The senior assistant legislative clerk read as follows:
Text printed in the Record (190 characters)
A bill (H.R. 2347) to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to exclude from gross income any damages, other than punitive damages, received on account of any sexual acts or sexual contact.
Pending:
Text printed in the Record (421 characters)
Thune (for Capito) amendment No. 6883, in the nature of a substitute.
Thune amendment No. 6884 (to amendment No. 6883), to change the enactment date.
Thune amendment No. 6885 (to amendment No. 6884), of a perfecting nature.
Thune amendment No. 6886 (to the language proposed to be stricken by amendment No. 6883), to change the enactment date.
Thune amendment No. 6887 (to amendment No. 6886), of a perfecting nature.
Text printed in the Record (179 characters)
Your administration possesses a treasure trove of records that prove out weaponization against Republicans, including you and your family, which we've investigated for many years.
The senior assistant legislative clerk proceeded to call the roll.
Text printed in the Record (60 characters)
But leaving the system unchanged is a guarantee of calamity.
Text printed in the Record (87 characters)
The status quo has left us completely unable to build the energy system [that] we need.
The senior assistant legislative clerk proceeded to call the roll.
Text printed in the Record (30 characters)
We still gotta live our lives.
Text printed in the Record (30 characters)
We still gotta live our lives.
The senior assistant legislative clerk proceeded to call the roll.
John Thune (R-SD)
Mr. President, later this morning, Ohio Senator Jon Husted will make his farewell speech here on the floor. He was appointed to the Senate just 2 years ago, so his tenure has been short, but his impact has been substantial.
As a lifelong public servant--State representative, speaker of the State house, State Senator, secretary of state for Ohio, and Lieutenant Governor for Ohio--there was never any question that Jon Husted was going to do anything but hit the ground running here in the Senate, and he did.
A longtime advocate for, as he says, making it "easy to vote and hard to cheat," Jon was a leading voice in the Senate for commonsense voter ID requirements during the SAVE Act debate.
He has also been an advocate for protecting communities from higher energy costs associated with data centers, and the permitting legislation we will hopefully pass this week--the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act--builds on the work of his Ratepayer Protection Act.
Mr. President, it has been a true pleasure to serve with Jon. He is someone who, through faith and hard work, found a real calling to public service and who cares very deeply about our country and the men and women he represents. I am profoundly sorry to see him depart the Senate, but I am excited to see what way he serves next. In the meantime, I hope he gets some well-deserved rest and some time to spend with his wife Tina and the rest of his family.
Mr. President, yesterday, the Senate confirmed its 59th article III judge of this Congress. We have floor votes locked in for 4 more, and we continue to move forward on a robust year-end package to confirm around 100 more of the President's nominees.
Confirming lower level Presidential nominees would once not have warranted much in the way of floor remarks, and that is because expeditiously confirming Presidential nominees used to be a standard practice. Whether you had voted for a President or not, the assumption was the President should be able to staff their administrations, and so no one was lining up scores of nominees for time-consuming floor votes. Most nominees were confirmed by voice vote or unanimous consent--a way of expediting their consideration here on the Senate floor.
All of that changed, however, during President Trump's first administration. Democrats introduced an unprecedented level of partisanship into the confirmation process, dragging out nominations that would once have been speedily approved by voice vote or unanimous consent.
President Obama had 90 percent of his nominations confirmed by voice vote or unanimous consent. President Trump, in his first term, had 65 percent, but at least a decent number were still going by voice vote.
Now fast-forward to the current Trump administration. Beginning immediately after President Trump's election, Democrats introduced a no-holds-barred level of partisanship on nominations. For the first year and a half of his administration, Democrats dragged out the process on every single one of his nominees, and that applied not just to nominees they voted against but to nominees they eventually ended up voting for. As of today, President Trump has 2.5 percent--2.5 percent--of his nominees confirmed by voice vote--just 2.5 percent or a tiny, tiny, tiny fraction of the rates enjoyed by Presidents Obama and Biden.
So what would once have been taken for granted--the swift confirmation of a majority of a President's nominees--has become something of note thanks to Democrats' unprecedented level of partisanship and obstruction.
I am proud of the work we have done in the face of historic opposition to ensure the President gets his team in place. We have spent many, many, many hours in session this Congress, nearly twice the time in session spent by the House of Representatives, and we have taken a lot of votes.
We also implemented reforms to restore the Senate's tradition of en bloc confirmations of largely uncontroversial nominees. Thanks to those reforms, both Democrat and Republican Presidents will see some protection against Democrat-type partisanship in the future.
Senate confirmation of nominees is important. There is no substitute for Senate confirmation, especially when it comes to judges. We have given the President the assurance of individuals who can serve throughout his administration or, in the cases of the judges, for life.
Unfortunately, I am very much afraid that the President will have a hard time getting any nominees through in the next Congress--not because of any deficiency in the nominees but because Democrats would stand in the way of George Washington himself if President Trump nominated him to serve in his administration. It is that which lends a particular urgency to confirmations here in the lameduck session.
Presidents should be able to get their teams in place. The American people deserve--deserve--to have fully staffed administrations. So for the remainder of this Congress, Senate Republicans will double down on what we have been doing this entire Congress, and that is putting in the work to get as many nominees confirmed as possible.
I yield the floor.
I suggest the absence of a quorum.
The senior assistant legislative clerk proceeded to call the roll.
Jon Husted (R-OH)
Mr. President, I am here today to provide a farewell address.
I found it somewhat challenging to figure out how to sum up 25 years of public service in 10 minutes or so and to provide thanks to everybody who deserves it and hope for the future, but I will try. Fair warning--particularly as I see my friend from Pennsylvania here--there is a lot of Ohio bias in these remarks.
Since 2001, I have had the honor of serving in the Ohio State House, as the speaker of the house, as the secretary of state, as Lieutenant Governor, and now serving Ohio as its U.S. Senator. That service is coming to an end, and I want to reflect on why--why did you do this? Why did you run for public office in the first place?
I remember having two main goals. It was education and jobs. Those are the things that stick out in my mind as to why I did it in the first place. Why did you even do this?
Specifically, though, it was to give children trapped in chronically failing schools an opportunity to attend the school of their choice and to fix Ohio's ailing economy.
At the time, I lived in the Dayton area, and the Dayton Public Schools were dead last in education--613 out of 613. And I just didn't think it was fair that those kids should be trapped in a failing school that wasn't educating them. It just made no sense to me.
And, economically, Ohio was in a bad spot. Ohio was a high-tax, high-regulated State. The Dayton area economy and Ohio were dying. Auto plants were closing. Corporate headquarters were moving out. Population was declining. Unemployment rates were high. And the people my age were moving out of Ohio.
It was depressing. It was depressing.
Even my own family had to leave Ohio because there was no place for my dad to go to work when the factory he worked at closed down.
Many people had given up, but I didn't. Giving up is just not who I am. I didn't want what happened to my family to happen to other families. It was just tough. I wanted Ohio to be a place where our children and grandchildren wouldn't have to leave the State to find a job--because I can tell you, when your family has to leave because they lost their jobs, it is tough on everyone.
I am sure there were other things that I cared about too, at the time, but I distinctly remember these being the reasons that I decided to run for the State legislature.
Successfully running for the legislature wasn't necessarily an easy thing for me to accomplish because I was relatively new to Dayton. I didn't grow up there. I grew up in rural northwest Ohio. And I didn't exactly have the greatest ballot name--Husted. Most people couldn't pronounce it, and some still can't.
But I ran anyway, and I won a State house seat in the 2000 election. And I was off to Columbus as a young man who was soon to receive a very rude awakening about my hopes and aspirations, as it seemed that even Republicans didn't share my passion for school choice, and the old ways were hard to change when it comes to economic recovery.
The status quo has a well-deserved reputation for a reason. It got there for many years, and it is hard to change it in a few.
But, fortunately, I was too young and naive to know better. So I pressed forward.
Soon, with just 4 years of legislative experience, I was elected unanimously by my colleagues to serve as speaker of the Ohio House. After just 6 months in that role, I had managed to find the votes to pass the most fiscally conservative budget in over 40 years.
It actually cut spending. It didn't slow the growth of spending. It actually cut spending from what we had spent the year before.
And what did that allow us to do? It allowed us to reform our tax code, eliminating taxes that were driving businesses out of our State and cutting the income tax by 21 percent.
We literally had a tax that taxed businesses for investing in machinery and equipment--unbelievable.
It also included a provision to create the EdChoice Scholarship, something I remember writing down on a scrap piece of paper. I wrote the whole thing down and said: Let's turn this into a law.
And it became the first statewide voucher program for kids trapped in chronically failing schools.
This is the lesson: Never give up. Believe in yourself. You can change things. No matter where you come from, where you grew up, what your background is, you can do it.
I believe that.
Creating jobs, saving tax dollars, and helping businesses succeed in Ohio was always on my mind because we were dying; we were a troubled State.
And as Ohio secretary of state, I did work on elections, making Ohio a place where--I believe I coined the phrase "making it easy to vote and hard to cheat."
But I was focused on more than elections. I made it easier to start a small business. If you started a business, you had to go through the secretary of state's office. We modernized an antiquated process, and this is something I am proud of. We reduced the turnaround time from 4 days to less than 4 hours and cut the fees for filing to build a business by 21 percent. And those efficiencies allowed me to operate my office without using any tax dollars the last 2 years. Ohio became the fastest and least costly State in the Midwest to start and maintain a business.
I remember people telling me that I couldn't do it--all of the reasons that we couldn't do this big technology upgrade and fix it. We did in just a few years.
And as Lieutenant Governor, I continued to focus on efficiency, using AI--literately using AI before anyone knew about ChatGPT. We did it pre-ChatGPT, and we identified 5 million words--nearly one-third of the Ohio administrative code--for elimination. This regulatory reform effort saved millions of dollars and made it easier to do business in Ohio.
And, yes, you could do this at the Federal level. I think the Federal Register is 33 feet tall if you printed it out. And that was my very first bill as I got here, and so I hope someday that will happen at the Federal level.
But education and the economy were always my priorities. I saw the hardships families faced after losing jobs--shuttered factories, boarded-up homes, and struggling neighborhoods--and I wanted to build a better future for our State.
It got pretty bad in Ohio. In 2010, Ohio had a 9-percent unemployment rate, 89 cents left in our rainy day fund--we were broke--and CNBC had ranked Ohio the 34th worst State in the country to do business.
And 16 years later, it is a new day with a rising sun. As of this year, in 2026, Ohio hit the lowest unemployment rate in our State's history--3.3 percent. It had the most jobs in our State history. It has over $4 billion in the State's rainy day fund. And CNBC ranked Ohio the No. 1 State in the country to do business.
I am not going to go through all of what it takes to do this, but you don't go from 34th to first by accident. I know what it takes. I was part of most of it, and I led much of it.
I often say you can't do "Made in America" without "Made in Ohio," because from the food you eat to the cars you drive, to the trucks that deliver, to the airplanes that fly, to the steel, to the energy, to the space exploration--and, yes, even your AI and online life depend on the Ohio supply chain. We make things, and we are really good at it.
During the time I was Lieutenant Governor, I was directly involved in deals that brought new jobs from Sherwin-Williams, General Motors, Ford, Honda, Intel, Stellantis, Cleveland-Cliffs Steel, Kimberly-Clark, GE Aerospace, Anduril Industries, Joby Aviation, SNC, Google, Meta, Amazon, AWS, and many, many more large, small, and medium-sized deals to bring those businesses to Ohio--to choose Ohio as a place to grow and create jobs.
And all of this happened in a 6-year period. But this isn't about businesses or statistics because I know people will say: Oh, big corporations, businesses.
Those are jobs, folks. Those are jobs. And the people of our State had long been left behind. It made life better for people who called Ohio home. That is why it mattered.
Always remember this: A good job is security, freedom, and hope.
I have always believed that a public official's most important contribution is to help people get a good education and to create good jobs for them.
Education and economic development go together. I guess that is why I love them so much--they go hand in hand.
Let me return, though, to education for just a moment. I am really proud of what we did. I mentioned the EdChoice Scholarship, something that when I got to the Ohio Legislature was widely rejected, but I fought for it. And when I became speaker of the house, we started it from scratch, in 2005. And now, nearly 150,000 kids in Ohio annually attend a school of their choice as a result of it.
Now, let me share a story about the Choose Ohio First STEM scholarship. We started it in 2007, when people didn't even know what STEM education was. I remember having to explain it to people--like, what is STEM education? I said it is the future.
And now, after we created that program in 2007, 28,000 Ohio students have used it to get a STEM degree.
