Legislative Assembly of Ontario · Committee

Wednesday, January 28, 2026

Standing Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs

The official transcript of the meeting, from Hansard, by heading. Ministers, officials and witnesses appear as the transcript names them; committees have no live transcript, so the record appears once the Assembly publishes it.

Wednesday, January 28, 2026

Read from the beginning of the meeting

Meeting ended

Thunder Bay Real Estate Board; Canadian Mental Health Association, Kenora branch; Association of Family Health Teams of Ontario

03:45:42Official transcript

Ms. Karen Hill

Good morning, Chair and members of the Standing Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs. My name is Karen Hill, and I am getting over a bad cold. Sorry if I sound a little raspy; I’ll make my way through it. I’m here on behalf of the Thunder Bay Real Estate Board and more than 250 realtors who work with buyers, sellers, landlords and tenants across our community. Thank you for the opportunity to speak to you today. Housing supply and affordability remain defining issues for Ontarians. Rental housing is a central part of the solution. A healthy rental market should work for everyone. It should offer a range of homes, different price points, sizes, support, stability and security, and provide a real path to move up the housing ladder over time. In Thunder Bay, that path is getting harder. Both landlords and tenants agree that the system is out of balance. Recent polling by the Ontario Real Estate Association found that seven in 10 landlords and tenants support modernizing the rental rules to better reflect today’s market realities and create a more balanced system for everyone. Rental vacancy in Thunder Bay is around 2%. A typical two-bedroom is now $2,000 to $2,500 per month. Tight vacancies still drive up rent prices, slow the path to home ownership and make challenges like labour mobility and community growth even tougher. Our submission focuses on three practical, budget-aligned priorities to boost housing supply, enable infrastructure and improve affordability in northern Ontario. These recommendations build on the existing provincial tools and align with the province’s capital plan and recent housing reforms, including Bill 60. First, expand housing-enabled infrastructure funding to unlocked serviced land. In the north, the constraint is not often land; it’s serviced land. Municipalities have available sites, but without upfront funding for water, waste water, stormwater and roads, projects can sit for years before shovels are in the ground. That delay shows up in our numbers, and our inventory under construction is falling. The provincial government did a great job in securing the Alstom contract here for Thunder Bay, which means 200 new jobs. But by 2028, we need multi-family and single-family homes for these employees. We recommend increasing the funding envelopes for the Housing-Enabling Water Systems Fund and the Municipal Housing Infrastructure Program by 50% over three years. We also recommend a dedicated northern and mid-sized municipality allocation that reflects higher per-unit servicing costs and shorter construction seasons. To support smaller communities, expand the Ontario Community Infrastructure Fund and adjust its formula to reward proactive zoning and approvals. This will help communities like Thunder Bay bring serviced lots online sooner and get builds faster. It would complement the Building Faster Fund and address chronic undersupply without needing broad tax increases. Secondly, we recommend accelerating the construction of modular and factory-built housing to build faster in northern, rural and Indigenous communities. Thunder Bay knows what it means to be in a short building season. Labour shortages and winter conditions can slow traditional construction. Off-site methods shift more work indoors, reduce on-site time and can help deliver homes faster with fewer disruptions. We recommend launching pilots in rural, northern and Indigenous communities using standardized pre-approval designs that can be adapted to local needs. The goal is simple: to add attainable units quickly and in places where starts remain too low, like here, where we’ve seen a 26% drop year over year. Third, prioritize transportation investments that unlock housing supply and economic growth and remove avoidable barriers in the delivery chain. In northern Ontario, highways are infrastructure that enable housing. Reliable corridors supply labour mobility, reduce construction costs and help communities grow. Isolation hampers everything from worker relocation to material deliveries, which feed our supply shortages. We recommend prioritizing improvements to Highways 11 and 17, including continued twinning and safety upgrades on all key segments of the northern network, as well as practical operational fixes. During the spring thaw, load restrictions and inconsistent permitting can delay the delivery of factory-built homes for weeks. Ontario should create a clear, consistent permit pathway for factory-built housing deliveries during the spring thaw that protects roads while avoiding unnecessary delays. In a short season, losing that delivery window can mean losing a full year of housing delivery. Taken together, these measures focus on consumer affordability. We urge the committee to include these in your priorities and in your pre-budget report with a clear northern lens. Thunder Bay and northern Ontario are ready to be partners in building more homes faster and in a way that is practical and fair. Thank you for your time. I welcome your questions.

Official source

03:50:00Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much for the presentation. Our next presentation is the Canadian Mental Health Association, Kenora branch, and it will be on the screen.

