Audit Review Finds Control Gaps

Summary#

The Audit Committee accepted Calgary’s annual review of internal financial controls for the corporate record. It also kept a confidential attachment and the closed-meeting discussions confidential, with a review set for January 1, 2027.

  • City staff tested controls across 11 processes for the 2025 year-end. They found 86% of the key controls tested were operating effectively, with nine minor and two significant deficiencies.
  • Staff are working to fix two significant deficiencies; one significant deficiency has been fully fixed.
  • The committee’s decision was carried unanimously, 7 to 0.

What it means for you#

  • Calgary residents: The public report gives information about the City’s financial controls. The confidential attachment contains details about significant deficiencies and management’s plans to address them.
  • City staff: Finance and business-unit staff carry out the assessment alongside their other work. City staff say the work requires significant effort.

Money#

The program uses existing approved operating funding; the report gives no cost amount.

  • City staff say limited staff resources could affect their ability to take part in the assessment alongside other priorities.

What is unclear#

  • The confidential attachment’s details about the deficiencies and management’s plans are not public.
  • The report does not give the program’s total cost or say whether the existing budget will cover any added work if the assessment expands.

Case for#

  • City staff say assessing financial controls supports good governance and can help them improve and monitor processes. The annual assessment also gives the Audit Committee and public more assurance about controls.
  • Testing 11 processes and reporting the results gives the committee information about both effective controls and identified deficiencies, rather than reporting only on problems or successes.

Case against#

  • City staff warn that the largely manual assessment takes significant effort from Finance and business-unit staff. That work could compete with other priorities and limit staff participation.
  • The committee kept details of significant deficiencies and the closed-meeting discussions confidential. That protects information the committee judged confidential, but leaves the public with less detail for assessing the problems and the City’s response.