As Lieutenant Governor, I created the TechCred Program that allows Ohioans--any Ohioan--I love eliminating excuses. There are no excuses. Anyone in Ohio can earn an in-demand tech credential at no cost, often in days or weeks.
The program has served 3,500 employers and awarded 178,000 credentialing opportunities, making it one of the most popular job-training programs I have ever seen. It is just effective. It is just effective because of the way we structured it. And it is serving a need--a credential that actually leads to a job when you get it.
I became an evangelist for high school career centers, excited about how they prepared students for the workforce, and was proud to be named the Career-Technical Education Public Servant of the Year multiple times. I think they got tired of it.
I guess my love for education and the economy and efficiency made me so fond of them because students graduate from high school ready for work without debt or delay. Graduate on Friday; go to work on Monday. Many of these students had jobs before they even finished high school.
I was at one high school where the senior class had earned $2 million before they even graduated because we put them to work early. Many kids drop out of high school if they don't see the purpose.
You get them a job. They stay. They succeed.
I helped rapidly expand career-technical education, with credentials earned rising from 40,000 in 2018 to 126,660 by the class of 2023. We celebrated signing days as students graduated with jobs and job offers. What a change you can make when you put your mind to it and you just don't give up until it gets done.
These aren't just numbers. They are real people whose lives were changed, and this is what makes public service worth the sacrifice. When you get to meet people who you have actually done something to change their future, it makes it all worth it. And I can't think of anything that really makes you feel that way more than seeing a high school student who came from maybe a tough background who has a job skill and a job and hope for the future.
I hope you will see that in all of these things that I am proud of. They have nothing to do with politics, political ideology, or labels.
They are just about solving people's problems and making their lives better. That has been my passion.
There are other things I am proud of: using technology to eliminate the need to go to the BMV is one of them because it just makes common sense. People would say: Why do I have to stand in line?
Well, you don't. You don't. We fixed it. Millions of people don't have to go anymore. They just don't have to go. Yes, you can do this online. You don't have to show up.
Why do we do things like that?
"This is the bureaucracy; this is just the way we have always done it." You don't have to do it that way--creating innovation districts and hubs across Ohio, healthcare cures, innovations, jobs, all of those things. Banning smartphones in schools is something that I did before I came here, probably the single most important thing that you can do to improve the culture of a high school today in America.
Fighting for kids' online safety; winning a case before the U.S. Supreme Court, Husted v. A. Philip Randolph Institute, where we set the gold standard for voter roll maintenance.
And as a kid who came out of foster care, I am proud of what we did to help advance adoption and foster care services. I know we made a difference.
Just as an aside, we put a technology solution in place where I know thousands more kids are getting placed in foster care and finding adoptions because we eliminated the bureaucracy with it. It is just stuff like that that matters.
Since joining the U.S. Senate, I have continued to work on these issues, but, admittedly, the Federal Government is not the place you go if you want to get things done quickly. I know all of my colleagues understand that.
It is so much easier to move the ball forward at the State level. I guess that is why I believe we should return more power to the States, but that is a conversation for another day. Although my tenure in the Senate was short, we did get four bills passed and signed by the President that focused on affordability, public safety, and protecting our Great Lakes.
My passion here in the Senate, though, has been the Upward Mobility Act. We have a hearing on it later today, but I know it will not get done. And I hope others will pick up where I left off.
To my knowledge, this bill offers the greatest effort to date to end the benefits cliff that traps people in generational poverty across this Nation. In recent months, I have presented every Senator with data from their State on how their constituents are held back by the benefits cliff that is baked into the fabric of our social safety net.
What the data shows is that for many people in poverty, they make more by not working than they do by going to work--which means they are trapped. My bill creates a pilot program to smooth that cliff to provide an off-ramp to give the lowest earning Americans a path toward upward mobility and out of poverty. The bill is well researched. My team did a great job on this, and it is ready to go.
I hope that one of my colleagues or a future Senator will carry this work forward and not allow this issue to fall through the cracks. When passed, millions of Americans will have hope for a better life by experiencing the dignity of work.
This is my final speech I will deliver in this Chamber before departing the Senate. Before my time closes, though, I want to just reflect on some of the things I said in my maiden floor speech because I know when you walk from your office, through the media gauntlet to get over here, and hear all of the negative things they want you to talk about or that somebody said or did or in the algorithm that we might be trapped in that just, I would say, in many ways isolates us, we can lose perspective about what this place is supposed to be about.
But if you step into the Capitol Rotunda and you look up to the stories painted on the dome, you are reminded of an enduring pattern: Americans built our Nation through personal sacrifice, often at a steep human cost; a nation that once rallied around sacrifice in war, in rebuilding, in laying foundations for the future, however, has seemingly given way to the new cultural mood.
The collective "we" stopped sacrificing for the future and started taking from it.
From this Capitol, the harvest that was supposed to be planted for the future has been devoured. In 1967, the year I was born, the national debt stood at $330 billion; today it is over $40 trillion, and a child born today inherits $121,000 as their share of that burden.
I don't blame any individual. I don't blame any individual. We, collectively, as a nation, bear this responsibility. Selfishness must be forsaken for selflessness. That is the difference.
We only sacrifice for the things we love. If we truly love our country and our children and our grandchildren, we should stop taking from them and make sacrifices for them. You will not sacrifice for things you do not love.
We need to teach our children to love this country; otherwise, why would they ever want to sacrifice for it? We need to prove that we love our children by ending the generational theft that has occurred over the past 50 years.
And I know that is tough--so tough. I am not preaching here; I am praying. I am not trying to tell people I know the right way because I know you all know the right way, but it is hard. It is hard to overcome the politics of our time. In fact, I know it is practically impossible. But I will still pray to find a way.
So as I conclude, I want to offer my fellow colleagues my thanks; some of you, I barely know, and some of you have become dear friends. No matter what category you fall in, thank you for your service. Your work is so important. Serving Ohioans from the statehouse to the Upper Chamber of the people's House, it has been a great honor and a privilege. It really has, one for which I will always be grateful.
To my wife Tina, thank you. You have sacrificed so much. You are the best. Your sacrifice has been immeasurable. To our son Alex, daughters Katie and Kylie, daughter-in-law Kathleen, and my grandchildren Mae and Cal, my public service has been your sacrifice. I love you all, and I am very excited to spend more time with you.
To my mom and dad Jim and Judy Husted, from the day you adopted me, you have been a blessing from God. Thanks for your sacrifices and unconditional love.
To the incredible people who have worked for me over the years, some great staff people, my team has been the best. From Ohio to DC, I am grateful to all of you.
For my DC team, you have helped build a great operation in a short period of time. Thank you. All right. You are great. We made customer service our No. 1 priority. Thank you for your dedicated work. I hope your time with me will lead to some great things. I am excited to watch what all of you will do. You are going to do amazing things in life. You already have. You will do more.
Finally, to the people of the great State of Ohio, whether you voted for me or you have never voted for me, thank you for the honor of representing and serving you. Public service has given me a daily purpose in life. I am grateful for it, and I am sure I will miss it.
I leave our Nation's Capital with gratitude in my heart and enduring hope that my State and my country's best days still lie ahead.
Mr. President and colleagues, may God bless and guide you in your service and may God bless the United States of America.
I yield the floor.
The legislative clerk proceeded to call the roll.
The clerk will call the roll.
The legislative clerk called the roll.
Text printed in the Record (1,084 characters)
Armstrong Banks Barrasso Blackburn Boozman Britt Budd Capito Cassidy Collins Coons Cornyn Cortez Masto Cramer Crapo Cruz Curtis Daines Ernst Fetterman Fischer Gallego Gillibrand Graham Grassley Hagerty Hawley Heinrich Hickenlooper Hoeven Husted Hyde-Smith Johnson Justice Kennedy King Lankford Lee Lummis Marshall McConnell McCormick Moody Moran Moreno Murkowski Ossoff Peters Reed Ricketts Risch Rosen Rounds Schatz Schmitt Schumer Scott (FL) Scott (SC) Shaheen Sheehy Slotkin Sullivan Thune Tillis Tuberville Warner Warnock Whitehouse Wicker Young
Alsobrooks Baldwin Bennet Blumenthal Blunt Rochester Booker Cantwell Duckworth Durbin Hassan Hirono Kaine Kelly Kim Lujan Markey Merkley Murray Padilla Paul Sanders Smith Van Hollen Warren Welch Wyden
Cotton
Klobuchar
Murphy
Schiff
The PRESIDING OFFICER (Mr. Ricketts). On this vote, the yeas are 70 and the nays are 26.
Three-fifths of the Senators duly chosen and sworn having voted in the affirmative, the motion is agreed to. The point of order falls.
The motion was agreed to.
The PRESIDING OFFICER. The majority leader.
The motion was agreed to.
The motion was agreed to.
The clerk will call the roll.
The senior assistant legislative clerk called the roll.
Text printed in the Record (859 characters)
Armstrong Banks Barrasso Blackburn Boozman Britt Budd Capito Cassidy Collins Coons Cornyn Cotton Cramer Crapo Cruz Curtis Daines Ernst Fetterman Fischer Gallego Gillibrand Graham Grassley Hagerty Heinrich Hickenlooper Hoeven Husted Hyde-Smith Johnson Justice Kennedy King Lankford Lee Lummis Marshall McConnell McCormick Moody Moran Moreno Murkowski Ossoff Paul Peters Reed Ricketts Risch Rosen Schatz Schmitt Schumer Scott (FL) Scott (SC) Shaheen Sheehy Slotkin Sullivan Thune Tillis Tuberville Warner Warnock Whitehouse Wicker Young
Alsobrooks Baldwin Bennet Blumenthal Blunt Rochester Booker Cantwell Cortez Masto Duckworth Durbin Hassan Hirono Kaine Kelly Kim Lujan Markey Merkley Murray Padilla Rounds Sanders Smith Van Hollen Warren Welch Wyden
Hawley
Klobuchar
Murphy
Schiff
The amendment (No. 6883), in the nature of a substitute, was agreed to.
The bill clerk read as follows:
Text printed in the Record (616 characters)
We, the undersigned Senators, in accordance with the provisions of rule XXII of the Standing Rules of the Senate, do hereby move to bring to a close debate on Calendar No. 453, H.R. 2347, a bill to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to exclude from gross income any damages, other than punitive damages, received on account of any sexual acts or sexual contact.
John Thune, Shelley Moore Capito, Mike Lee, John
Barrasso, Alan Armstrong, Thom Tillis, Tom Cotton, Pete
Ricketts, Mike Crapo, Cynthia M. Lummis, Ted Budd, Jon
Husted, John R. Curtis, David McCormick, Tim Sheehy,
Steve Daines, Katie Boyd Britt.
The clerk will call the roll.
The bill clerk called the roll.
Text printed in the Record (982 characters)
Armstrong Banks Barrasso Blackburn Boozman Britt Budd Capito Cassidy Collins Coons Cornyn Cotton Cramer Crapo Cruz Curtis Daines Ernst Fetterman Fischer Gallego Gillibrand Graham Grassley Hagerty Heinrich Hickenlooper Hoeven Husted Hyde-Smith Justice Kennedy King Lankford Lee Lummis Marshall McConnell McCormick Moody Moran Moreno Murkowski Paul Reed Ricketts Risch Rosen Schatz Schmitt Schumer Scott (FL) Scott (SC) Sheehy Slotkin Sullivan Thune Tillis Tuberville Warner Warnock Whitehouse Wicker Young
Alsobrooks Baldwin Bennet Blumenthal Blunt Rochester Booker Cantwell Cortez Masto Duckworth Durbin Hassan Hawley Hirono Kaine Kelly Kim Lujan Markey Merkley Murray Ossoff Padilla Peters Rounds Sanders Shaheen Smith Van Hollen Warren Welch Wyden
Johnson Klobuchar Murphy
Schiff
The PRESIDING OFFICER (Mr. Banks). On this vote, the yeas are 65, and the nays are 31.
Three-fifths of the Senators duly chosen and sworn having voted in the affirmative, the motion is agreed to.
The motion was agreed to
Marsha Blackburn (R-TN)
Mr. President, I am on the floor today talking about an issue we have discussed many, many times, and it is about how big tech companies put profits over the safety of our children.
Now, there are some things that we have learned over the past several years about what Big Tech does.
And these are not things that are conjecture; these are facts--facts--that are widely discussed, facts that are known, facts that we hear from parents and principals and teachers and even kids themselves.
We know for a fact that big tech companies have intentionally designed product features to foster addiction in children. We know that because of this addictive feature, children are spending 8\1/2\ hours a day doomscrolling. That is not a number I just pulled out of thin air; that is a number that we hear from our Surgeon General. We hear it from different groups that are working with children.