Official source

03:50:07Official transcript

Ms. Sara Dias

Hi. My name is Sara Dias, and I’m the chief executive officer of the Canadian Mental Health Association, Kenora. Thank you for the opportunity to participate in these consultations. I’d like to start by expressing our sincere gratitude to the Ontario government for providing a 4% increase for community mental health and addiction services in the last budget. This vital stabilization funding will help our sector manage pressing financial pressures including inflation, necessary wage adjustments and the growing cost of day-to-day operations. Most importantly, it enables our CMHA branch network to sustain the level of care and support we currently provide to more than 110,000 people each year. While this increase offers short-term relief, it does not resolve the long-standing challenges we face, including chronic underfunding, persistent staffing shortages and the rising demand for services that continues to put significant pressure on the system. That is why we encourage the government to keep up the momentum this year and provide another round of stabilization funding for the community mental health and addictions sector. While CMHA has a branch in Thunder Bay, the Kenora branch is also closely connected with the city, as the mental health care in northwestern Ontario is delivered through a regional system, not in isolation by individual communities. Thunder Bay serves as the regional hub for specialized mental health services, and many of our clients in Kenora and surrounding communities are routinely referred there for higher acuity and specialized treatment. This means that Thunder Bay is often a point of care not because the need originates there but because it is where the regional capacity exists. As a result, any pressures or gaps in one part of the system are felt throughout the northwestern region. It is also why, across the northwest, the challenges look the same. People experience homelessness, co-occurring mental health and substance use issues, long waits for care, staff stretched thin and too few specialized services to meet growing need. Municipal research indicates that more than 8,000 people are homeless in northern Ontario—a number that increased by 37% over the past year. This is largely due to a growing shortage of affordable community housing in the region. In Kenora alone, a recent needs assessment report revealed that the city has a shortage of 1,620 units—a deficit projected to grow to about 2,500 by 2031 as population grows and service demands increase. For our sector, the shortage serves as a critical barrier to recovery and stability. Long housing waits significantly increase the risk of crisis hospitalization and chronic homelessness for people living with mental illness or substance use challenges. The numbers underscore this point, with the northwest health region reporting more than four times the number of emergency department visits related to mental health and addictions compared to the rest of the province. In light of these growing challenges, last year’s budget increase was not sufficient to keep pace with rising demand or to relieve the ongoing strain on the system. A sustained and predictable investment is urgently required to stabilize services, improve quality of care and retain skilled mental health professionals. Without this level of support, the sector remains fragile and unable to respond effectively to the growing needs of Ontarians. This brings me to our formal pre-budget request: We are asking for an additional 4% base budget increase for the community mental health and addictions sector in the 2026 budget. This investment would enable competitive compensation, support the recruitment of up to 200 currently vacant positions across our branch network and expand access to care for an additional 8,000 Ontarians seeking mental health and addictions services. It will also enable CMHA branches like ours to go beyond providing mental health and addictions services to our communities. Our services focus on the whole spectrum of well-being, including housing and food security, employment supports and other social determinants of health. At CMHA Kenora, for example, we provide mental health and addiction supports like crisis intervention and structured psychotherapy. We also operate the emergency shelter and provide court support and telemedicine services to our community. We are also a key partner on the HART hub in our community, which is one of the two Indigenous-led hubs in our province. Providing another 4% funding increase this year will allow us to maintain all these critical services to ensure Ontarians struggling with mental health or addiction issues receive the care they need when they need it. It will also help to ensure we have a stable workforce to adequately staff the essential services we provide. Our current funding has not kept pace with the increased need for our services. Our sector has received a 9% increase in the last 11 years, compared to inflation increasing at least 30% over that time. Investing in community mental health and addiction services will deliver proven results to the rest of the health care system. Research shows that every dollar invested in community mental health saves multiple dollars in hospitals and justice costs. Continuing to provide stabilization funding for our sector will allow us to address key issues that are impacting our partners, municipalities, hospitals and first responders. In closing, I would really like to thank the committee for making the time to hear from CMHA Kenora and other stakeholders in our region. I’m happy to take questions.

Official source

03:54:44Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you. We will now go to the Association of Family Health Teams of Ontario.

