Thunder Bay Real Estate Board; Canadian Mental Health Association, Kenora branch; Association of Family Health Teams of Ontario
Ms. Jess Rogers
Many thanks. Good afternoon, honourable members of the Standing Committee on Finance and Economic Affairs. Thank you for the opportunity to speak before you. My name is Jess Rogers; I am the CEO of the Association of Family Health Teams, or AFTO for short. Joining me virtually, as you can see, and even above, you can sort of see the teams that are here and the distance they are from Thunder Bay. I’ve got April Delorme, Crystal Kaukinen and Pat Delf. And you just heard from another group of our team members, I think, in the previous session. So I’m speaking to you from the association writ large. We’re 190 primary care organizations of team-based primary care across Ontario. We include family health teams, nurse practitioner-led clinics, Indigenous primary health care orgs and many other team models. Our mandate is to work hard to ensure equitable access to team-based primary care. So we’re aligned to where the government is headed and the commitments the government has already made in the past year or so in terms of primary care teams and ensuring that we’re attaching as many Ontarians to that high-quality care. In terms of our whole organizations—so, 190 of them—we actually care for four million Ontarians and growing. That’s the lens that we bring here in terms of the expertise, the experience that those teams have to tell you from the ground what’s really needed to ensure that we maximize the investment the government has already made and continues to make in this space so that it is legacy-building and we have a sustainable way forward for primary care as the foundation for the health system. In northwestern Ontario, that reliance in terms of the investment is even more pronounced. We serve, across our teams, more than 100,000 people in the northwest area, so it’s important for us. We wanted to choose Thunder Bay to participate in this engagement intentionally because we see such important opportunities but significant barriers in northern and rural communities where primary care is not just the front door, in some cases it’s the only door, and is often where the pressures of Ontario’s health system are felt first and most significantly. It’s also the place where we can have an impact on cost as well in terms of investment. So with the $2.1-billion primary care action plan, Ontario did set a very strong goal, along with the Primary Care Act, which is substantial for this province to have an act that we can build from. But with that said, what I’d encourage the committee to think about is a house. When you think about the foundation of a house, it’s absolutely critical that you’re doing maintenance on that foundation, that you’re doing everything that you can to ensure that it is strong. And at the first floor, picture the welcome mat: These are our teams. These are the primary care organizations out there that are caring for the community currently while also trying to expand. The vast majority of the investment that this government has made is on the second-storey addition: new attachment for new Ontarians. We as members are on board for that. That said, you cannot build a second-storey addition on a crumbling foundation on a first floor that’s not being maintained. The invisible team that is working within these teams need to be right-sized in order for us to be able to build forward. I can’t wait for an ensuite bathroom on that second floor, but I don’t want to end up in the basement, is sort of where we’re coming at this. The result, if we don’t address those concerns, is a system that’s trying to expand capacity while actively losing the workforce required to deliver that expansion. Just these last few weeks, Ontario announced it’s investing in expanding teaching clinics and increasing seats to educate the next generation of health care professionals. These investments are critical, but without addressing the system that those graduates are entering, the return on investment will not be realized. From a fiscal perspective, this is not workforce planning; it really is a leaky pipeline, where we are training clinicians only to see them leave primary care for higher-paying jobs or not even enter primary care. This mismatch exists across the province, but it’s magnified in rural, remote and northern communities. Recruitment in rural regions already requires additional spending: reallocation costs, temporary housing, signing bonuses etc. When the wages remain structurally uncompetitive, teams are forced to cycle through these costs again and again, which is a misuse of funds in many respects where we could have the investment come in for consistent wage increases and steady and stabilize the foundation. Closing the primary care compensation gap isn’t just about fairness, this is about protecting public investments that you’re already making on the education, recruitment and structural investments. When primary care compensation lags 15% to 30% behind market rates, the outcomes are predictable. I should say that’s 15% to 30% behind market rates for every profession working in primary care teams. It’s not specific to any one profession. So what happens is teams can’t recruit, retention deteriorates, remaining staff burn out and physicians and nurse practitioners reduce their patient rosters or don’t take on more patients because they simply can’t, so our attachment capacity shrinks. We’re happy that we’re able to move forward on attachment—the numbers are looking promising—but we’re not confident that they’re sustainable going forward. So what are our asks? There are three. The first is, immediately release the remaining $115 million in already committed workforce funding. It’s called recruitment and retention funding. No new funding is required immediately. This funding supports that invisible team—that first floor, the foundation—and allows the family doctors and nurse practitioners to practise at full scope and therefore attach more patients. I will point out, just as a point of example to this committee, that you made this commitment last year and the funding letters did not come out to teams until August. The funds did not flow out to the teams until September or October. Yes, it was retroactive to April 1, but our teams work on one-to-two-year contracts with the government. They cannot plan appropriately.