Now, we also know that these big tech companies have chosen to turn a blind eye to the consequences of this addiction, including rising eating disorders, depression, and anxiety among children. They have chosen to say "Well, it really doesn't exist" even though we have found out that they have research that proves the point that it does exist. And we know--we know--from research that children are exposed to appalling harms and relationships, from sexual predators to illicit drugs. Most kids today that meet a drug dealer meet them online. Most children that meet a groomer meet them online. Same thing with a sexual predator or a pedophile or some perpetrator.
What we have seen is this illicit and harmful activity has moved from the physical space to the virtual space because these traffickers and drug dealers and predators and pedophiles are sick human beings. They are sick, and they are also somebody who wants to hide behind the algorithm so that nobody knows what they are doing.
Social media companies will tell you that to enhance their profits and to keep their business model, they need to keep children doomscrolling as long as possible. They will tell you that the more time a teenager spends online, the more data they are generating. The more data they are generating, the richer that data is. And guess what. They make more money. These are the greediest companies that we have. They are harming our kids in order to make more money and monetize that data. To me, this is an appalling business model.
Now we are beginning to see the courts take some action on this, and they are doing it because Congress has not taken action. In August, Meta agreed to pay $17.1 billion--$17.1 billion--in penalties to resolve claims that it designed its platforms, including Facebook and Instagram, to foster addiction among minors. They have admitted they have done this.
They also agreed to implement safeguards for children, including a default 2-hour time limit. They know doomscrolling is a bad thing. This settlement is a victory for parents across the country who have fought for accountability after losing their children to social media harms, and it is also a victory for the bipartisan coalition of our States attorneys general who secured the settlement and really deserve so much credit.
See, because Congress has refused to act, the States have had to step up and fill that gap in order to protect children. But the work on this really is far from over.
Under the settlement, Meta is only required to implement safety measures for 10 years, so basically, they are saying: We know we are guilty. We know this is not something that is healthy for our kids. But you know what, we are going to stand down for 10 years, and then we will be back.
While States can attempt to force changes company by company through litigation, only Congress can establish a uniform national standard governing how online platforms must protect children by designing with safety in mind. That is why I have come to the floor today to seek unanimous consent to pass the Kids Online Safety Act that Senator Blumenthal and I have worked on for years.
KOSA would save lives by ensuring safety by design isn't optional for big tech companies. At the heart of this legislation is a duty of care requiring all--every--social media platform--not one or two but all of them--to prevent foreseeable dangers to children, including sexual abuse, illicit drugs, and self-harm.
Here is why this is so important: Every industrial sector that we have has safety-by-design standards. If you buy a car, there are safety standards. Indeed, auto manufacturers will tell you: That is item No. 1--make the car safe to drive. They don't tell you how to drive the car, when to drive the car, what speed to drive the car; they tell you the car is safe to drive.
If you go buy a toaster oven, they tell you the toaster is safe to use. They don't tell you how and when to use it but that when you use it, it is going to be a safe product.
You can go through all of our industrial sectors but guess what--the virtual space has not one--not one--safety standard. It is the lone exception. When children are online, there are no protections from the harms they see online. There are no protections. Nothing. In the physical space, you have those protections, but in the virtual space, you do not, and we need to ensure that our children are safe.
Mr. President, therefore, notwithstanding rule XXII, I ask unanimous consent that the Committee on Commerce, Science, and Transportation be discharged from further consideration of S. 1748 and the Senate proceed to its immediate consideration; further, that the Blackburn substitute amendment at the desk be agreed to; that the bill, as amended, be considered read a third time and passed; and the motion to reconsider be considered made and laid upon the table.
Text printed in the Record (269 characters)
Once again, a piece of federal legislation with broad powers and vague definitions threatens Pro-Life . . . speech. . . . [Those] targeted by a weaponized federal government will always include Pro-Life Americans, defending mothers and their children--born and preborn.
Text printed in the Record (271 characters)
Already the Pro-Life Generation faces discrimination, de-platforming, and short- and long-term bans from social media on the whims of others. Students for Life Action calls for a NO vote on KOSA to prevent viewpoint discrimination from becoming federal policy at the FTC.
Marsha Blackburn (R-TN)
Mr. President, the gentleman is wrong with the statements he just made, and I would like to point out why the gentleman is wrong in his statement.
First of all, Kentucky. Let's talk about Kentucky. Eighteen percent of Kentucky high school students--that is nearly one in five--reported being electronically bullied through texting, Instagram, Facebook, or other social media. That compares with 16 percent nationally. So it is worse in Kentucky. Maybe the gentleman would like to help protect students in Kentucky. Nineteen percent of Kentucky high school students seriously considered attempting suicide during the previous year, and 30 percent missed at least 1 day of school because of poor mental health.
I would encourage each of us to find out what the stats are in your State.
Another area where the gentleman is missing the bill--and I would encourage him to actually read the bill--is that this is a product-designed bill; it is not focused on content. So his premise about free speech is misplaced.
And if he thinks it is going to open a Pandora's box, did having safety protections open a Pandora's box on the auto industry? Does it open a Pandora's box on appliance manufacturers or furniture manufacturers?
And most people would look at me and say: No, that is silly because having those standards protects the public.
And we know that having a standard would protect our children. We know that one in four children between ages 9 and 17 reports having an online, sexually explicit interaction with somebody that they finally decided had to be an adult. Think about that: one in four of our precious children. And 59 percent of U.S. teens have reported being cyber bullied because of the virtual space.
Now, let's talk about free speech because my colleague is, again, not understanding the bill. As I said, it is not about a free speech issue. It is about product design and safety, and the bill explicitly focuses on design features.
Now, to lay it out for my colleague, section 102(a) says a "platform" must "exercise reasonable care in the creation and implementation of any design feature."
Now that is what we would expect of people that are creating a product for the American marketplace--that they would "exercise reasonable care."
Also, the bill even defines a "design feature" so that this is not ambiguous, because we want it to be accurate.
So 101(4) is a platform feature that--a design feature in 101(4) is a platform feature or component that encourages or increases the "frequency, time spent, or activity of minors" on the platform.
Now, this is just to say: We know, if you are designing it to addict children, you have got to design this so that you are not encouraging addictive behavior. And the bill specifically protects a child who goes looking for content.
Let's say a child wanted to find content about eating disorders or pregnancy or whatever. Section 102(b)(1) says the duty of care--and this is important for my colleagues to understand--the duty of care cannot be construed to require a platform to prevent a minor from "deliberately and independently searching for, or specifically requesting, content."
Section 102(b)(2) says nothing--nothing--that the duty of care can be construed to allow government enforcement "based upon the viewpoint of users expressed . . . through speech, expression, or information protected by the First Amendment."
So his objections are answered. They are answered in the language in this bill.
When I meet with parents that have lost their children to suicide, to sextortion, to other harms--meeting a drug dealer, a sex trafficker, a groomer online--my heart breaks for them, because until Congress takes an action--an action that is not based on conjecture but is based on the fact that these social media platforms have now admitted doomscrolling is a problem, addictive features--this is a problem. We need to take an action and protect our children.
We say children can't drive before they are 16. You can't take them into a pornographic movie. You cannot expose them to other harms. If you sell alcohol to a minor, your liquor store is going to be padlocked. If you try to expose them to pornographic magazines, they will shut down your Minute Market. But in the virtual space, our children are being harmed every day.
You cannot unsee this stuff. It is regrettable--absolutely regrettable--that we have passed this bill before 91 to 3. We have 77 cosponsors, but yet we have a couple of people that are trying to make it something that it is not. It is a product design bill, not a content bill.
So, concerned parents across this country, we are going to find a way to get this bill passed.
To my House colleagues and my friends on both sides of the aisle in the Senate, let's make certain that before we adjourn sine die, we have passed the Kids Online Safety Act and that we are standing to protect our children.
I yield the floor.
Richard J. Durbin (D-IL)
Mr. President, what makes America great is our aspiration to uphold the inherent dignity, equality, and inalienable rights of all of our people.
All too often, when we are faced with threats, there are those who would cast these foundational ideals aside. Unfortunately, after the terrorist attacks on September 11, that view prevailed, promoted by those in power who believed that the risk of another attack justified compromising our basic values.
This January marks the 25th anniversary of the opening of detention camps for suspected terrorists at Guantanamo Bay. Many of us remember the infamous photographs of blindfolded men, in shackles and orange jumpsuits, on their knees in fenced cages.
The expressed purpose of sending captured suspects to Guantanamo was to detain them in a legal black hole. Our nation's leaders wanted a place where detainees could be held and interrogated beyond the reach of our laws, our courts, our Constitution, and our ideals of justice and dignity.
Detainees were tortured and subjected to unspeakable abuse at Guantanamo, as well as at secret CIA black sites around the world. Most were held in indefinite detention without charges or trial. The few who were charged were in makeshift military commissions.
Americans were told this illegal and inhumane treatment was not only lawful but necessary and justified because these men were terrorists and "the worst of the worst."
Some of them were, but many were innocent people in the wrong place at the wrong time or simply had the wrong name. Some were picked up because they had a neighbor with a grudge or an interest in bounty money.
This betrayal of our values weakened America. Rather than making us safer, we fueled terrorist recruitment, surrendered the moral high ground in the argument, wasted the good will of our allies, and damaged our standing in the world.
This astronomically expensive offshore prison also cost American taxpayers--and continues to--billions of dollars more than if we had used our time-tested Federal court system.
Meanwhile, thousands of 9/11 families continue to suffer from the emotional and financial loss of their loved ones--loss compounded by the failure of our government to give them a modicum of justice.
Twenty-five years after the attacks, the 9/11 trial still has not begun, and key confessions have been ruled too tainted by torture to be admissible in the court or a hearing.
For all of these reasons, I have held hearings, introduced legislation, and I came to this floor dozens of times, over the years, to push for the closure of Guantanamo.
Four years ago, I chaired a full committee hearing in the Senate Judiciary Committee about the urgent need to restore the rule of law by closing Guantanamo and resolving, finally, these cases.
At the hearing, we heard powerful testimony from Colleen Kelly, a family nurse practitioner in the Bronx, NY. Colleen's brother Bill was attending a conference at Windows on the World in the North Tower that fateful morning.
Colleen described the repeated heartbreak of watching one surviving 9/11 family member after another die without receiving the justice and closure that they sought.
This is not right. These victims' families deserve better. Our hurt and healing Nation deserves better.
We should have learned by now that we are strongest as a nation and as a people when we uphold human dignity and the rule of law.
Instead, we left the Guantanamo playbook open and available for President Trump and Stephen Miller.
Trump vowed during his Presidential campaign in 2016 that he would not only keep Guantanamo open but he would also "load it up with some bad dudes." And now, in his second term, the President is making good on his threat by sending immigrants to this grotesque facility.
Most are migrants who have come to America seeking safety from persecution and torture, or simply a better life. But Trump and Miller are seeking to avoid our laws and our courts by shipping these immigrants off to legal black holes around the world, faster than the courts can stop them.
Let me tell you about one of them, Victor Omar Bonilla Alvarez.
Victor escaped years of torture and abuse at the hands of MS-13 and law enforcement in El Salvador. He has no criminal record. An immigration judge granted him withholding of removal to El Salvador based on his credible fear of torture if he returned.
After months of confinement in the United States, our government decided to send Mr. Alvarez to Guantanamo. Then, after months of confinement there, the government transferred him to Arizona and then swiftly removed him to Mexico. They did all this without informing his counsel and without any assurance from Mexico that he would not be sent to El Salvador.
Victor's story is sad but not unique. The administration has sent an estimated 25,000 people to third countries, denying them due process and legal protection against persecution and torture.
Many like Victor risk being returned to torture. Others are being indefinitely detained in abysmal conditions and with little or no access to the rule of law or any hope for the future.
Violating the law to send people away to be persecuted or tortured, is this who we are? Is this American? Is this who we aspire to be?
With the new year and a new Congress on the horizon, I hope our next generation of leaders will continue to fight for the ideals that made this Nation great and finally close the Guantanamo detention facility.
I yield the floor.
Mr. President, I suggest the absence of a quorum.
The senior assistant legislative clerk proceeded to call the roll.
Text printed in the Record (65 characters)
Change is in the air, and we cannot avoid it much less ignore it.
Steve Daines (R-MT)
Those were the words that my fellow Montanan, the then-Senate majority leader Mike Mansfield, used in 1971 to describe the bipartisan frustration with the growing abuse of the filibuster. Senator Mansfield knew that substantial reforms to the cloture rule were desperately needed, both to prevent a revolt from Senators and to protect the power and prestige of this institution. That was 1971. Mansfield feared the Senate could even become an innocuous House of Lords that would seek influence of the House of Representatives.