Official source

03:54:48Official transcript

Ms. Jess Rogers

Many thanks. Good afternoon, honourable members of the Standing Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs. Thank you for the opportunity to speak before you. My name is Jess Rogers; I am the CEO of the Association of Family Health Teams, or AFTO for short. Joining me virtually, as you can see, and even above, you can sort of see the teams that are here and the distance they are from Thunder Bay. I’ve got April Delorme, Crystal Kaukinen and Pat Delf. And you just heard from another group of our team members, I think, in the previous session. So I’m speaking to you from the association writ large. We’re 190 primary care organizations of team-based primary care across Ontario. We include family health teams, nurse practitioner-led clinics, Indigenous primary health care orgs and many other team models. Our mandate is to work hard to ensure equitable access to team-based primary care. So we’re aligned to where the government is headed and the commitments the government has already made in the past year or so in terms of primary care teams and ensuring that we’re attaching as many Ontarians to that high-quality care. In terms of our whole organizations—so, 190 of them—we actually care for four million Ontarians and growing. That’s the lens that we bring here in terms of the expertise, the experience that those teams have to tell you from the ground what’s really needed to ensure that we maximize the investment the government has already made and continues to make in this space so that it is legacy-building and we have a sustainable way forward for primary care as the foundation for the health system. In northwestern Ontario, that reliance in terms of the investment is even more pronounced. We serve, across our teams, more than 100,000 people in the northwest area, so it’s important for us. We wanted to choose Thunder Bay to participate in this engagement intentionally because we see such important opportunities but significant barriers in northern and rural communities where primary care is not just the front door, in some cases it’s the only door, and is often where the pressures of Ontario’s health system are felt first and most significantly. It’s also the place where we can have an impact on cost as well in terms of investment. So with the $2.1-billion primary care action plan, Ontario did set a very strong goal, along with the Primary Care Act, which is substantial for this province to have an act that we can build from. But with that said, what I’d encourage the committee to think about is a house. When you think about the foundation of a house, it’s absolutely critical that you’re doing maintenance on that foundation, that you’re doing everything that you can to ensure that it is strong. And at the first floor, picture the welcome mat: These are our teams. These are the primary care organizations out there that are caring for the community currently while also trying to expand. The vast majority of the investment that this government has made is on the second-storey addition: new attachment for new Ontarians. We as members are on board for that. That said, you cannot build a second-storey addition on a crumbling foundation on a first floor that’s not being maintained. The invisible team that is working within these teams need to be right-sized in order for us to be able to build forward. I can’t wait for an ensuite bathroom on that second floor, but I don’t want to end up in the basement, is sort of where we’re coming at this. The result, if we don’t address those concerns, is a system that’s trying to expand capacity while actively losing the workforce required to deliver that expansion. Just these last few weeks, Ontario announced it’s investing in expanding teaching clinics and increasing seats to educate the next generation of health care professionals. These investments are critical, but without addressing the system that those graduates are entering, the return on investment will not be realized. From a fiscal perspective, this is not workforce planning; it really is a leaky pipeline, where we are training clinicians only to see them leave primary care for higher-paying jobs or not even enter primary care. This mismatch exists across the province, but it’s magnified in rural, remote and northern communities. Recruitment in rural regions already requires additional spending: reallocation costs, temporary housing, signing bonuses etc. When the wages remain structurally uncompetitive, teams are forced to cycle through these costs again and again, which is a misuse of funds in many respects where we could have the investment come in for consistent wage increases and steady and stabilize the foundation. Closing the primary care compensation gap isn’t just about fairness, this is about protecting public investments that you’re already making on the education, recruitment and structural investments. When primary care compensation lags 15% to 30% behind market rates, the outcomes are predictable. I should say that’s 15% to 30% behind market rates for every profession working in primary care teams. It’s not specific to any one profession. So what happens is teams can’t recruit, retention deteriorates, remaining staff burn out and physicians and nurse practitioners reduce their patient rosters or don’t take on more patients because they simply can’t, so our attachment capacity shrinks. We’re happy that we’re able to move forward on attachment—the numbers are looking promising—but we’re not confident that they’re sustainable going forward. So what are our asks? There are three. The first is, immediately release the remaining $115 million in already committed workforce funding. It’s called recruitment and retention funding. No new funding is required immediately. This funding supports that invisible team—that first floor, the foundation—and allows the family doctors and nurse practitioners to practise at full scope and therefore attach more patients. I will point out, just as a point of example to this committee, that you made this commitment last year and the funding letters did not come out to teams until August. The funds did not flow out to the teams until September or October. Yes, it was retroactive to April 1, but our teams work on one-to-two-year contracts with the government. They cannot plan appropriately.

Official source

04:00:01Official transcript

Ms. Jess Rogers

Second, invest $430 million over five years to close the structural compensation gap in primary care. After more than seven years of wage stagnation, the 2.7% increase last year does not come close to addressing the 15 to 30% market gap. And the third, you’ll be happy to hear, doesn’t cost you any money. The third is that we need to remove policy barriers that are inefficient and causing lag time in all kinds of things, from approvals to where teams can spend their funds through to where they can move funds within their budget. There are simple things this government can push forward in a very quick time frame that will allow our teams to have a little bit more flexibility. They are their own organizations; they are governed. You can hold them accountable, but they need to be able to run their organizations to meet the needs of their community. Thank you so much, and I appreciate your time today.

Official source

04:01:47Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much for the presentation. That concludes the presentations. We’ll start now with the first round of questions with MPP Saunderson.

Official source

04:02:04Official transcript

Mr. Brian Saunderson

I want to thank each of our presenters who are here in person or virtually for taking time today in your busy schedules to contribute to the budget process for 2026. Thank you for the important work you do in our communities. I’m going to start with you, Karen, from the real estate board, just on your housing recommendations. I am the parliamentary assistant to Minister Flack, so this is an important part of my responsibilities at Queen’s Park. You know this government has made a big effort with the HEWS funding and health and safety funding to push infrastructure forward, but in the north—I know the model is slightly different when you have a large urban area, or even like my riding of Simcoe–Grey, which has a mixture. We have large infrastructure for communal water and waste water systems. Up in the north, that’s not always the case. You talked about trying to create a northern stream or northern envelope for the HEWS funding. Can you just expand on what you think that might look like?

Official source

04:04:01Official transcript

Ms. Karen Hill

Sure. I also have a colleague here, Ashley. Can she come and join us for the questions as well?

Official source

04:04:16Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

With unanimous consent from the committee, she can join us—agreed.

Official source

04:04:24Official transcript

Ms. Karen Hill

Thank you. Ashley is our government support from the Ontario Real Estate Association, and she has been working with Timmins, Sudbury, Sault Ste. Marie and Thunder Bay, so I think she has a wider scope on this than I do, even.

Official source

04:04:50Official transcript

Ms. Ashley Schultz

Thank you. I think what’s really important about developing this infrastructure in northern Ontario is that we’re really looking for water, waste water and highways. We don’t necessarily—in our research and proposals we put forth to—

Official source

04:05:17Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

I’ll just stop you for a moment. Could you introduce yourself before we—

Official source

04:05:26Official transcript

Ms. Ashley Schultz

Oh, I’m sorry. Ashley Schultz. I’m from the Ontario Real Estate Association.

