, and we have to make the effort. So thank you for coming today because that’s the only way we’re going to find out, is if you come and tell us the rest of the story. Thank you very much for being here. I appreciate it very much.

Official source

05:17:36Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

We will move on to the government side. We will start with MPP Leardi. The floor is yours.

Official source

05:17:43Official transcript

Mr. Anthony Leardi

So, Ms. Spanjers and Ms. Pennings, we were having a previous discussion with previous presenters, and we were talking about one of the aspects of Bill 109. And one of the aspects of Bill 109 was this idea that, somehow, we should place restrictions on the potential of people selling their Ontario farmland into foreign ownership. The concerns raised by some people in the industry were that there were foreign purchasers seeking to purchase up large, large farms—and even small farms—in Ontario. And then the example was given of Prince Edward Island, where large tracts of farmland were purchased in Prince Edward Island and then either taken out of production, or what production remained was not for Canadian consumption but rather for outside-the-country consumption. So you had the dual consequence in Prince Edward Island of farms being purchased and owned by people outside of the country, and then the production of those farms being shipped out of the country for consumption outside the country. That is part of what arose with regard to our discussion around Bill 109 about this potential occurring in Ontario. I wanted to ask you some questions about the goat industry, which you’re involved in. I would like to have both of you tell me whether any of this activity—that is, the potential, I’ll say, gobbling up of goat farms—whether you have seen or heard of any threats to this being taken out of production, number one, and, if not taken out of production, falling into the hands of foreign ownership. Can either of you comment on that issue?

Official source

05:20:00Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

You’re asking me whether or not I would approve of land being sold to foreign, and then the production going to foreign?

Official source

05:20:10Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

Yes, I’d like to keep the ball in the team, and I think that says it all. I’m from the Netherlands. If you see what’s going on there with farmers and how they are practically chased out of their farms, it’s ridiculous. At a certain point, they cannot supply food for their own people. In the Netherlands, it’s small. I know Canada is big, but you can’t make land. That’s the one thing that you can’t make; you can’t make land. There is just this amount, and I think it’s best to keep it, at least, for producing for ourselves.

Official source

05:20:52Official transcript

Ms. Geraldine Pennings

I have two thoughts here. The first one is, with the additional regulations that are coming to the goat industry—like traceability and the costs associated with that, then this DGFO and the licensing fee as well as the penalties—a lot of farmers are uncertain about our future. There are several I know of who, once DGFO becomes an organization that takes the check-off, will exit the industry. We have many farmers who work an off-farm job just to supplement the farm, because there really isn’t a lot of money in milking goats.

Official source

05:21:34Official transcript

Mr. Anthony Leardi

It sounds like a very—I think somebody used the word “niche”—niche market—very niche.

Official source

05:21:41Official transcript

Mr. Anthony Leardi

So if you’re into that, yes. And if you’re not, it’s not something that—there’s no mass market for it. Would I be saying that correctly? There’s no mass market for goat milk.

Official source

05:21:55Official transcript

Ms. Geraldine Pennings

Most of the market is in cheese, and I think 60% goes to the United States. It is exported. That is one problem: We will lose production.

Official source

05:22:07Official transcript

Ms. Geraldine Pennings

The second thing I’d like to point out is the Chinese plant, Canada Royal Milk—when that was proposed, the goat milk industry got very excited. We thought we would have the opportunity to ship vast amounts of milk. A lot of plans were made for ramping up production, expansion.

Official source

05:22:30Official transcript

Ms. Geraldine Pennings

Oh, I’m sorry. It didn’t materialize. They’re making formula out of cow milk, but the goat side never materialized. Again, that was quite tough on a lot of farmers. We lost a lot of farmers from that as well.

Official source

05:22:47Official transcript

Mr. Anthony Leardi

I’m particularly interested in the Dutch example, because that’s what was foremost in my mind with regard to Bill 109. I know that we only have a limited time, but perhaps I can follow up with you after our meeting, because I’m particularly interested in the Dutch experience and whether this has any application in the province of Ontario.

Official source

05:23:14Official transcript

Ms. Monique Spanjers

I worked for five years for the traceability organization in the Netherlands. I was the guard of the information from cow farms. I knew everything about every farm, every cow in the Netherlands. My biggest problem with that is that once all this information is gathered and put in the system, you can do awesome things with it, and—

Official source

05:23:40Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

That concludes the government’s time. We’ll move on to the official opposition. MPP Vanthof, the floor is yours.

Official source

05:23:49Official transcript

Mr. John Vanthof

I would like to thank you for your presentation. It will be noted we learned a lot, but I have no further questions. You’ve done a great job.

Official source

05:24:01Official transcript

The Acting Chair (Mr. Andrew Dowie)

Thank you, MPP Vanthof. MPP McCrimmon, the floor is yours.

Official source

05:24:05Official transcript

Mrs. Karen McCrimmon

No, I think I understand the situation, but thank you for coming. We need to do more of this. Get out and talk to people who are on the ground, and don’t give up. Just keep on going.

Official source