Unfortunately, the reforms that the Senate adopted during the 1970s and since have failed to safeguard this institution as a deliberative and functional body. And by any fair measure, dysfunction in the Senate has only gotten worse, and this institution has only become weaker in the decades since.
As my former colleague from the State of Utah Senator Orrin Hatch, who served 42 years as a U.S. Senator, said during his final speech in 2018 on this floor, "The Senate, as an institution, is in crisis."
Today, many Members on both sides of the aisle share this unfortunate and unacceptable conclusion, and demand for institutional change is once again in the air.
There is bipartisan concern that the Senate is not carrying out our article I powers and responsibilities. It has been diminished. We are concerned that this body is incapable of addressing the pressing challenges our country faces, and we are concerned that a diminished Senate will ultimately threaten our country's prosperity and even our national security.
But I hope I have some good news--some better news. I rise to discuss my comprehensive, bipartisan plan with Democratic Senator Jeff Merkley of Oregon to halt the Senate's decline and restore its power and influence, all while protecting its distinguishing characteristics.
Following one term in the U.S. House, I have had the privilege of serving in the U.S. Senate now for 12 years. I immediately felt the weight of this office as soon as I took the oath: advice and consent of every Supreme Court and Cabinet nominee, a muscular role in shaping foreign policy, serving as the jury at impeachment trials, and being the ultimate decider of whether treaties are ratified or fall by the wayside. All of this is decided not by 435 legislators but, uniquely, just 100 here in the U.S. Senate, as the Founding Fathers intended.
The Framers of the Senate knew that greater responsibilities could draw political opposition and, at least for a short time, be at odds with the fickle passions of energetic citizens. So they sought to protect the Senate from reckless shifts in public opinion by establishing 6-year terms, having the Senate be a continuous body where only one-third of the Senators would be up for reelection every 2 years and, in its original design, having Senators appointed by State legislatures rather than direct elections.
The Framers also established a higher eligibility age and, in fact, longer citizenship requirements for U.S. Senators. Taken together, these characteristics of the Senate were designed intentionally to help ensure that Senators exercised a more deliberative and mature judgment, insulated to a greater degree from the shifting passions of public opinion. In the words of James Madison, the Senate is supposed to be a necessary fence against hasty and unwise decisions that the Framers knew the House would sometimes make.
And I haven't even mentioned the most profound and perhaps brilliant feature of the U.S. Senate, and that, of course, is that every State gets equal representation in the Senate. My State of Montana, which ranks 43rd in population, has as much voting power as California; Rhode Island has as much as Texas; and the list goes on.
I am not sure we sufficiently appreciate how important this feature of the Senate was in 1789 and remains today. So let me offer a few stats to drive it home. In the House, the combined delegations of just nine States make up the majority of House Members. Let me repeat that. More than half of the House seats come from nine States: California, Texas, Florida, New York, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Ohio, Georgia, and North Carolina. Together, these 9 States control 221 House seats--more than the 218 that constitute a majority.
This occurred for the simple reason that the size of a State's delegation in the House is determined by population. And as one can expect, roughly half of our country's population resides in those nine States. The other half resides in the other 41 States. This feature of the House empowers larger populated States with substantially greater voting power compared to smaller populated States.
Now, let's compare that to the design of the U.S. Senate. Because each State gets 2 seats, it takes the combined representation of 25 States--or 26 for the party that doesn't control the Presidency--to establish a majority. Not 9 States, but at least 25.
Let me drive this home as well. The largest 25 States by population make up nearly 85 percent of our country's population. Yet they control half of the Senate seats. In the House, these same 25 States control 361 seats. In the Senate, the 25 States with the lowest populations represent 15 percent of the country's population. They could theoretically defeat a proposal supported by the largest 25 States. In practice, this remarkable characteristic of the Senate ensures that a composite of both large and smaller populated States is needed to pass legislation or confirm a nominee.
Some might view that as a bug. The Framers strongly viewed that as a feature. Only this institution, the U.S. Senate, ensures that the interest of smaller populated States, like Montana, cannot be single-handedly crushed by larger populated States.
As James Madison wrote in Federalist 58: In the House, the larger States will have the most weight; in the Senate, the advantage will be in favor of the smaller States.
In fact, Madison added, in Federalist 62, that the structure of the Senate would serve as a "complicated check" against "improper legislation." He emphasizes that support from both "a majority of the people"--this is the House of Representatives--and the "majority of the States"--that is, the Senate--would be required to enact a bill.
In fact, Madison envisioned that the Senate served as a bulwark against bad bills, even while indicating that a numerical majority would be sufficient to pass bills both in the House and the Senate.
What I just said there is very important in terms of Madison's intent that it would be a majority, numeric majority, to pass a bill in the House and the Senate.
To summarize thus far, the two most important distinguishing characteristics of the Senate are facilitating a more deliberative and politically insulated judgment and giving equal voting power to every State regardless of population.
Over time, these bedrock features of the U.S. Senate have been expanded substantially and arguably distorted. And in that vein, nothing generates more discussion than the shifting concept of the filibuster. The term "filibuster" has historically been hard to define. But today, it is synonymous of a supermajority cloture rule requiring 60 votes to shut off debate before a vote on passage can occur. Stated more colloquially: It takes 60 votes to pass most legislation in the U.S. Senate.
But did the Framers of the Senate think of the common procedural delays of their era in the same way? And did the men who first served as Senators and wrote our first rules in 1789 give any indication that the supermajority would effectively be required to pass legislation?
What exactly was the Framers' vision for how the Senate would operate?
Well, for that answer, I didn't seek one-sided resources that perhaps prejudged conclusion based on their own political preferences. No, I learned when I was in high school debate at Bozeman High School, it is critical to examine a wide range of scholarship from historians, from political scientists, and, in fact, our former colleagues. And that is exactly what I have tried to do today and will unpack here over the course of the next hour or so.
It began just months after I took office in the U.S. Senate in January of 2015. I asked then the nonpartisan Congressional Research Service to provide an overview of the scholarship and answer these following questions: Did the Framers intend for the Senate to operate under majority rule? A fundamental question.
Did they envision the filibustering tactics that we have seen in recent decades?
Did they envision legislation or nominations needing support from a supermajority of Senators before a vote on passage or confirmation could occur?
And what actually happened in 1806 when the Senate discarded the previous question motion that was included in the original Senate rules?
To be clear, I didn't ask CRS to put a thumb on the scale or draw its own conclusions, but, instead, to provide an overview of how scholars addressed these questions. And I can tell you: CRS put a lot of thought into that memo. It took over a year to complete and involved many conversations with my staff. But in May of 2016, CRS sent me the memo, and I am sharing it publicly for the benefits of all Senators, for those who are students of this body, and the public.
To summarize at length, CRS reviewed the scholarship and observed that: One, scholars generally agree that there is little evidence that the Framers or early Senators expected the filibuster to be a defining feature of the institution.
Second, they concluded that Senate scholars rarely claim that the Framers intended for the Senate to allow extended debate. CRS references political scientist Gregory Wawro's Senate testimony in 2010, that there is "ample evidence" that the Framers envision the Senate legislating by simple majority.
CRS cites scholars Sarah Binder and Stephen Smith who point out that the Framers were concerned about supermajority requirements following the failure of the Articles of Confederation. In fact, Binder and Smith highlight Alexander Hamilton's warning against supermajority requirements in Federalist 22.
Further, CRS writes that the original rules of the Senate "imposed limits on what might be viewed as unnecessary debate," including rule IV, which said: No member shall speak more than twice in any one debate on the same day, without leave of the Senate. Today's rule XIX is similar in concept.
Citing the research of Historian Richard Beeman, the memo notes that, in an 1801 parliamentary manual drafted by Thomas Jefferson, then President of the Senate--he put this together in 1801--he stated this:
Text printed in the Record (83 characters)
No one is to speak impertinently or beside the question, superfluous, or tediously.
Steve Daines (R-MT)
The nonbinding, but influential, manual also stated: The voice of the majority decides.
On the other hand, the CRS memo points out that some scholars argue that the filibuster is consistent with the Framers' intentions for the Senate, even though the Framers did not conceive of it. CRS references Senate scholar George Haynes' conclusion in 1938, that establishing a straightforward, simple majority cloture tool would violate the distinguishing characteristics of the Senate that I previously highlighted and result in hasty decisions.
The memo quotes from Senator Robert Byrd's renowned remark to new Senators in 1996, during which he highlighted the "Senate's absolute right to unlimited debate and to amend or block legislation passed by the lower house." Byrd also reminded them that "Senators were intended to take the long view and be able to resist, if need be, the passions of the often intemperate House."
Similarly, the memo references former Senate Parliamentarian Robert Dove and Richard Arenberg's conclusion that the supermajority rules of the Senate provide a useful test when the majority may be overzealous.
Regarding the elimination of the previous question motion of 1806, CRS notes that the motion was used rarely and for the purpose of postponing debate "on account of its delicate or sensitive nature," not to shut off debate. CRS observes that scholars generally agreed with this point.
CRS writes that the historical evidence supports neither the claim that the original rule was meant to shut off debate at a simple majority threshold, nor the competing claim that the elimination of the motion in 1806 was a deliberate decision by the Senate to establish a right to a limited debate.
Finally, CRS points to research indicating that the Framers of the Senate were familiar with obstructionist tactics used in colonial legislatures, such as denying a quorum to block a vote and sought to balance the interest of the minority and majority when they established the Senate's core rules in the Constitution.
The CRS memo is an overview; it is a primer. On balance, there seems to be a good deal of consensus that the Framers expected the Senate to operate on a majority rule, unless otherwise prescribed in the Constitution. It did not establish or envision unlimited debate as a feature of the Senate.
At the same time, CRS found that some of our Senate colleagues and scholars of this institution believe the gradual expansion of the filibuster was a natural outgrowth of the Framers' intent for the Senate and is now nothing short of essential.
But what is acknowledged by virtually everyone, however, is that the rules and the practices of the Senate have changed substantially since this body first met in 1789.
The CRS memo was just the beginning of our exploration. Over the years, we have done an even deeper dive into the scholarship to gain a better understanding of how the Senate came to be a supermajoritarian body on most issues. What happened? And how did it happen?
This is going to take some time, but I think it is important to walk through the history and share with my colleagues and the American people just how the Senate got to where we are today. It won't be an exhaustive list of Senate actions or dissect every counterfactual, but my aim is to provide an accurate and comprehensive account of what happened, while pointing to additional resources for those who want to explore further.
As former Senate Historian Betty Koed and others have observed, the use of parliamentary tactics and procedural tricks to delay a vote on legislation dates back to the Senate in Rome. Forcing a delay on a vote can show constituents their leaders are fighting for them. It can encourage the majority to offer concessions. It can block a passage of a bill when a quorum is denied, especially at the end of a session, and it can affect attendance and impact the outcome of the vote.
In fact, we saw that latter motivation during the very first session in the U.S. Senate in 1789. Senator William Maclay of Pennsylvania wrote in his journal that Senators from Virginia and North Carolina "talked the time away" to avoid a vote on a House-passed legislation that would establish our Nation's permanent capital on the Susquehanna River near what is today Columbia, PA. These southern Senators spoke at length because another southern Senator was out sick and could not vote. They didn't want an attendance issue to determine the outcome of the vote.
Well, Maclay continues. There was a must-see hot air balloon the next day in New York City where our first Senate was meeting, and so the vote was delayed yet again.
The delays didn't last long. However, just one day later, the Senate voted on legislation to determine the permanent location of our Nation's Capital. Maclay's fellow Senator from Pennsylvania, Robert Morris, opposed the Susquehanna location and instead wanted our Nation's Capital to be Germantown near Philadelphia.
Senator Morris led a successful amendment to change the capital site to Germantown. The vote was 9 to 9 with Vice President Adams breaking the tie in the affirmative.
The House soon adopted the Germantown site, but they included an additional amendment. The session of Congress ended at the end of September before final differences could be resolved.
It is fair to say that had the Pennsylvania delegation in the Senate and the House more quickly agreed on where they wanted the capital, we would be in Philadelphia today. But, alas, here we are along the Potomac instead.
In all seriousness, I urge my colleagues to keep in mind what occurred here. The stalling tactic used by the southern Senators was driven by an attendance concern, and the vote was delayed by merely 2 days. Further and crucially, Senators had a right to amend, and the vote on related amendments and passage was at a simple majority. Yet a dilatory move was initially used, but it did not suppress what the majority of voting Senators supported. And even though it was a contentious matter and a close vote, there were no supermajority requirements anywhere in the process. These Senators did not envision anything like the current, modern-day filibuster.
Beeman, the historian, writes:
Text printed in the Record (187 characters)
The Rules [of the] Committee of the First Congress did not anticipate the problems created by lengthy debate; certainly they did not envision the development of the filibustering tactics.