Official source

04:05:36Official transcript

Ms. Ashley Schultz

We’re not really in the business of telling you, necessarily, how we want to do it. Our research and policy analysis shows different solutions for different parts of northern Ontario, but a big part of that is that infrastructure piece and helping us set up the framework to build more houses. And kind of using our colleagues here on Zoom who talked about building the house: That foundation piece is really missing in northern Ontario. We just don’t have the infrastructure. We don’t have the water set up. We don’t have the roads set up. And so that’s really where we’re hoping to see some budget dollars get allocated.

Official source

04:06:49Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

If we could also have the title to add to the name.

Official source

04:06:55Official transcript

Ms. Ashley Schultz

Oh, I’m sorry—government relations specialist for northern Ontario.

Official source

04:07:04Official transcript

Mr. Brian Saunderson

I appreciate those comments, and maybe we’ll have an offline discussion on that, because I’ve got a couple of questions. I wanted to go to your second portion of that: modular home construction. You have a slower building or a tighter building season up here, and we heard yesterday in Kapuskasing from a modular home construction company. It’s been a big topic in the south as well, because we need the housing now. And so, I’m wondering what you’ve seen up here in terms of modular housing construction. Is it happening and are there suppliers up here?

Official source

04:08:08Official transcript

Ms. Karen Hill

Yes. I believe we have probably six or seven. I’ve met with a few of them, and I know Kevin Holland has as well. We have a really big push and a really big acceptance. The realtors spoke with the banks, and we pushed for the last year. RBC actually has a mortgage available if someone wants to put a modular home on a current, existing serviced lot. We are seeing it a lot in Thunder Bay. They opened the doors and we had all the realtors view it, and we really stand behind them. There’s less waste because everything is cut to size. We have a huge labour shortage up here, so it’s nice because it’s not waiting for another electrician to come or it’s not holding up any of the progress. We’re really seeing that modular is a great solution up here right now. And they can build anything. You can send them a two-storey house, a split-level house, you can put it on a concrete slab, you can put it on a basement. It’s a really great solution up here.

Official source

04:10:03Official transcript

Mr. Brian Saunderson

Thank you for that. I’m going to switch over to the Association of Family Health Teams of Ontario, Jess and your team. Thank you all for attending and your input. You bring a nice overall lens because we’re up here in the north talking about some local issues, but you service people all across the province—I think you said four million Ontarians. I come from a rural area in southern Ontario, and it seems to me that a lot of our family health teams are very closely connected to the bricks and mortar of a hospital. That may be the case in southern Ontario; I don’t think it’s the case up here. Can you talk about the different challenges that that presents?

Official source

04:10:51Official transcript

Ms. Jess Rogers

Sure. Thank you for the question. A couple of pieces: We definitely have a number—probably less than 10 of our academic family health teams are co-located close and/or near to a hospital, but they still function as their own independent organization. There are a couple of examples more, as you said, in the suburban Ottawa and Toronto area, where it’s a little bit different. But by and large, the overall family heath team model is their own sort of bricks and mortar co-located organization—

Official source

04:11:26Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time. MPP Vaugeois.

Official source

04:11:31Official transcript

MPP Lise Vaugeois

For the family health teams: First of all, I’d like to thank you for the work that you do. I know that it’s been underfunded for a very long time and that the 2.7% increase just doesn’t bring you up to par. Maybe you can just explain a little bit about how that affects recruitment and retention?

Official source

04:11:52Official transcript

Ms. Jess Rogers

Yes, absolutely. As we sort of said in our piece, when we look across every health care professional that works within these teams, regardless of profession, there is anywhere between a 15% to 30% gap between—not just across sectors like primary care to hospital or to long-term care, but in some cases even across the primary care sector. Something that’s really important for the committee to appreciate is family health teams and nurse practitioner-led clinics have a salary grid the government provides to us, and it’s based on that of what they actually fund us. There are a lot of limitations put on these organizations in terms of what that could look like and I think there are some structural pieces we could look at that are not necessarily high-cost items but to give the organizations a bit more flexibility in terms of how they use those funds. But again, 15% to 30%, in addition to not having received an increase in over seven years in the primary care sector—I think my colleague from CMHA quite readily pointed out what inflation has looked like. A 2.7% increase was very difficult. We started to see people leave right away. As soon as those funding letters came out in August, we heard from all of our teams that there was a bit of a mass exodus in terms of teams that had been holding on. If primary care truly is the foundation, maybe we’re going to get there as a system in this province. We’re on board and we want to do it, but we have to right-size. We have to stabilize this workforce. In the north in particular—I’m sure you heard some stories—our teams here have recruited nurse practitioners up here with 20 years of experience who leave within three months because the patients are so complex. They don’t have as many benefits, bonuses of being up here, so it’s extremely difficult to recruit up here before there’s even that level of discrepancy between wages.

