Zoning change to boost housing fails

Summary#

Calgary City Council rejected a land-use amendment for 1729 – 8 Avenue NE in Mayland, Ward 10. The defeated motion would have changed the 1.09-hectare site from an Industrial – Business district to a Multi-Residential – High Density Low Rise district; the application’s stated goal was to enable more housing.

  • The motion to approve the change was defeated 4 to 10. Councillors McLean, Chabot, Dhaliwal, Kelly, Mayor Farkas, Yule, Pantazopoulos, Ward, Jamieson and Johnston voted against it.
  • The proposed change would have allowed residential development on the site, where two office buildings currently stand. No development permit had been submitted.

What it means for you#

  • Nearby residents: The site was not redesignated for residential use under this decision.
  • The landowner and applicant: This decision did not authorize the proposed residential development. The current land-use district remains in place.
  • Future development: The application described two six-storey buildings as its intended proposal. The land-use decision itself would not have approved building plans, unit numbers, access or parking.

Money#

City staff reported no anticipated financial impact from the proposal; no dollar estimate was provided.

What is unclear#

  • The supplied material does not say whether the landowner will bring forward another application.
  • No development permit had been submitted, so details such as the number of homes, site access and on-site parking were not decided.

Case for#

  • City staff said the change would support housing supply and choice in an established community, and make more efficient use of existing infrastructure, amenities and transit.
  • The report summarized eight letters supporting the change. They cited possible new amenities, better connectivity and the opportunity to add residents to an inner-city area.

Case against#

  • The report summarized 35 letters opposing the change. Concerns included building scale, traffic and pedestrian safety on 8 Avenue NE, parking on Mariposa Drive NE, loss of sunlight and pressure on schools, utilities, roads and parks.
  • The final motion to approve was defeated 4 to 10, with the ten councillors listed above voting against it.

Votes

3 recorded votes on this bill, newest first.

  1. Division No. 481016

    Defeated13 members voted

    Public Hearing Meeting of Council, item 7.2.16 (Land Use Amendment in Mayland (Ward 10) at 1729 - 8 Avenue NE, LOC2024-0254, CPC2025-0906): That with respect to Report CPC2025-0906, the following be adopted: That Council give three readings to Proposed Bylaw 179D2025 for the redesignation of 1.09 hectares ± (2.70 acres ±) located at 1729 – 8 Avenue NE (Plan 1014791, Block 1, Lot 1) from Industrial – Business f1.0h12 (I-B f1.0h12) District to Multi-Residential – High Density Low Rise (M-H1) District.

    AGAINST · 9FOR · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    9Against

    • Independent5
    • Communities First3
    • A Better Calgary Party1

    4For

    • Independent4
  2. Division No. 481017

    Passed14 members voted

    Public Hearing Meeting of Council, item 7.2.16 (Land Use Amendment in Mayland (Ward 10) at 1729 - 8 Avenue NE, LOC2024-0254, CPC2025-0906): That Council reconsider the vote with respect to Item 7.2.16, Land Use Amendment in Mayland (Ward 10) at 1729 - 8 Avenue NE, LOC2024-0254, CPC2025-0906.

    FOR · 10AGAINST · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    10For

    • Independent8
    • Communities First1
    • A Better Calgary Party1

    4Against

    • Communities First2
    • The Calgary Party1
    • Independent1
  3. Division No. 481018

    Defeated14 members voted

    Public Hearing Meeting of Council, item 7.2.16 (Land Use Amendment in Mayland (Ward 10) at 1729 - 8 Avenue NE, LOC2024-0254, CPC2025-0906): That with respect to Report CPC2025-0906, the following be adopted: That Council give three readings to Proposed Bylaw 179D2025 for the redesignation of 1.09 hectares ± (2.70 acres ±) located at 1729 – 8 Avenue NE (Plan 1014791, Block 1, Lot 1) from Industrial – Business f1.0h12 (I-B f1.0h12) District to Multi-Residential – High Density Low Rise (M-H1) District.

    AGAINST · 10FOR · 4

    Each dot is one member. Hover or tap one to see who.

    10Against

    • Independent5
    • Communities First3
    • A Better Calgary Party1
    • The Calgary Party1

    4For

    • Independent4