Text printed in the Record (118 characters)
Tactics patently obstructive, however, were characteristics of the House long before they became common in the Senate.
Text printed in the Record (117 characters)
Perhaps the most striking feature of the discussion was the lack of concern for freedom of debate in minority rights.
Text printed in the Record (217 characters)
Southerners were over twice as likely to obstruct as were free state Senators. . . . But it is worth emphasizing that the data indicate that, overall, Senators exercised abundant restraint in their use of obstruction.
Text printed in the Record (698 characters)
By bizarre happenstance, senators learned to exploit the
tediousness of Senate debate as a parliamentary weapon that
gave them individually and collectively immense legislative
and political power--more so than any other legislators
anywhere. This was the filibuster.
On the whole, however, the Senate still operated under majority rule, despite the long-winded speeches and this filibuster.
In fact, Wawro and Schickler summarized:
When an issue was salient to both the majority and the minority, the pre-cloture Senate was essentially majoritarian, with the sole caveat being that the filibuster in the final days of a Congress posed a genuine threat to legislation [as the clock ran out].
Text printed in the Record (137 characters)
Even in the absence of formal rules restricting debate, majorities typically were able to overcome obstruction in the pre-cloture Senate.
Text printed in the Record (106 characters)
The spirit of reciprocity results in much, if not most, of the senators' actual power not being exercised.
Text printed in the Record (251 characters)
The modern filibuster . . . has little to do with deliberation and even less to do with debate. The modern filibuster is simply a minority veto, and a powerful one at that. It is not part of a long Senate tradition and history alone cannot justify it.
Text printed in the Record (358 characters)
The filibuster is a powerful tool, and it ought to be invoked only in extraordinary circumstances. . . . Senators are obliged to exercise their best judgment when invoking their right to extend debate. They also should be obliged to actually filibuster, that is, go to the Floor and talk, instead of finding [a] less strenuous way to accomplish the same end.
(Ms. LUMMIS assumed the Chair.)
(Mr. SCHMITT assumed the Chair.)
Steve Daines (R-MT)
The work of gaining bipartisan cosponsors, receiving a legislative hearing, securing bipartisan passage, witnesses traveling in for hearings, having markups ultimately went for nothing.
I know this isn't a perfect metric. There could be other reasons why the Senate's dysfunction--there could be other reasons beyond the Senate's dysfunction that some of the bills became stuck in the mud. But the reality is, hundreds of bipartisan committee-passed bills had no place to go should motivate this body to find an alternative way to allow these bills to at least get a vote.
Under our proposal, the chairman and ranking member--it is a bipartisan combination--could motion to bring committee-passed bipartisan bills to the floor under suspension. They could bundle bills together and meet the eligibility of bipartisanship.
Members would have the right to motion to strike a bill or provision they oppose, but otherwise the proposal or set of proposals would go straight to a vote on passage without amendment after a specified number of hours of debate. And if they gained the support of 67 more Senators, it would pass.
This proposal, while having the potential to become enormously useful, is not a new concept in the Senate. In fact, under the current rule X, two-thirds of Senators can determine the next subject for consideration on the Senate floor. And if there are at least 67 Senators to orchestrate a motion to bring a bill to the floor, it could be reasonably concluded that there are probably at least 67 Senators who would support its passage.
I am told that rule X hasn't been used since the 1940s. The process for considering the bill, once it comes to the floor, is ill-defined and, frankly, unclear. But the concept of bringing legislation to the floor and passing it at a two-thirds threshold already exists in today's Senate rules.
Meanwhile, rule V of the Senate prescribes the process for suspending other rules. Interestingly enough, before 1915, the Senate could suspend rules, pass legislation with a simple majority threshold, and the body did so at least 13 times before the rule was changed in 1915 to require a two-thirds threshold.
Our proposal would establish a straightforward process to pass bipartisan bills with the support of at least two-thirds of the Senators.
The third and fourth proposals overlap considerably and represent the boldest colors of our plan. We propose establishing a new mechanism to both process and pass bipartisan bills at simple majority thresholds. This tool could be used for authorizing appropriations bills.
This is another derivative of the Prevent Government Shutdowns Act. Our intent is to address the double whammy of the current practice of the cloture rule.
Rule XXII erects a supermajority barrier that even bipartisan bills with majority support sometimes can't clear. On the other hand, it is readily used to stifle the right to amend once 60 votes are locked down and debate is shut off.
Here is how our plan would work: The chairman and ranking member of the committee of jurisdiction could give notice of intent to bring legislation to the floor after it has passed committee with strong bipartisan support. The notice would provide every Member of the Senate--on and off committee--with the opportunity to file amendments. The chair and the ranking member would be required to identify at least eight amendments for authorizing bills, 20 minutes for appropriations bills, equally divided, by Republican- and Democrat-led amendments. That is right. Believe it or not, our plan restores the Senate's right to amend.
For most of my 12 years in the Senate, the right to amend has been a caricature of what it has been in generations past. In an unfortunate irony, deliberation in the era of cloture and pain-free filibustering is but a fragment of what it once was, and substantive floor amendments are but crumbs. Too often, the Senate is a body in the midst of a quorum call, not deliberation.
More often than not, Senators have had very few opportunities to amend. Sure, there are times where noncontroversial amendments can be added to a managers' package or substitute amendment, and there are times when some amendments, including so-called poison pills, get votes in exchange for reducing postcloture debate but only if the amendment is certain to fail.
Our proposal seeks to restore the opportunity for votes for a third bucket of amendments. Those that are bipartisan would make substantive changes to legislation that its sponsors or managers might prefer to exclude but that are germane to the bill and, in fact, might even pass if they get a vote.
These amendments should not be suppressed, especially if they are bipartisan. And if they create a policy conflict that must be resolved in the House in a formal or informal conference down the road, I say that is OK. That is how the regular order of deliberations worked in the past and should work again.
Under our plan, amendments would be listed in the motion that brings the measure to the floor. The motion requires 16 signers--16 signers--similar to rule XXII's cloture process, but to gain fast-track consideration on the Senate floor, it must be signed by the chairman and ranking member, plus at least three other Republican and Democratic Members--both sides--who do not sit on the committee of jurisdiction.
The legislation would come to the floor with 15 additional calendar days, provided the motion is signed by the requisite composition of Senators.
Amendment votes would be guaranteed including for off-committee Members. The amendment tree could not be filled. Regular order would be restored.
Members would debate the underlying bill and amendments and vote on the amendments within the prescribed number of hours. Typically, authorizing bills could be amended and voted on within one calendar day after they hit the floor. Appropriations bills could pass within two calendar days.
And, finally, the proposals allow the chairman and ranking member to bundle bipartisan committee-passed bills. Up to three appropriations bills could be combined and considered on the floor without the need for unanimous consent.
The budget and appropriations process is one of my greatest frustrations. Here is a staggering and stunning fact that most Members are aware of but--I am guessing--maybe most folks back home aren't aware of: The Senate and the House have not enacted all 12 appropriations bills by September 30, the end of the fiscal year, since 1996; 30 years--30 years--of continuing resolutions, minibuses, omnibuses.
In theory, the Senate should have considered 144 appropriations bills over my 12 years in this institution. But on 58 occasions, bipartisan appropriations bills that cleared committee, sometimes with votes of 27 to 0, never came before the full Senate for consideration. For various reasons, they became stuck.
My proposals with Senator Merkley would make both omnibuses and government shutdowns much less likely. They would empower every Senator with the right to amend these bills on the Senate floor. And if utilized regularly, they could help stop the trend of the majority party going outside of the appropriations process to fund contentious programs or policies.
I mentioned a minute ago that our proposal allows bipartisan bills to be both processed and passed with simple majority support. We create what is often called a majoritarian exception.
While it is true that the filibuster typically requires supermajority support to pass legislation, it is also true that majoritarian exceptions in the Senate are quite common.
According to Senate scholar Molly Reynolds, there are at least 161 majoritarian exceptions in law. To put this more clearly, on at least 161 occasions, the U.S. Senate has voted to prohibit filibusters on specified topics to allow related legislation to pass with simple majority support. We saw this as recently as 2021 when the Senate voted to create an exception to the filibuster to allow a subsequent bill of raising the debt limit to pass with only majority support.
We see majoritarian exceptions come to the Senate floor on a regular basis: reconciliation; War Powers Resolutions; Congressional Review Act resolutions; budget rescissions; canceling weapons sales; free-trade agreements established under trade promotion authority. Some, such as the Base Realignment and Closure--or BRAC, as it is called--are not used very often but still very much exist.
And you will notice that in the modern Senate, most of these fast-tracked or privileged majoritarian exceptions are used for overwhelmingly partisan initiatives. Sometimes the party who holds the trifecta of the White House, the Senate, and the House use them to enact sweeping reforms, and other times the minority party seeks them to use them to rein in Presidential actions. But the point is the same: They are primarily used for party-line initiatives.
My proposal with Senator Merkley encourages exactly the opposite. It establishes the majoritarian exception in Senate rules but only for bipartisan bills. It incentivizes and rewards bipartisan policymaking, empowers committees to go forth and conquer, and brings the Senate back to its original design and practice, and that is debate, amend, vote.
We are hopeful that these reforms will help lower the temperature of the Senate.
And for those of us who think it would be damaging for the Senate to use the nuclear option to pass even more party-line legislation, I would respectfully suggest that adopting these reforms and using them would reduce the likelihood that either party would take that unwanted action.
To summarize, our plan reduces unnecessary procedural delays, establishes a modern tool to pass less controversial bills under suspension, and creates a separate fast-track tool, a simple majority, 51-vote threshold for bipartisan bills, one that provides every Member the opportunity to amend.
I would like to respond to some common concerns about substantial changes to Senate rules. The first and most prominent is the concern that the Senate will become just like the House.
Well, to say the obvious, our proposal doesn't touch any of the Senate's distinguishing features contained in the Constitution I highlighted earlier. States will continue to have equal representation. Our terms will continue to be 6 years. And, of course, the 17th Amendment provided for direct elections more than a century ago for Senators.
So it seems skepticism should be given to any claim the U.S. Senate will become irreparably broken by discouraging the modern practice of the filibuster, considering the Framers did not envision it or suggest it was imperative for the function of this body.
But I know exactly what concern Senators are getting at. The unfortunate reality is that, in practice, the Senate is not immune from political pressure. Far too often, we are not the "temperate and responsible body of citizens" that exists "to suspend the blow mediated by the people"--that is the House of Representatives--"against themselves until reason, justice, and truth can regain their authority over the public mind," as James Madison so masterfully described the Senate in Federalist 63.
While our 6-year terms remain intact, majority control of the Senate is up for grabs every 2 years. Politics weigh heavily on decision making in the Senate, just as they do in the House. As an institution, the Senate is no longer nearly as politically insulated as our Founding Fathers had hoped.
I saw this firsthand when I was the NRSC Chairman in 2024. I helped lead the effort to restore a Republican majority, and 2 years later, the Democrats took it right back.
I must say that wasn't exactly the parting gift I had hoped for from my colleagues across the aisle.
If this were merely an academic exercise, I would suggest that what is broken in the Senate is not the concept that a majority of States should still be able to pass a bill but, instead, that the deliberative judgment the Framers envisioned for the Senate has deteriorated.
But as I said earlier, this isn't an academic exercise. We must be clear-eyed about the dangers of the politicly charged time we live in.
And for that reason, I think there is merit to the concern that returning an outright majority rule in the Senate, especially if done with the nuclear option, would do major and lasting harm to this institution. Worse, it could further divide our citizens and create dangerous instability across our country.
Our plan seeks a healthy balance. It encourages the Senate to pass legislation at majority rule wherever bipartisan consensus exists while retaining the cloture process for strictly partisan bills. It is even possible that bills would be processed and passed with fewer than 60 votes but only if the bills are bipartisan.
In short, our plan encourages Senators to run to our common ground, rather than their own corners.
I believe that this transformation is urgently needed and would be extremely helpful to this institution. I can tell you, it would boost morale of Senators in power committees once again.
A second possible objection is a fundamental belief the Senate does not need to change its rules; it only needs to change its behavior. As a literal matter, this might be true, but color me skeptical of that idea.
If the minority rarely filibustered and requiring cloture was the exception not the rule, if the majority regularly allows the substantive amendments to get votes regardless of the outcome, we could theoretically debate and have up-or-down votes on more legislation without change to the rules.
But let's be honest. It is extremely unlikely that a sufficient number of Senators in the majority and the minority will come together and, through a change of behavior alone, restore regular order and halt the Senate's institutional decline.