Official source

04:14:14Official transcript

MPP Lise Vaugeois

Oh, fantastic. Sara Dias, CMHA: I think all of the things that were discussed in this session are very closely related. And again, you’re dealing with funding shortfalls—kind of chronic funding shortfalls. When we’re struggling for housing, which Karen and Ashley have been talking about, if you become homeless, you have a mental health problem. You might not have had one in your work when you were working before, when things were more stable in life, but when you lose that stability, you are going to wind up needing mental health care, and you can see how each of these things compound. Also, with our primary health care, when everybody is stressed and pushed past what they can actually cope with and work with and stay healthy themselves, the situation tumbles. I just wonder, Sara, if you could—I just kind of made a statement rather than a question. But perhaps you could just talk a little bit about—again make it clear to us why it makes a difference that you be adequately funded and what the impact is when that is not there.

Official source

04:15:29Official transcript

Ms. Sara Dias

I thank you very much. Absolutely, we have a large housing and stock issue. We have multiple rent supplements available but no units to fill—those particular units with individuals because we don’t have the units. In addition to that, just having a roof over your head is not enough. People require a lot more intensive community supports and additional supports in order to address homelessness. We have lots of individuals within our region now losing long-standing employment within our region—mill closures, etc.—that enhances the need for our services. So not only just an investment in the housing continuum; we also need investments in mental health and the whole continuum of services in order to support that demand that’s coming through.

Official source

04:16:24Official transcript

MPP Lise Vaugeois

Thank you. I think I’ll go back to the family health teams because the family health teams have been doing a team-based model. Perhaps Crystal from the nurse practitioner-led clinic—if you could talk a little bit about the history of that clinic and how integrated the programs are there. Again, this is another reason why the funding needs to be appropriate for the work that you’re doing.

Official source

04:16:52Official transcript

Ms. Crystal Kaukinen

Hi. Thank you very much. Yes, we as well as the family health teams and nurse practitioner clinics work in a team-based model, so we rely on many different health care providers to provide service for our patients. We have social workers who provide mental health services, system navigators who help our patients navigate our confusing health care system, dietitians, kinesiology, nurses of various types as well as physicians and nurse practitioners all working together for one goal. That is for the health—

Official source

04:17:29Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time. We’ll now go to MPP Fairclough.

Official source

04:17:35Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

Thank you to all three groups for presenting. I will be coming to each of you over the course of my two question slots. Sara, I’d like to start with you, with the Canadian Mental Health Association in Kenora. I was struck by your comment that there are four times the emergency room visits in Kenora than anywhere else in the province right now. Can you talk a little bit more about what you’re seeing and what are the service gaps that you really feel that you need to be able to fill in your community?

Official source

04:18:11Official transcript

Ms. Sara Dias

Thank you very much for the question. Yes, we are seeing a large service gap in regard to point of entry for service within our region and the emergency department and, just like Jess had indicated, our primary care being that entry point into the service delivery. I know that in Toronto alone, there’s eight crisis teams. In northwestern Ontario, there’s only nine within the entire region. So we don’t have the capacity of services in the community in order to respond as first points of entry, so individuals either use 911, emergency responses or the emergency department to get that need met.

Official source

04:18:55Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

Thank you for that answer. I think we are hearing, actually, over the course of the last two days, both up in Kapuskasing and now here, housing and affordable housing really need to be a focus. So it’s good to hear that you’re leaning into that in your community in Kenora—it’s good to hear. I would also just say that when we were in Kitchener, I was very impressed that the start of the real estate board presentation was similar, which was, “We need to start resolving issues at the Landlord and Tenant Board.” There’s a lot of agreement about that from both the tenant and the landlord perspectives, really ensuring that there’s access to affordable housing. I wondered, Ashley, if you wanted to comment a little bit more on some of the recommendations. I was very impressed with your northern perspective today and your presentation. But how is that issue playing out up here in Thunder Bay?

Official source

04:20:00Official transcript

Ms. Karen Hill

We do have available units sometimes, and with the inconsistency in the landlord-tenant act, we’re finding that some landlords are leaving those vacant. They could fill them. One of my colleagues put up an apartment a couple of weeks ago and got 93 applications. So the people need the housing, but the risk is too great with the current, outdated landlord-tenant act. That’s how they’re feeling right now. We don’t want them leaving it vacant or doing something like putting it on Airbnb, because we need housing on every level.

Official source

04:20:35Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

That’s great. Thank you. I really sense a willing partner to come to the table on these issues. I also sense that in the CMHAs that we’ve spoken to as well, Sara, and I wondered if you wanted to comment on that issue at all.

Official source

04:20:49Official transcript

Ms. Sara Dias

Yes, absolutely. We have a huge housing crisis need. That needs assessment report was just released by the city of Kenora last month in regard to the number of units that I have put into my presentation, and what we’re actually going to be needing for targeted. We have unused rent supplements because the need is so great and there are no units to be able to fill those things. So we need that in order to ensure that we create a continuum of wellness for people in order to support not only their housing needs but those wraparound services that come with that as well. That makes that tenancy very successful.

Official source

04:21:30Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

Thank you very much. I serve as well for the Liberal caucus as the critic for hospitals, mental health, addictions and homelessness, and it’s very clear that this link between health and housing—they really do go together. So it’s great to see two organizations here in very different businesses recognizing that we need to find solutions so that we can get upstream of the homelessness issues as well. How many more minutes, Chair?

Official source

04:22:00Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

I will turn to my colleagues at the Association of Family Health Teams of Ontario and continue in the next session as well. Jess, it’s very good to see you again. Are you still there? I should be looking at the camera.

