For the Friends of David Law

Summary#

Bill C-231, An Act to amend the Youth Criminal Justice Act, would amend the Youth Criminal Justice Act. It may also be cited as the For the Friends of David Law. Its stated goal is to clarify and expand ways treatment programs can be considered or required in youth justice cases; those changes are proposed, not in force based on the supplied material.

  • Police would have to consider referring a young person to a problematic substance use treatment program, with the young person’s consent, when the young person is alleged to have committed certain drug or cannabis offences.
  • An extrajudicial sanction (a measure used outside court) could require attendance at a problematic substance use treatment program or another treatment program.
  • A youth justice court could delay sentencing after finding a young person guilty so they can attend a treatment program. This would require the consent of both the young person and the Attorney General.
  • Courts would have to consider participation in a treatment program when deciding on a youth sentence. They could also order attendance at an approved non-residential program, within limits of 240 hours over no more than six months.
  • Treatment attendance could be included as a condition in certain orders, including conditional supervision.
  • If Bill C-16 becomes law, a related provision would require prosecutors to consider a treatment referral, with the young person’s consent, for the same specified offences.

What it means for you#

  • Young people accused of the specified offences: Police would have to consider a treatment referral, but the referral would require the young person’s consent. The bill does not require police to make the referral.
  • Young people facing a court sentence or order: A court could delay sentencing for treatment, but only with the young person’s and Attorney General’s consent. Treatment attendance could also be required through some sanctions or orders; the bill does not state a consent condition for those requirements.
  • Police, prosecutors and courts: The bill would add duties or options involving treatment. It does not set up a new treatment service or explain how referrals would work.
  • General public: The bill would not change which conduct is an offence. It would change how treatment may be considered in some youth justice decisions.
  • The supplied text does not include the current Youth Criminal Justice Act. I could not verify which parts of the replacement wording already exist in current law.

Money#

No cost information is in the available material.

  • The bill does not set out funding for treatment programs, or estimate costs for courts, police, prosecutors or provincial directors.
  • The bill does not state whether program attendance would be publicly funded or what a young person might have to pay.
  • If enacted, the main provisions would start 30 days after royal assent. The separate prosecutor provision depends on Bill C-16 receiving royal assent and both relevant provisions being in force.

What is unclear#

  • The bill does not define “problematic substance use treatment program” or “any other treatment program.”
  • It does not set standards for programs, explain who decides which programs qualify, or say whether suitable programs will be available.
  • It does not set out referral procedures, decision timelines, appeals or reporting requirements.
  • The supplied text does not show how the proposed treatment conditions interact with existing rules under the Youth Criminal Justice Act.
  • No publicly available information is supplied about the bill’s passage or whether it is in force.

Case for#

  • The bill appears intended to make treatment a possible response at several stages of a youth justice case, from police contact through sentencing and supervision.
  • A possible argument for the bill is that courts and officials would have more room to consider treatment instead of relying only on other justice measures.
  • Consent is required for the proposed police referral and for delaying sentencing, which limits those two measures.
  • The sentencing order described in the bill would be limited to an approved non-residential program and a maximum of 240 hours over no more than six months.

Case against#

  • The bill does not define the kinds of programs that count or set standards for them. That could leave important decisions to others without clear rules in the bill.
  • Treatment attendance could be required as part of some sanctions or orders, even though the bill does not state that the young person must consent to those conditions.
  • The bill does not provide funding or explain whether treatment will be available when a court or official considers it.
  • The supplied material does not include the current Act, so it is not possible to check how much of the replacement wording changes existing law.
Loading versions…Read this official publication

Summary matches the latest captured text

Summary version: As passed by the House of Commons · 2026-11-16

Last source check:

Read the latest official text

Votes

The recorded vote on this bill, member by member.

  1. Division No. 96

    Passed327 members votedOfficial record

    FOR · 327

    327For

    • Liberal165
    • Conservative134
    • Bloc21
    • NDP6
    • Green1

    0Against

    10 members were paired and sat out the vote. 343 seats in the House.