No, I am persuaded by my now nearly 12 years in the Senate that our rules and practices have contributed to the deteriorating culture of this body. They are far from the cause and are arguably more of a symptom of the broader political dynamics rather than a cause. But they do make it too easy to obstruct and too hard for good-faith bipartisan work to get to the Senate floor.
I mentioned that most of the reforms adopted in 2013 did not work, and I recognize it is possible that my plan with Senator Merkley might also prove inadequate in achieving its goals. I also agree with what Burdette said in his 1940 book on filibustering. He wrote:
The solution, whatever it is, will never be found to lie wholly in a set of rules. It must rely, in part, on the election of legislators with a keen sense of public responsibility--men, [women], who will never allow political strife to thwart a need for action.
So, yes, the solution does rely in part on behavior. It cannot be solved by rules alone. But I believe changing the rules are absolutely essential. They can influence behavior. They can incentivize true deliberation and foster bipartisan policymaking. They can empower the rules. They must be strong, and above all, they must be used once adopted.
This again is the balance that Senator Merkley and I have sought to strike.
Another potential objection to our proposed fast-track tools is the assertion that the Senate was not made to move quickly. Here again, I generally agree. As discussed at length, the Framers established the Senate to guard against and defeat improper legislation that the House has perhaps passed in haste.
But under our plan for bipartisan measures, we insist on full committee review before a bill can come to the floor. Committees would seek input from Members on the front end of creating legislation, hold legislative hearings, then hold a markup where on-committee Members could seek improvements, and then the committee would seek and need to pass the bill with strong bipartisan support before it can be eligible for fast-track procedures on the Senate floor.
Bills that come to the floor on a rule XIV, which waives committee consideration, would be ineligible for these fast-track procedures.
So I think our plan ensures meaningful deliberation both at the committee level and on the floor. Every Member would have a chance to modify or vote to defeat a bill.
So in summary, while the Senate was not designed to act in haste, it was designed to function. And our plan will improve the workflow of the Senate while also restoring deliberation.
The final potential concern that I will address today is that bipartisan initiatives, however noble in motivation and design, should not be encouraged over party-line bills on the same topic that contain better policies.
I must say that I am somewhat sympathetic to this concern. After all, the Framers designed the Senate to ensure the support from both large and small populated states is needed to pass a bill, not support from a mix of Federalists and anti-Federalists, or in today's context, Republicans and Democrats. But here again, I think it would be misguided to ignore the realities of today's political climate. There is typically a clear party-line divide on high-profile contentious issues. We should be careful to avoid seeing the Senate pass major reforms on a partisan basis which then can shift sharply in a different direction a few years later.
At the same time, Members across the aisle are drawn to work together on many other issues because they fundamentally share a concern about the status quo and agree on how to address it.
In fact, every committee I have served on as Senator has produced bipartisan proposals on weighty issues, and nearly half of my own bills have had bipartisan cosponsorships. I am not just talking about naming post offices. I am talking about tax, healthcare, energy, environment, commerce, banking, and foreign affairs. The list goes on. I have seen Republicans and Democrats create a stronger product through their partnership and the exchange of ideas.
My proposal with Senator Merkley rewards such bipartisan work. It will help bring the best out of the Senate without forcing Senators to compromise their values and principles. It is a set of proposals that will encourage bipartisanship in both unified government, when partisan policymaking is most tempting, as well as in divided government.
We, of course, will be a divided government for at least the next 2 years, and Senator Merkley and I are convinced these reforms could help the Senate function better and will lead in solving our Nation's pressing challenges for the good of the American people.
Bipartisan policymaking will not just be preferable; it will be mandatory if you want to get something done here.
I offer no conjecture on whether Senator Mansfield or Senator Byrd or Senator Hatch would support each of these bipartisan proposals that Senator Merkley and I have put forward, though I think it is quite plausible they would.
But based on their clear misgivings about the pervasive abuse of the filibuster, I am near certain that they would recognize the Senate has increasingly diminished and that the previous reforms have failed to restore this institution as a deliberative body rather than simply an obstructionist body. And I am near certain that they would want Members who are now privileged to hold this office to do everything in their power in a bipartisan way to get the Senate working again for the American people. And that is what Senator Merkley and I are seeking to do with these bold yet reasonable proposals.
I urge my colleagues to closely review these proposals. I look forward to continuing conversation with them over the next month. And for the good of this great country, I hope all Senators--Republicans and Democrats, Independents alike--can come together to save the Senate, halt its decline, restore its prestige and its effectiveness.
Change is once again in the air, and now is the time to act.
I yield the floor.
The senior assistant legislative clerk proceeded to call the roll.
Alex Padilla (D-CA)
Mr. President, 2 weeks ago, the American people made history. An estimated 124 million Americans voted in this year's midterm elections, the second highest turnout rate for a midterm in more than a century. Now, a new generation of leaders who better reflect the diversity and promise of our Nation are headed to Washington, DC, and to State capitals across the country.
California, my home State, elected its first Latino Governor. The State of Georgia elected the first Black woman as Governor. The State of Texas will have its first Latina Governor. The State of New Mexico will have its first Native American woman Governor. And here in this Chamber, we are about to welcome the first Muslim U.S. Senator, the first Black Senator from the State of Mississippi since 1881, and the first Native American woman to serve in the U.S. Senate--all historic victories made possible by the American people, who showed up and exercised their right to vote.
Now, for months, I predicted that voters would hold this administration accountable. This historic turnout rate was certainly inspired by the conditions that the American people are living in. Voters sought to hold this administration accountable for economic policies that are making life increasingly unaffordable; for the corruption, the self-dealing, and the relentless attacks on our institutions; for a reckless, unauthorized, and costly war with Iran; and for a cruel mass deportation campaign that has terrorized communities and taken the lives of both immigrants and U.S. citizens alike.
Two weeks ago, that is exactly what voters did, and the message they sent could not be any louder and could not be any clearer. The people want an end to the chaos, an end to the corruption, and an end to the cruelty. They want affordability; they want accountability; and, above all, they want a government that works for them, not against them.
I know Democrats have heard this message loud and clear, and we intend to deliver. But before looking too far ahead, before we start debating about what the next Congress will prioritize and take action on, it is important that we acknowledge and reflect on what it took for Americans to make their voices heard this year--because if there is a fundamental lesson to take from these midterm elections, it is that our democracy is not self-executing. It depends on Americans showing up to defend it, on election officials ensuring that every eligible vote is counted, and on people willing to stand up when the right to vote is threatened.
So let's be clear. These midterms were under threat from the very beginning of this Trump administration. Donald Trump and his MAGA allies spent nearly 2 years using the power of the Presidency to undermine confidence in our elections and seeking to make it harder for the American people to vote. They spread baseless lies about election integrity. They threatened to deploy Federal law enforcement and troops to polling locations. They attacked mail-in voting and pressured States to turn over confidential voter rolls. They gutted the Voting Rights Act and pushed aggressive racial and partisan gerrymandering in an attempt to hold on to power.
And when States like California stood up to Trump, Trump's Justice Department filed lawsuits seeking to throw out ballots from eligible voters based on unreliable data. But Americans saw right through it, and they refused to be deterred by this administration's attacks. Eligible Americans registered to vote, and then they voted. They voted early. They voted by mail. They returned their ballots to drop boxes. And they made their voices heard in record numbers.
As one of President Trump's own advisers told CNN, the election was "essentially too big to rig." Too many Americans showed up. Too many people made their voices heard. The margin of victory was so big, any attempt to slow down the count, throw out ballots, try to twist the rules to try to eke out some victories when they were losing wasn't going to happen.
And the record number of people who turned out weren't alone. An unprecedented coalition of civil society organizations, voting rights groups, and State and local election officials pushed back on the administration's attempts to interfere. And Democrats on the Rules Committee, together with Leader Schumer's election protection task force--and I want to give Leader Schumer the credit he deserves for convening this task force and investing in it--also helped to create the Senate's first election observer program.
We trained more than 100 Senate staff in election law and procedure and deployed more than 60 staff members to more than a dozen States to monitor polling places, the vote counting, and canvassing process--it was important to oversee to ensure accountability.
And for the staff that served and for the staff of the Rules Committee who developed and successfully implemented this program, thank you--thank you, thank you--for your service. And thank you to all the members of the broad coalition that came together to defend our democracy and our access to the ballot. Your efforts made a difference. Voter suppression Executive orders were stopped. Courts rejected the Justice Department's attempts to obtain State voter roll data 28 times. The States of California and Washington courts blocked the administration's efforts to interfere with the counting of eligible, lawful ballots.
Now, these victories sound like common sense, but these victories matter. They show what is possible when people stand together to defend our democracy. But the fight is far from over.
One election may be behind us, but the next election is less than 2 years away, and there are still too many barriers keeping too many eligible Americans from being able to vote--like the backlog of 600,000 voter registration applications that the State of Texas failed to process on a timely basis; the voters in Tarrant County, TX, for example, who waited in line for hours after officials slashed a third of the polling places in that county--that is unacceptable--and the young voters in North Carolina, who marched for miles along highways to cast ballots because early voting locations at historically Black colleges were closed.
Thousands of voters were purged in Mississippi, based on unreliable credit agency address data leading to a surge in affidavits, otherwise known as provisional ballots--two-thirds of which were rejected just in Hinds County alone.
We need to shore up our elections by giving State and local officials the resources they need to run secure and accessible and efficient elections.
And we need to ensure every eligible Americans' access to the ballot box by expanding automatic voter registration and vote-by-mail and preventing eligible voters from being wrongly purged from the voter rolls. There are plenty of States across the country--not just California, where I believe we have the gold standard--that have implemented these policies, these new laws, the best practices, if you will, to maintain safe and secure elections and making sure they are free and fair by modernizing elections and giving voters more opportunities to be able to participate in our democracy. It is so fundamental.
We also need fair redistricting, and we need to get big money out of politics and permanently put our elections back in the hands of the people by overturning the Citizens United decision.
That is the unfinished work of this democracy that still remains ahead of us. And if I have the privilege of serving as chair of the Rules Committee in the next Congress, that is the kind of work that I look forward to taking on.
The American people delivered resounding results and historic firsts of this year's election because they were sending a message. With the sanctity of our elections threatened and so much on the line for working families, the American people showed up in record numbers to demand change. They demanded accountability from an administration that tried to undermine the right to vote, tried to keep the American people from having their voices heard, the same administration that has put its own interest ahead of theirs. The people demanded an end to the chaos and the corruption that have gripped our country these last 2 years, and they demanded a government that makes life more affordable and gives working families a fair shot at a better future.
So with the election now behind us, we can say the American people have done their part, and now it is time for us to do ours.
I yield the floor.
Text printed in the Record (92 characters)
To know even one life has breathed easier because you have lived, this is to have succeeded.
Text printed in the Record (104 characters)
We must use our lives to make the world a better place . . . That is what we were put on this earth for.
Text printed in the Record (10 characters)
eSi puede!
The senior assistant bill clerk proceeded to call the roll.
Maria Cantwell (D-WA)
Mr. President, I come to follow my colleague from California Senator Padilla and to thank him for organizing this discussion this afternoon but really to thank him for organizing really last years' importance of voting rights and protecting our voting rights in the United States of America.
His strong leadership has been a key to helping us defend our voting rights. As a former election officer in our Nation's largest State, he had deep experience. He knew a lot about election administration, and he knew a lot about voting rights. So our efforts, led by him--by Senator Padilla--I think, brought a lot of very smart communication to the American people and, for that, I thank him.
Together, we worked hard to try to respond to what were very disruptive actions by President Trump and his administration. We wanted to protect secure, free, and fair elections, but it seemed like every other day the White House was saying something else.
Article 1, section 4 of the Constitution gives the States the primary responsibility for administrating elections and Congress a secondary role. The President has no role.
That is the key thing here: The President has no role. And yet the President and his administration undertook a number of efforts to try to basically control aspects of the election, and he also sought to undermine public confidence in our States' administration of those elections.
So here we are now at the end, almost, of that election season. We have one more Senate election to be confirmed by the State of Alaska. But we have made it through that process again with a lot of confidence in the system, a lot of confidence by the American people, a lot of confidence by organizations like the League of Women Voters--not to say that there aren't issues or problems that arose, but in general, the notion that States run elections and we continue to fight for those rights and protect them is critically important.
And so I join the Senator from California--again, thank him for his leadership, but join him in bringing attention to the fact that a lot of work went into that.
Now, in the State of Washington, I joined my secretary of state; the NAACP; as I said, the League of Women Voters. We had a lot of press conferences because people started to say that they weren't going to be able to have their votes cast and counted appropriately if they voted by mail. In fact, there was a huge example of people just pounding every day in the administration about the vote-by-mail system.