Official source

04:22:15Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

There we go. Hi, Jess. In the last presentation, we’ve heard from a few different family health teams—including Timmins yesterday and then the previous session—with similar asks. One of the suggestions in the last presentation was moving to global budgets for family health teams, and I just wanted to hear a little bit from you. Again, as a previous hospital president, there’s flexibility that comes with that and how you can creatively use that budget to fund the services and the people that you need. Have you got any comments on that from the perspective of AFHTO?

Official source

04:22:52Official transcript

Ms. Jess Rogers

Yes. Global budgets is one of those things in that third bucket. We think it’s a no-cost item for the government to look at some of the ways in which the contracts are set up to provide greater autonomy and flexibility, still with the accountability required—

Official source

04:23:10Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time. We’ll now go to MPP Racinsky.

Official source

04:23:15Official transcript

Mr. Joseph Racinsky

Thank you to all the presenters for coming out this afternoon and thank you for everything you do for your communities here in northern Ontario. I really appreciate it. I’m going to start with Jess as well—I’ll keep talking to you, Jess. Thanks for being here. Thank you for recognizing our government’s creation of those 17 teaching clinics. I think that’s really important. We heard in the last round, like you mentioned, from some other family health teams here in the north, and we heard about a vacancy they had. They have the funding for the position but for 20 months it’s gone vacant. They’ve got some retirements coming up; they’re really concerned about that. Another program that our government started was the Learn and Stay grant, which is about $262 million over three years to encourage students to stay in more rural and remote communities, like mine in rural Ontario, down in the south. Do you think that that is a positive program and something we should continue, that would be helpful for your areas?

Official source

04:24:22Official transcript

Ms. Jess Rogers

I can start us off. April, Crystal, Pat: If you have a specific, just put your hand up so that we know. What I would say to that is, overall, across our members—because, again, it’s 190 organizations—we received relatively positive feedback around the Learn and Stay program. I think, again, there are opportunities to streamline processes and make things a little bit more efficient, and also recognize some of what’s required in order, on the team’s end and the organization’s end, to make those programs successful. I don’t know, from a northern lens, whether or not there’s anything Pat, Crystal and April would suggest as specific to the north. April, I see you coming off mute, there—nothing to add? Okay. Crystal? Pat?

Official source

04:25:10Official transcript

Ms. Crystal Kaukinen

The only thing I might add is that that funding is excellent for new people coming into the roles, but it does nothing to support the current people who have been working in those roles for the last several years.

Official source

04:25:25Official transcript

Ms. Jess Rogers

Yes, and in some cases, it exacerbates the difference in terms of wages, right? So now you have, within a team, people knowing what people are making because they’re part of one program, and they’re new and making more than the teams that have been there slugging away. Sometimes that can obviously create tension and a challenge, I think, locally, but also from a government perspective as well. Sorry, Pat.

Official source

04:25:52Official transcript

Ms. Pat Delf

We don’t use the Learn and Stay, but I echo that. If you are giving incentives to hire new people, it doesn’t reward the people who have been here since we started the FHT. It’s great if we can get new people, but not many people want to move north, so it really hasn’t worked as an incentive for us. The wage difference is just so noticeable from one side to the other, that $15 to $30 difference to walk across the parking lot and work at the hospital. The 2.7% that came was a big disappointment to all those people who had been hanging on. And now, most of my employees have second or third jobs to make ends meet.

Official source

04:26:33Official transcript

Mr. Joseph Racinsky

Just following up on that, I appreciate the request for increases there, but I’m also aware that a lot of our northern hospitals are in need of doctors as well, and they have staffing shortages as well. So outside of funding, what can we do to attract more workers, more health care professionals, to places like northern Ontario?

Official source

04:26:55Official transcript

Ms. Jess Rogers

I think it’s an important question. What I would offer is what we know from the research evidence, not only in this province but across the board. The investment in primary and community care services has a huge ROI with respect to cost savings downstream in terms of use of emerg and hospitals. In our rural communities, that’s tricky because there hasn’t been a lot of capacity for primary care, and where it is, it’s difficult to grow that capacity. So what I would offer is, some of this is about the way in which you set the foundation, and it may take a few years to catch up. But if we have a strong primary and community care system in these regions and an investment in terms of the physicians that are required there as well as other professionals, some of the pressure on the hospital side alleviates, as well as some of the downstream costs, which I think is an important consideration.

Official source

04:27:55Official transcript

Ms. Pat Delf

Housing. We are desperate for housing for new staff to move in. We’ve got lots and lots of mining happening in the Red Lake area, and we’re all looking for housing, even for physicians. I will put a plug in for the Practice Ready Ontario Program. We have two physicians through that program. It’s been wonderful, but we struggled. If we hadn’t had the co-operation of one of our mining companies to assist us with housing, we would have no place for them to live.

Official source

04:28:26Official transcript

Mr. Joseph Racinsky

Well, thanks for that. I’m probably going to run out of time, but on housing, I’m just going to the real estate board. Recently, we passed the Fighting Delays, Building Faster Act. We tried to bring balance to the Landlord and Tenant Board. How important is that to getting more people to become landlords to get more rental housing? You mentioned the need—93 applications—but there’s still fear amongst people to become landlords. We heard from another real estate board: There’s a third of people who have the space to become landlords. So what can we do get more people to become landlords?

Official source

04:29:05Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time for that question. MPP Vaugeois.

Official source

04:29:10Official transcript

MPP Lise Vaugeois

My question, actually, is also for Karen and Ashley. We had concerns about Bill 60. You’re talking about reforming the landlord and tenant act, but part of what we see is that there are not enough adjudicators. Also, for many people who have to do it online, it fails for them. It seems to me that there’s another aspect in the existing act that could be fixed now to create that balance. We want it to be fair for tenants and for landlords. We don’t want landlords to be afraid to rent, and to do that, they need to know that they are safe, that they will get a hearing in a timely way. The tenants also need to be able to get a hearing, preferably in person, which is what the legal services are also asking for. Can you speak to that for us?

Official source

04:30:00Official transcript

Ms. Ashley Schultz

Thank you for the question—great question. One of the things that we have recommended is to bring back additional adjudicators and bring back those in-person hearings. Lots of our policy research showed us that those hallway meetings between landlords and tenants, when they get face to face, in person, there are resolutions there as well. Our recommendations are to benefit both the tenant and the landlord. That needs to be a cohesive relationship to see those people who have the ability, and have the space and capacity to build additional units—see them putting forward the capital and taking the risk, right? And so, that is one of our pushes as well with government: We would like to see the return of in-person meetings, we want more adjudicators and we really want to try and get some mediation type of services in place, where landlords and tenants can be face to face, and really alleviate some of their issues that way as well. It’s a great point.

Official source

04:31:10Official transcript

Mr. Sol Mamakwa

Meegwetch to Karen and Ashley from the Thunder Bay Real Estate Board—good to see you; also, Sara Dias from Canadian Mental Health Association, Kenora branch; and certainly, Jess Rogers from the Association of Family Health Teams of Ontario. Very quickly: I think when we talk about housing, I’m wondering—say, for example, in Thunder Bay—how many homes, whether it’s affordable or other housing, have been built since 2018 in Thunder Bay?

Official source

04:31:40Official transcript

Ms. Karen Hill

I have the statistics just for the last year: only 60 new homes. I also sit on the mayor’s task force for the federal funding, we have about 268 additional dwelling units that have been added—so that’s someone who owned a house and put a basement suite in. They’re really focusing on apartments, multi-family and additional dwelling units right now, but we also need single-family dwellings as well. So that is kind of the next phase of the mayor’s task force unit to start looking at that now. As you can tell, we don’t have enough units being built. We still need a lot more.

Official source

04:32:20Official transcript

Mr. Sol Mamakwa

Okay. Thank you. I want to switch over to the Canadian Mental Health Association. I know across the north, people are struggling with mental health, and not only with that, but with addictions, there is a crisis happening. One of the things in my region—they’re our friends, they’re our family members, our children. I want to say one thing: The rate of self-harm for children and youth in the Sioux Lookout area is 88% higher than Ontario’s overall rate. So I think what I want to ask is: Does CMHA, Kenora branch work with First Nations across the north to provide mental health services?

Official source

04:33:02Official transcript

Ms. Sara Dias

Thank you for the question. Yes, our data also indicates that youth hospitalizations for mental health are up by 136% as well. So I can indicate that our branch has a couple of lifespan programs that are mobile that go into First Nation communities—one being our mobile mental health and addictions program. It was a pilot project that now has turned into permanent base funding as of this past fiscal year.

Official source

04:33:31Official transcript

Ms. Sara Dias

And we service communities at Eagle Lake First Nation, Grassy Narrows First Nation, and we just onboarded Whitefish Bay First Nation within our region. But that’s a small, select portion of the entire northwest.

Official source

04:33:45Official transcript

Mr. Sol Mamakwa

Very quickly, I don’t know if you’ll have time: If someone is struggling with their mental health or experiencing a crisis, what would it look like for them to access support in the Kenora district?

Official source

04:33:59Official transcript

Ms. Sara Dias

So as I had indicated, in regard to the north, there is not a large amount of crisis services. We have nine crisis teams within the entire northwest Ontario region. Toronto has eight crisis teams alone. They’re not 24 hours—

Official source

04:34:15Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time for that question. Maybe we can get that through in the next question. MPP Fairclough.

Official source

04:34:24Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

Do you want to just finish that answer, Sara, to the end? Because I think it’s an important question. If somebody wants to access crisis service, what does it look like in your area?

Official source

04:34:37Official transcript

Ms. Sara Dias

In our area, if our crisis teams are not available—because they’re not 24 hours—it’s through 911 service or the emergency department.

Official source

04:34:46Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

I think, just to build on that, it was going to be a question that I had as well, for you and the family health teams here. When I was in Kapuskasing yesterday, I learned in my morning visit to the hospital that one of their struggles is the pathways to specialists seem to have become quite difficult, including the pathway for psychiatry as well. I wondered if you might just comment on that from a northern perspective—how you’re able to support your patients in being able to get access to more specialized care from your communities where you are, and what are some of the barriers that you’re experiencing in that regard?

Official source

04:35:30Official transcript

Ms. Sara Dias

There are huge barriers for access to psychiatry. We’re usually referring to our outpatient services through Lake of the Woods District Hospital, which has a large waiting list. If the funding is not attached to our current existing programs in order to receive those contracts for psychiatry ourselves, we don’t have any options, other than the wait-lists through the hospital.