Now, vote-by-mail, I think, has increased voter participation in the State of Washington. It has brought a lot of opportunities for voters to understand the issues, a lot of opportunities for them to get their voter pamphlet maybe 2\1/2\, 3 weeks before the election, sit with that voter pamphlet, and then cast their ballot.
But what they didn't want to see is the U.S. Postal Service changing the postmark practices and requirements, as was done, and literally--literally--making sure that people's ballots did not count in the primaries in our State.
So we, with the secretary of state and others, went on a major drive to educate the people that they had to vote early, that reaching a regional processing center might delay their votes and not get cast.
In September, Secretary of State Hobbs and I released a snapshot report showing that late-postmark rejection rates more than doubled in 19 Washington counties compared to 2024 primaries, following adoption of this new policy which delayed postmarking of mail-in ballots for several days.
And rural counties saw the most negative impacts during our State's February 2026 special election. Seventy-five percent of the total rejected ballots were due to late postmarks.
The people in the United States of America who vote by mail should have their ballots counted. They should not be sent to some regional center without a postmark and then held and never delivered to the auditors and individual counties.
And so that is why, in this election, you saw many Washingtonians basically putting their ballots in a ballot box instead, close to their homes, making sure some postmark or some process by the U.S. Postal System wouldn't delay them.
We also prepared and showed the perspectives of Members of Congress by filing an amicus brief and litigation defending our elections.
In one case, the Republican National Committee threatened election administration practices of States like Washington that permit mail ballots that were postmarked by election day to be counted when they are received within a certain number of days of the election.
I joined with Members, our Senate colleagues, in filing the amicus brief with the Supreme Court, and in June, the Court agreed with our position and ruled that States have the right to set those rules for counting ballots and when they are received. The Supreme Court ruling affirmed both a key element of by-mail voting and the constitutional authority of States to administer those elections.
I can't tell you how important it is for people to have faith in the decisions we make and, once the votes are counted, that we move forward. That is what people want to see. And so they want to know that there was a high level of participation, and they want to know that America has spoken. And that is why we move forward.
And again, that is why there is no role for the executive branch in the administration of elections.
Fortunately, in spite of President Trump and the administration's efforts to disrupt the elections with lawsuits or false narratives or changes to the Postal Service, we did have a free and fair and secure election.
For this, I am grateful for the efforts of bipartisan and nonpartisan State election officials across the country who once again assured this outcome.
I want to say to the people here tonight, this wasn't a light subject for the State of Washington because 2 years before that, somebody actually blew up ballot boxes with a very sophisticated chemical, destroying ballots in a closely monitored congressional election.
So for us, that local auditor took that threat very seriously, called out the county sheriff and others to guard and make sure that ballot boxes were safe. And in this election, we saw none of that.
So I am especially grateful for the many poll workers, the volunteers who give of their time and their effort in making sure that election days go smoothly.
And it is also important to remember all of the people who can't, as I said, in my State get to a polling place and yet have this great opportunity to cast a ballot through the mail and through a ballot box.
So I want to continue to work on these important issues--those that give people the confidence that their vote does matter--to show that the higher the turnout and participation, the better. It says that our voting system is working well.
And I am glad to cosponsor bipartisan legislation with Senators Scott and Lisa Blunt Rochester, reauthorizing the African American Civil Rights Network, a National Park Service program that connects 130 historical sites related to the Civil Rights Movement, a long-time effort and site central to fighting for the right to vote. And I hope that we will pass this legislation soon here in the U.S. Senate.
So, Mr. President, again, I think that as we look ahead to our work in the next Congress, the fight may not be over. We need to restore and strengthen our laws to make sure we are protecting the voter rights of all Americans. But the goal remains the same: to ensure that Americans can freely exercise their precious, precious right to vote.
We did get through this election cycle, and we have to learn the lessons of trying to undermine it and, instead, fight hard to strengthen it.
I yield the floor.
So the purpose of this is to follow what people in my State want, and what they don't want is they don't want people to have these jobs and then come back and lobby people.
So, unfortunately, my colleague is leaving, but I look forward to trying to work with my colleague and others to try to have a bill that, you know, stops this revolving door of people coming to the Senate, coming to the Congress, and then immediately leave and become lobbyists.
I yield the floor.
Kevin Cramer (R-ND)
Mr. President, one of Cramer's convictions is that not every transaction requires a loser.
Too often in this town, however, our success is measured by how badly we defeat our competitors rather than how much we produce for our constituents. What it is we actually deliver, not defeat, should be the standard.
One of the best opportunities that I have seen in my 14 years in Congress for us to actually deliver something significant to our constituents is well within our reach. It is right in front of us. And that, of course, is permitting reform.
For decades, the process of approving the building of the infrastructure necessary to meet the demands of a growing and dynamic economy have been mired in partisan politics and an out-of-control bureaucracy, which limits our Nation's potential, our prosperity, and stifles our global competitiveness.
The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act is an opportunity for us to turn that corner, and it is imperative that we do it now while the window is open.
Whether it is transmission lines to load centers, pipelines to refineries, steel mills and drone factories, or family housing, we must secure durable changes to the Federal permitting process or continue to fall behind our global competitors.
We must make it easier to build in America. China, for example, dominates global manufacturing, particularly in those industries that are indispensable to our national defense. For example, China's steel production exceeds ours by roughly--get this now--12 to 1. In shipbuilding, China possesses capacity roughly 230 times that of the United States. Let me say that again. With regard to shipbuilding--very important to our economy, obviously, and important to our national defense--China possesses capacity roughly 230 times that of the United States. A single major Chinese shipyard can exceed the total output of the entire U.S. commercial shipbuilding industry.
Regarding infrastructure, well, a recent report put out by McKinsey & Company paints a stark--very stark--picture full of opportunities. McKinsey's report on the economic impact of Federal permitting delays highlights the massive scale of capital and economic activity that is stalled in the United States "permitting pipeline," if you excuse the expression.
According to McKinsey's report, U.S. Federal permitting holds, get this now, $1.8 trillion--with a "t"--$1.8 trillion in infrastructure projects, and better than that, $1.1 trillion of it is private sector money.
In my State of North Dakota, $24 billion sits on the sidelines while the bureaucracy holds development hostage.
These delays represent over $3 trillion in cumulative unrealized economic activity.
The priority sectors account for roughly 40 percent of total construction spend--$899 billion, actually, out of $2.17 trillion--led by manufacturing, $330 billion; transportation, $215 billion; oil and gas extraction, $114 billion; broadband and telecom, another $101 billion; electricity generation, $63 billion; electric transmission--we are going to talk a lot about that--$38 billion; and mining and oil-gas pipelines, $19 billion each.
Absolute investment delays, according to McKinsey, are concentrated in large States for sure, like Texas, California, Florida, and New York, while relative economic exposure peaks in States like Wyoming, Alaska, North Dakota, New Mexico, and West Virginia.
Permitting delays, in addition to all of that, trigger roughly 5 percent annual cost increases. So delays cost money, they reduce income availability, and they actually drive prices up.
But the good news--the good news--is that we are on the brink of reversing those negatives and using the opportunities to put Americans to work building things right here--building things right here in the United States. This bill is an opportunity to create winners all around. Both sides of the proverbial political aisle are tired of the regulatory whiplash from one administration to the next.
Another one of Cramer's convictions is that nothing brings people together like a common adversary.
Earlier this year, the Environment and Public Works Committee held a hearing on permitting reform. We had excellent technical witnesses--I think it was about five of them--with great knowledge and great experience they were bringing to the discussion.
Ironically or perhaps not so ironically, it was the Senators who did most of the talking, taking turns sharing their grievances about how Presidents of the opposing political party were blocking their State's projects--in many cases after the projects were permitted and in some, actually completed. In some cases, it was a wind or solar project; in others, it was a pipeline or a liquid natural gas terminal.
I leaned over to ranking member Senator Whitehouse, and I said: Sheldon, we should just stipulate that we don't like Presidents from the other party who kill our projects.
But remember, nothing brings people together like a common adversary.
The Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act--or BAAJA, as we like to call it--hits that nail right on the head. It is the kind of bill where everyone across the political spectrum gets enough of what they want. They may not get everything they want, but they get enough to claim victory--no losers.
I believe the most consequential parts of BAAJA deal with judicial reforms. Challenges to the National Environmental Policy Act--a.k.a. NEPA--Clean Water Act, and the National Historic Preservation Act must be filed within 150 days rather than the 6-year window they are now. That is what our bill does. It takes 6 years and turns it into 150 days--6 years down to 150 days.
Think about that for a minute. A project can be built and operational. Yet, as of now, a litigant can file years later and throw that road, bridge, pipeline, or transmission line into doubt. We have experienced that phenomenon in North Dakota.
Also under our bill, legal challenges can only come from those who raised the issue during the comment period and then--get this--can actually show direct harm. Did you know that before, they didn't have to show harm? They could just--anybody could sue. In other words, law firms cannot simply create a cottage industry exploiting would-be victims because their feelings are hurt.
If a court finds a problem, the Agency needs to fix it within 180 days rather than just being forced to just vacate and start the whole project over, as is often the case when activist and activist judges look to block the projects. In other words, to try to throw a legal wrench in the process, someone must have skin in the game.
NEPA has been weaponized for decades by extreme activists who simply want to obstruct projects. NEPA is a procedural statute, according to the Supreme Court, not substantive. It is designed to make sure Agencies consider all of the options before green-lighting a project. On average, this process takes roughly 4 years and often much, much longer than that--twice as long as that or more. That will stop under this bill. It gets back to the intent of NEPA--to consider informed alternatives and green-light the best, most workable option. We are going to get back to building, not balking.
Analysis from the Council of Economic Advisers found that reducing NEPA environmental impact statement review times to 2 years from that 4 to 8 to 10 actually increases annual tax revenue by $14 billion to $28 billion--increases the revenue to the coffers of the government simply by bringing the review time down to 2 years--and it increases real wages by $306 to $637 per year for the average household, OK? So it increases tax revenue, increases wages, and reduces electricity bills by $178 to $251 per year for the average household. Wow. It gets better. More revenue for the government, higher wages for the worker, and lower electricity bills for the consumer. And we often say around here that energy security is national security, and this legislation certainly helps secure North Dakota energy production and energy production in every State.
I submit to you that permitting reform is also essential for our national security. As a nation, we cannot build and we cannot produce at the rates necessary to counter adversaries like China, which builds three times as fast as we do at a fraction of the cost.
Now, I wouldn't trade governments with China for anything. The COVID pandemic highlighted the risks, however, within our supply chains. We need to mine our own rare earth and critical minerals where we have them and onshore our pharmaceutical production where we may not have the ingredients.
Our defense industrial base must be able to grow at a speed necessary to deter our adversaries and allow us, the United States, to prevail should we end up in a major conflict. These are no-fail missions over which we can never allow ourselves to be held hostage by an outsized bureaucracy.
Now, this bill nearly perfectly encapsulates what it takes to negotiate a true bipartisan product. It is a balance. It has balance.
Take electric transmission for example. Given my experience as a former utility regulator, I have advocated for caution and even blocked previous attempts to overhaul electricity policy. Is the transaction section what I would have written if I were the King? It is not. But I am not the King. But the bill is an improvement over prior versions, and it strikes enough of a balance for me to get behind it given all of the other provisions particularly of the bill.
The vast majority of this body has rallied around this bill because it provides certainty for everyone. Oil producers in North Dakota and Alaska and offshore wind projects in Rhode Island will benefit just as much as manufacturers and roads and bridges from coast to coast.
(Mr. HUSTED assumed the Chair.)
Kevin Cramer (R-ND)
Achieving true balance is undeniably elusive. In fact, it is darn rare, even in the Senate, where we depend on consensus. Achieving true balance, though, should be the goal. Finding balance at the right time, however, is even harder. We have an open window to pass this generational legislation to empower the people who make things in America, but the window will close soon, to likely not open again for a very long time, if ever.
Further evidence of the policy balance that this bill strikes is the breadth of support that only a truly bipartisan bill could enjoy. It is supported by investor-owned utilities, rural electric cooperatives, the White House, renewable energy groups, oil and gas producers, manufacturers, labor organizations, miners, farm groups, and many, many more. In fact, the diverse coalition of people lined up behind this bill is proof enough of the major work that has been done to reach this consensus.
By the way, consensus is not just gravitating to the lowest common denominator and claiming immunity. No. The policy victories claimed by all sides in this incredible work product demonstrate deep convictions, even some redlines that could not be crossed, but it also includes some low-hanging fruit and some really hard-to-reach compromise. It involved fits and starts, moments when it would have been easier to simply throw up your hands and walk away. It involved late nights for staffers whose names you may never hear or know and meetings with allies right after the meeting with negotiators and back to the allies and the usual back-and-forth in a negotiating process, helping stakeholders feel comfortable with the progress and the process.