Official source

04:35:56Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

Okay. Thank you. Any others want to comment? Pat or April?

Official source

04:36:00Official transcript

Ms. Pat Delf

Yes—same barriers, plus transportation. We don’t have any public transportation, except for air, out of Red Lake. Treatment options sometimes don’t even exist if people can’t drive themselves out of the community. They just can’t go to specialist appointments at all.

Official source

04:36:18Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

Yes. I will say, too, that was a theme last night. This was the rationale for making sure the roads were there, the roads were safe and the roads were open, too: for people to get access quickly to some of the more specialized care that they need. I do want to come back to the funding, Jess, that you’ve been requesting around the family health team. I’m certainly supportive of it. I understand the discrepancies between the primary care and the hospitals. Are you envisioning that, with some of those changes too, there are ways that we can increase access for people in terms of the hours and the time that services could be available? I think this has always been one of the rationales for, maybe, why there’s differences in salaries between hospitals and the community. But on the flip side, I’ve always sensed a lot of commitment to access and ensuring access in the primary care environment. I don’t know if you have comments on some of the other measures, beyond attachment, that we could be achieving, especially now that we’re moving in this team-based model.

Official source

04:37:33Official transcript

Ms. Jess Rogers

Thanks for the question. April and Pat, feel free to chime in. What I would say is, yes, absolutely. This isn’t a linear curve in terms of first, you get everyone attached, and then you provide access and provide quality care. We have to be doing that all the way through. So that return on investment—by stabilizing the workforce, you have certainty that you’ve got those three RNs that can still run that extra program or that extra clinic, and the NP can stay for some of the after-hours clinic. Part of the workaround, unfortunately, is when you’re not really sure if you’ve got a stabilized workforce, where people are kind of coming and going. It’s harder to put some of those programs in place so that you can ensure that you’ve got the right level of access and that people know where to be going. You can’t be innovative either, because you’re just always trying to catch up. And let’s be honest, the morale isn’t great either, right? There are huge advantages to having that stabilization that would allow for greater efficiency and effectiveness, I think, and being able to work with partners differently around the right flow of patients through the system, rather than it feeling quite broken throughout. I don’t know if April and Pat have anything to add.

Official source

04:39:01Official transcript

Ms. Pat Delf

If I were to add an example, it would be RN nurses are trained, or have been with us a long time, and have extra training in wound care.

Official source

04:39:12Official transcript

Ms. Pat Delf

Sometimes, they can do things, like with the TeleVU glasses, that keep a patient here. They don’t have to go and stay in Thunder Bay for two weeks to receive some specialist care. So investing in primary care saves money downstream—or upstream; whichever way you’re looking at it.

Official source

04:39:31Official transcript

Ms. Lee Fairclough

That’s great. Thank you very much. I think, for my last question—I asked this of the previous group: I find that clinicians in the north are often some of the most creative for the ways that you deal with supporting people in their care. Is there an example that you’d like to share of how you worked very creatively in our publicly funded health system to make sure people are receiving the care they need?

Official source

04:40:00Official transcript

Ms. Pat Delf

I think because we’re small communities, we connect patients with all the other services. Lots of our people will go see someone in their home or go the extra mile, pick up their groceries or their prescriptions—

Official source

04:40:19Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

Thank you very much. That concludes the time for that question. It also concludes the time for this panel. I want to thank all the participants for all the time you took to prepare and all the able way you came to present it. I’m sure it will be of assistance to us, so thank you very much.

Official source

Sioux Lookout First Nations Health Authority; Northern Ontario Aviation Committee; Ontario English Catholic Teachers’ Association, Thunder Bay secondary unit

04:40:45Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

We now will switch to the next panel, and that’s the Northern Ontario Aviation Committee; Sioux Lookout First Nations Health Authority; and the Ontario English Catholic Teachers’ Association, Thunder Bay secondary unit, if they will come forward. Everybody is here, and I hope everybody has heard the instructions. You will have seven minutes to make your presentation. At six minutes, I will say “one minute.” At seven minutes, I will say “thank you” and move on. We also ask each participant to identify themselves for Hansard to make sure we have it recorded properly to the presentation. With that, the first presenter is the Northern Ontario Aviation Committee.

Official source

04:41:47Official transcript

The Clerk of the Committee (Ms. Lesley Flores)

He was here, but he left the room. He was here before.

Official source

04:41:52Official transcript

The Chair (Hon. Ernie Hardeman)

He’s not here at the moment—wait a minute. The Sioux Lookout First Nations Health Authority—that’s virtual?

Official source

04:42:01Official transcript

Ms. Monica Hemeon

Hi. We’re here, yes. My name is Monica Hemeon. I’m the vice-president of regional services for Sioux Lookout First Nations Health Authority. Online, we have—

Official source

04:42:16Official transcript

Ms. Sonia Isaac-Mann

Hello. My name is Sonia Isaac-Mann. I am the president and CEO for the health authority.

Official source

04:42:24Official transcript

Mr. Brian Calleja

Good afternoon. I’m Brian Calleja, vice-president of finance and corporate services for the health authority.

Official source

04:42:34Official transcript

Ms. Monica Hemeon

Sonia, they don’t have the option for PowerPoint, so everybody has a copy if you want to go ahead.

Official source