It took uncommon leadership, and I am grateful. I am grateful for my colleagues who worked tirelessly, mostly cheerfully, for the last year to get us to this point.
Most importantly, thank you, Environment and Public Works chair Shelley Moore Capito and ranking member Sheldon Whitehouse.
I said to both of them this morning that they might be the only two Senators who tolerate each other. Because they have been through this, they are better partners than ever.
Thank you, Energy and National Resources chair Mike Lee and ranking member Martin Heinrich, for hanging in there.
Guys, I am telling you, I know this stuff. The nerdy stuff these two had to work through would cause lesser people to throw in the towel. The work of these four leaders and a host of others is what results in a law that is as durable as it is balanced. And what is the point of making laws that aren't durable?
A special thank-you also goes to the President's team at the White House. President Trump and his Energy Dominance Council are on board with a bill that, frankly, defers a significant amount of Executive power. Presidents don't give that up easily. But their constructive engagement is greatly appreciated.
So now lets get the job done. Lets pass the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, send it to the House with a lot of momentum, restore certainty in the Federal permitting process, and build and produce in America as though our country depends on it because today, our country depends on us.
I yield the floor.
Lisa Murkowski (R-AK)
Mr. President, I am pleased to be able to follow my colleague from North Dakota in speaking about the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, BAAJA.
You used the word "balance" there, and I think that is important for us all to be concentrating on because, as you have noted, this is probably not a bill that the Senator from North Dakota would have written on his own, nor the bill that the Senator from Alaska would have written on her own or that the chairman of the Energy Committee or the chairman of EPW or the ranking members would have written on their own. But what we are doing here, folks, is we are legislating. My goodness, it is kind of good. It is kind of good.
So it feels good to be able to be on the floor and talk about where we are because I think this is the most substantive bipartisan agreement on permitting reform that we have reached since I have been serving here in the Senate now, and that really is a credit to its sponsors. I am going to come back to them shortly.
But I think the reason that BAAJA is the most important bill for us to enact before the end of the year is because of just the focus that we have been through with this recent campaign. The people in this country are focused on affordability. They want solid growth, and they want good government. And I think this is what this bill provides for us.
There is a lot of debate and dissension that goes on on this floor, but there is one thing that most Members of Congress would agree upon, and that is that our Federal permitting system is broken. It is really troubled. No matter what you want to do, where you plan to do it, your project is at a major disadvantage if you need to acquire a Federal permit. That is bottom line. That is because Federal permitting has evolved--or perhaps devolved--into something it was never meant to be. It is no longer a fair or a predictable process. It is this gauntlet, this series of gauntlets. It takes way too long. It costs way too much. And the Senator from North Dakota I think outlined that well--the cost of delay and what that means to us, to our communities, to our economies.
But also it leads to litigation inevitably, it seems, and that, too, adds to the cost. So even if your project survives all of this, your approvals can still be reopened and rejected on political grounds and sometimes years after the fact. When this happens, we don't need--we should not fool ourselves here. It is not like we are protecting the environment when we do this. What happens then is we end up outsourcing really important projects and all the benefits that they would provide to nations that have lower standards or perhaps no standards at all. That is worse for us, and it is worse for the environment.
I come from a State that has seen firsthand in living colors the harms that come with a broken permitting process. Yet you can't do much in Alaska without a Federal permit. That is our reality. And our experience in trying to obtain these permits is usually just pretty awful. There are probably better descriptives, but bottom line: It is pretty awful.
Just about every project that enters Federal permitting winds up being delayed and, again, costing more, and just about every project that eventually makes it through the process still winds up in court.
I will give a couple examples here. In the late 2000s, it took years to convince the Obama administration to let us build a bridge. It was a simple bridge. We were trying to allow for a petroleum project to advance within our National Petroleum Reserve. This is an area that is designated and leased for petroleum production. And this permit was not for the project itself; it was just for the bridge to help facilitate it. And it took years--years.
In Southeast Alaska, the permitting process for a gold mine down there started in the 1990s. It continued into the early 2010s. So you are talking now several decades. The agencies developed one set of environmental documents, and they were requested to do another set, and then they faced last-second legal challenges. Ultimately, it went all the way up to the U.S. Supreme Court.
Another example: Back in 1980, Congress passed a law guaranteeing that Alaskans would be allowed to construct a roughly 211-mile industrial road. This was in order to access a world-class mining district. Now, there are about 19 miles of this 211 miles of proposed road--19 miles that would have to go through Federal land, through BLM lands, and that has been the holdup here. The project entered Federal permitting back in 2016. After being approved in 2020, it was then voluntarily remanded by the last administration, and then it was reopened and then rejected, even though the law says--the law guarantees--that level of access.
So here we are a full decade later--in 2027--and you should legitimately ask the question: Well, did you build the road? And I can tell you: No, not even a mile. It is still in permitting.
We have also got a 15-mile stretch of highway--this is an important part of our State. It accesses our peninsula area. There is great fishing down there. We have been trying to make this road corridor safer now for years. We have been in the permitting process off and on for more than 40 years. I am looking at the young pages down here on the floor. Like twice your life we having been trying to get this 15-mile stretch worked through so we can avoid collisions and disasters on the road. We are only now getting through with it, so it has been a generational thing.
But permitting reform is critical for us in Alaska. It is critical throughout our country. But I look to what we have in my State. We have tens of billions of dollars' worth of projects that are underway. This is everything from oil and gas to clean coal, to renewables, to mining, to transportation. And we are a State that still lacks a lot of basic infrastructure, right, so we need these projects to help advance our State so that Alaskans can have some good jobs, have a higher standard of living, a sustainable economy. But when everything seems to hinge on Federal permits that are difficult, if not sometimes almost impossible, it really makes it hard.
So to be here at this juncture where we are talking about how we can finally advance BAAJA, again, I feel so gratified for those who have worked so hard. I want to commend the sponsors; Senators Lee and Senator Heinrich from the Energy and Natural Resources Committee; Senator Capito--Chairman Capito; Senator Whitehouse from EPW; all their committee folks. They have done great work, and they all deserve strong credit. But they really have worked together.
And they haven't done it by themselves. They brought us in. My colleague from Oklahoma who just recently arrived to the Senate this year has been all in, laser focused on permitting reform, permitting reform, permitting reform. So it is going to be so good to have the input that he has given to us. But it has been so many that have been engaged.
And as the Senator from North Dakota commented, this is not an easy subject to legislate on. It is hard to get this right at a substantive level, and it is even harder to navigate politically. We have been close to bipartisan success in the past. We had a really great effort with Senator Manchin and Senator Barrasso with their Energy Permitting Reform Act of 2024. They got so close but then fell short, which was disappointing.
But I think what you saw with the leadership of these four Senators was they didn't give up on that. They built on what they had inherited. They designed a bill that goes even further and, I think, really is the best one that we have seen on Federal permitting reform and why we need to get it enacted into law. This is our chance.
This is our chance to reform NEPA, to address the Endangered Species Act, the Clean Water Act--a lot of statutes that we are talking about here. But this is our chance to put firm deadlines on agency decisions, to give that clarity, to provide for clear limits on judicial review. It is our chance to put an end to many of the games and, quite honestly, some of the abuses that take place within a Federal permitting process.
There is a lot to like in BAAJA. And the Senators who worked to build this, I think they really took great pains to ensure that they were listening to other Members and listening to their priorities. I have several that they have incorporated as they relate to hydropower and geothermal. I have my FLOWS Act in there. But I am also very, very pleased that BAAJA includes bipartisan legislation that my vice chairman on the Indian Affairs Committee, Senator Schatz, and I introduced to reduce permitting barriers on Tribal lands and support Tribal economic development.
And I really want to thank the sponsors for working directly with me and my team on the Indian Affairs team. And I know, with my vice chair, that the bill, when it was introduced in September, it caught many a little bit--let's just say--off guard with a title that was contained in it that related to the National Historic Preservation Act.
And shortly after the text was released, I started to hear from Tribes, Tribal organizations. They were calling me from around Alaska and, really, from around the country, weighing in. They objected to the reforms that had been incorporated in the bill that related to the National Historic Preservation Act, NHPA.
But NHPA provides a really important process for the identification and the protection of sacred sites. These can include burial grounds, places of traditional religious and cultural importance to Tribes. But it also provides for this definition of what we call an undertaking. When a project involves a Federal action or approval, that is known as a Federal undertaking. And so we saw, we heard, from folks and looked very carefully at the text. And I agreed with them. I agreed. I think that NHPA needs to be modernized, but we also must--must--take Tribes' concerns very carefully and seriously to ensure that permitting reform does not come at the expense of meaningful consultation or the protection of properties of traditional religious and cultural importance. And so we all worked together. We worked over a long period of time to make what I think are substantial changes to address those concerns.
My team and I on the Indian Affairs Committee really get how important section 106 is to making sure that we get these projects right. In Alaska and across the country, Tribes and Federal Agencies have successfully used this process, again, to protect sacred sites, to minimize the impacts on culturally significant places, while still allowing projects to move forward.
So if you are working together, this can happen. You can still provide for the necessary and the very important protections while still allowing for that important project, whether it be a road or a transmission line or just whatever the project may be.
So this has been a really key effort in my State to address this. We have so many places of deep cultural and religious importance to Tribes that are located on lands that the Tribes no longer control. And so what section 106 does is it gives Tribes a voice when Federal projects may affect these sites by requiring agencies to consult with them and then to consider any potential impacts before--before--making the decisions.
And so, again, we heard from the Tribes and the Tribal organizations who weighed in. We asked the bill sponsors to work with us. And Senator Lee and his team were right there. They worked through some initial changes. But we needed to make some important changes to address the concerns that we had heard.
And so let me just talk about some of the changes that we did secure that are either incorporated in the substitute or will be included as part of the managers' amendment when we are able to adopt that.
We removed a restrictive, unworkable definition for Tribal religious and cultural properties. This was really important, to be able to address that.
We have directed the Federal Government to help--not take over but to help--Tribal Historic Preservation Offices. These are the THPOs.
We improved opportunities for Tribes to participate in the identification of these historic properties, including the opportunity to review the findings, to raise substantive objections, and to receive a response--again, before the Federal decision is made. It doesn't help it if they don't get a response until after that decision is made.
We will increase the authorization for the Historic Preservation Fund to $300 million. This is in recognition of the fact that we need to support the Tribes and the Tribal Historic Preservation Offices, the THPOs, alongside the reforms to the review process. And so it was important to address that authorization.
We also addressed the most consequential question in this title, and that is: What qualifies as a Federal undertaking and, therefore, triggers this section 106 review process? So we secured changes to the definition of "undertaking" to preserve a pathway for section 106 review of projects when a Federal Agency exercises predominant control and responsibility over Federal financial assistance for a project's adverse effects on historic properties. So, again, this is particularly important in Alaska, where we have many sites of cultural and religious significance to Tribes that are located on State or private lands and then the Federal financial assistance supports infrastructure projects through the communities. So that was a significant one. We worked a long time, and hard, on that.
We also specifically preserved section 106 review for major Federally assisted transportation projects. These clearly have substantial footprints across our Nation.
So, again, the Senator from North Dakota used the word "balance," and I started my comments off with acknowledging the balance in a bill and whether or not we have achieved perfection. Well, folks, we haven't achieved perfection. And I know that the changes that I have just outlined as they relate to the National Historic Preservation Act may not satisfy and resolve the concerns that have been raised by all of our Tribes, but the concerns that they raised--this is what led us to the substantive revisions of this text. And I truly want to thank those who weighed in with us--the Tribal leaders who sent the letters, who made the calls, who passed the resolutions, who came and met with me and met with my team.
Again, the NHPA title does not have every change that we wanted, but it is significantly better. And so I am hoping that Members on both sides of the aisle, in both Chambers, who have expressed similar concerns, those who have heard from their Tribes in their States and their regions, that they will look carefully at these changes that we have made and recognize what we have done.
So, again, is it a perfect bill? No. None of them are. We can't make that the standard for individual votes. We cannot keep holding out on permitting reform year after year in the hopes that maybe--just maybe--somehow we are going to do it just a little bit better next time with just a little more time. This is it. This is it. This is our best option, not only for now but likely for years to come, for something that should have been done a long, long time ago.
So, in my view, BAAJA is absolutely worth supporting for affordability, for abundance, for jobs, for economic growth, for international competitiveness, and for so much more.
Again, I want to thank Chairman Lee, Chairman Capito, Ranking Member Heinrich, and Ranking Member Whitehouse, and all those who contributed so much to what I think is quite a considerable effort and undertaking and would urge Members support its final passage.
I yield the floor.